ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeUmbrella Insurance AgentsOhio › Columbus

Find Umbrella Insurance Agents Near You in Columbus, OH

Browse umbrella insurance agents serving Columbus, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated umbrella insurance agent in Columbus, Ohio is Compare Quote Insurance, rated 5.0 stars across 904 reviews. Other highly rated options include Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent, Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio, Lisa Diemer American Family Insurance. This directory lists 28 umbrella insurance agents serving Columbus.

Showing 28 umbrella insurance agents in Columbus, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Compare Quote Insurance5959 Scarborough Blvd #4500(888) 667-1212
2Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent2140 Riverside Dr ste b(614) 485-9077
3Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio4701 Olentangy River Rd Ste 102(614) 475-3583
4Lisa Diemer American Family Insurance3040 Riverside Dr #209(614) 488-9445
5Solid Insurance986 Morse Rd(614) 854-0000
6Isner Insurance Associates, Inc3695 N High St(614) 236-8691
7Sokol Eisenberg Insurance1620 E Broad St #103(614) 362-4262
8Brown Insurance Company LLC21 E State St #200(614) 324-6980
9Horizon Insurance Services, Inc.3806 N High St(614) 326-0200
10Putnam White Lewis Insurance4161 N High St(614) 267-1269
CQ
5959 Scarborough Blvd #4500
Compare Quote Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Compare Quote Insurance serves the Columbus, Ohio metro area, offering umbrella insurance agent services. This company helps local residents and businesses secure extra liability coverage that kicks in when standard home or auto policies are exhausted. The agency works to assess each client’s unique risk profile, ensuring adequate protection against major claims or lawsuits. It handles policy comparisons for personal umbrella insurance and also assists with commercial umbrella coverage for Columbus-based enterprises.

KR
2140 Riverside Dr ste b
Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent in Columbus, Ohio provides umbrella insurance policies that offer extra liability coverage beyond standard home and auto plans. Service plans focus on helping clients assess their personal risk exposure and adjust coverage limits appropriately, with regular policy review to account for life changes or asset growth. Maintenance plans include annual coverage checkups and claims support to ensure continuous protection. The agency services single-family homes, apartments, retail properties, and restaurants.

AH
4701 Olentangy River Rd Ste 102
Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Homeowners, businesses, and property managers in Columbus, Ohio, rely on this umbrella insurance agent for additional liability coverage beyond standard policy limits. The agency helps clients protect assets and future earnings by offering layered liability protection that activates after underlying home or auto policies are exhausted. Operating throughout the broader Columbus metropolitan area, the agency also serves clients in nearby communities such as Dublin or Westerville.

LD
3040 Riverside Dr #209
Lisa Diemer American Family Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

In Columbus, Ohio, umbrella insurance agents provide policies that offer both one-time protection for immediate liability concerns and recurring coverage to safeguard long-term assets. This specialized insurance extends beyond standard home and auto limits, addressing gaps in coverage where larger claims may arise. As a local agent, Lisa Diemer American Family Insurance assists clients in understanding how these policies can shield against significant financial loss. Service options typically run on a one-time fee basis for initial policy setup, with renewals scheduled annually as needed.

SI
986 Morse Rd
Solid Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Based in Columbus, OH, Solid Insurance serves the city and its surrounding communities. The agency specializes in umbrella insurance, handling policies that provide additional liability coverage beyond standard homeowners and auto limits. This extra layer of protection helps shield clients from major claims and lawsuits. To determine the right level of coverage for a typical job, the agent generally conducts a thorough review of a client’s existing assets, risks, and current policies. It then structures the umbrella policy to coordinate seamlessly with those underlying coverages.

II
3695 N High St
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Isner Insurance Associates, Inc specializes in umbrella insurance policies, offering additional liability coverage that extends beyond standard home and auto limits. Serving the Columbus, Ohio area, the agency helps clients protect their assets by bridging coverage gaps left by underlying policies. This extra layer of protection becomes especially valuable during winter months, when increased risks of slip-and-fall accidents on icy driveways or snowy sidewalks can threaten a homeowner’s financial security.

SE
1620 E Broad St #103
Sokol Eisenberg Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

As Columbus winters thaw and melting snow can create unexpected liability from icy walkways or basement seepage, Sokol Eisenberg Insurance offers umbrella insurance coverage in Columbus, Ohio. This type of policy adds an extra layer of personal liability protection beyond standard home or auto limits. It helps shield assets from large claims or lawsuits. An agent will review a client's current policies and risk factors during an initial consultation to determine appropriate coverage levels.

BI
21 E State St #200
Brown Insurance Company LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Brown Insurance Company LLC provides residential umbrella insurance services in Columbus, Ohio, offering additional liability coverage beyond standard homeowners policies to protect personal assets. The agency also handles commercial umbrella insurance for local businesses seeking extra liability layers against unforeseen claims. Serving the greater Columbus area, they help clients from policy selection through claims support. This agent assists with policy adjustments and annual reviews, ensuring coverage keeps pace with asset changes, with follow-up available between regular visits for updated coverage needs.

HI
3806 N High St
Horizon Insurance Services, Inc.
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Horizon Insurance Services, Inc. in Columbus, Ohio assists clients with general insurance needs while adding umbrella liability coverage for extra asset protection. This specialized policy extends existing liability limits beyond standard home, auto, and watercraft policies. It helps shield policyholders from large claims or lawsuits that exceed underlying coverage. The layers of protection offered by Horizon Insurance Services serve various commercial sectors, including offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

PW
4161 N High St
Putnam White Lewis Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Putnam White Lewis Insurance is an umbrella insurance agent serving clients in Columbus, Ohio, known for providing excess liability coverage that extends beyond standard policy limits. This agency assists homeowners, auto policyholders, and business owners in securing protection against significant financial loss from major claims or lawsuits. Tailored coverage options address personal and commercial exposure within the Columbus area. A specialty service it can add on is coverage for rental property owners or landlords seeking broader liability protection.

BW
1335 Dublin Rd #110-D
Briggs & Williams Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 486-7646
briggswilliamsinsurance.com
TV
2000 W Henderson Rd #340
Town & Village Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 457-6913
townvillageins.com
RG
1554 Polaris Pkwy #325
The Rivera Group Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(740) 513-3181
theriveragroupinsurance.com
DC
1080 Fishinger Rd
Dan Coonfare Agency LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 486-5400
coonfareinsurance.com
GI
1500 W 3rd Ave #300F
Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 915-0977
grandviewinsuranceservice.com
FI
5898 Cleveland Ave
Ferrell Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 899-8867
progressiveagent.com/ferrell-insurance-agency-columbus
AW
3040 Riverside Dr #201
The Al Washington Ins Agy Ltd
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 564-9156
alwashingtoninsurance.com
AI
5659 Emporium Square
AATO Insurance Agency LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 918-9803
aatoinsurance.com
OH
1600 W Lane Ave #200
Overmyer Hall Associates a Hub International Company
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 453-4400
hubinternational.com/offices/us/ohio/columbus-west-lane-ave
LI
1820 Northwest Blvd Ste 200
Loy Insurance Inc
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 891-0093
loyinsurance.com
KP
8885 Commerce Loop Dr
Kevin Patterson Agency, LLC American Family Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 212-2475
amfam.com/agents/ohio/columbus/kevin-patterson
SG
4449 Easton Way 2nd floor
Sylvia A. Garrett Agency, LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 665-9801
sylviaagarrettagency.com
WE
29 Frederick St
W.E. Davis Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 443-0533
wedavis.com
FI
1500 W 3rd Ave Ste 300a
Farmers Insurance - Nicole Kraft
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 310-4944
agents.farmers.com/oh/columbus/nicole-kraft
SI
120 Mill St
Schneider Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 471-8444
schneiderins.com
MS
301 S Hamilton Rd
Murray & Sons Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 237-0291
murrayandsonsins.com
AA
5250 Bethel-Reed Pk
Above All Insurance Group
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 588-7840
AA
3021 Bethel Rd STE 101
Above All Insurance Group, LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 583-8785
insuringallofohio.com

What Does an a Umbrella Insurance Agent in Columbus Cost?

The cost of an umbrella insurance policy in Ohio typically ranges from 150 to 300 dollars per year for 1 million dollars in coverage. Premiums may be higher for individuals with multiple properties or high-risk assets. Costs vary by case and depend on your underlying insurance limits and claims history. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About umbrella insurance agents in Columbus

Umbrella insurance agents in Columbus Ohio help you secure extra liability coverage beyond standard auto and homeowners policies. Ohio law requires minimum auto liability limits of 25000 per person and 50000 per accident but an umbrella policy can add 1 million or more in protection. These policies are especially useful for homeowners with pools or rental properties in Franklin County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does an umbrella insurance agent in Columbus do?

An umbrella insurance agent in Columbus helps you assess your personal liability risks and find a policy that provides extra coverage above your existing auto or home insurance. They explain how Ohio state laws affect your liability limits and help you choose the right amount of protection.

How much umbrella coverage do I need in Ohio?

Most agents recommend at least 1 million dollars in umbrella coverage for Ohio residents with significant assets. The amount you need depends on your net worth, property holdings, and potential lawsuit risks. An agent can help you calculate a suitable limit based on your personal situation.

Do I need an umbrella policy if I have a pool in Columbus?

Yes, having a pool increases your liability risk and an umbrella policy can provide extra protection beyond your homeowners insurance. Ohio does not require umbrella insurance but it is a common recommendation for pool owners to guard against injury claims.

Umbrella Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each umbrella insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.