ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Syracuse, NY

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Syracuse, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Syracuse, New York is Donigan Business and Personal Insurance, rated 4.9 stars across 493 reviews. Other highly rated options include CH Insurance, Haylor, Freyer & Coon Inc., Delmonico Insurance Agency. This directory lists 35 supplemental insurance agents serving Syracuse.

Showing 35 supplemental insurance agents in Syracuse, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Donigan Business and Personal Insurance708 W Belden Ave Box 11535(315) 428-8600
2CH Insurance100 S Salina St #370(315) 234-7500
3Haylor, Freyer & Coon Inc.300 S State St #1000(315) 451-1500
4Delmonico Insurance Agency720 Van Rensselaer St Suite 207(315) 472-4242
5Freeway Insurance814 S Geddes St(315) 514-0626
6Taylor Made Insurance Solutions, Inc.933 State Fair Blvd(315) 303-7020
7MedicarePaul American Senior Benefits117 N Townsend St(315) 663-8129
8Sarah Galutz - State Farm Insurance Agent6003 S Salina St #6(315) 299-8080
9AAA - DeWitt3460 Erie Blvd E(315) 446-3134
10MY Agency of CNY, Inc824 N State St(315) 422-2203
DB
708 W Belden Ave Box 11535
Donigan Business and Personal Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

Donigan Business and Personal Insurance serves the Syracuse, New York area as a supplemental insurance agent. This company works with local clients to address coverage gaps left by primary health plans. Supplemental insurance agents in this region commonly assist with policies that provide direct cash benefits during hospital stays or medical events. These plans can help manage out-of-pocket costs for procedures and deductibles. Donigan Business and Personal Insurance handles cancer insurance and hospital indemnity plans for residents of Syracuse.

CI
100 S Salina St #370
CH Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

CH Insurance serves clients in Syracuse, New York, as a supplemental insurance agent, offering a range of policies designed to fill gaps left by major medical coverage, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. Its service includes assisting clients with plan selection, application processing, and ongoing support for claims and policy changes. The company services local properties including single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

HF
300 S State St #1000
Haylor, Freyer & Coon Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

Homeowners, small business operators, and commercial property managers in Syracuse rely on supplemental insurance to fill gaps left by standard policies. Haylor, Freyer & Coon Inc. offers these supplementary plans, which can cover deductibles or loss-of-income scenarios that primary insurance often excludes. Their services help clients manage financial risks from unexpected damage or liability claims. The agency also extends its supplemental insurance expertise to clients throughout the nearby Onondaga County communities, including the village of Fayetteville and the town of Dewitt.

DI
720 Van Rensselaer St Suite 207
Delmonico Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

Delmonico Insurance Agency serves the Syracuse, New York area and its surrounding communities, handling supplemental insurance needs for local residents. It offers policies that help cover gaps left by primary health plans, such as accident, hospital indemnity, or critical illness coverage. The agency evaluates each client’s existing coverage and personal risk factors before recommending appropriate supplemental options. To handle a typical job, it begins with a no-obligation consultation to review a client’s current plan and identify potential exposures.

FI
814 S Geddes St
Freeway Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

As a supplemental insurance agent, Freeway Insurance in Syracuse, NY offers products that address the difference between a one-time life event policy and the recurring, annual coverage needed for ongoing health gaps. Their services typically help clients close the financial shortfalls not covered by major medical plans. Policies can be tailored to fill specific needs such as accident or critical illness protection. This local agency operates on both a scheduled and as-needed basis to adjust coverage with changing circumstances.

TM
933 State Fair Blvd
Taylor Made Insurance Solutions, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

As winter weather in Syracuse often leads to slips on icy sidewalks or unexpected health setbacks, many residents consider coverage that traditional plans may not fully address. Taylor Made Insurance Solutions, Inc. works as a supplemental insurance agent, helping local policyholders explore options for filling gaps in their existing health or accident policies. Their role involves explaining how additional plans can ease out-of-pocket costs during recovery. A typical first step includes a no-obligation review of a client’s current coverage to identify potential areas for supplementary protection.

MA
117 N Townsend St
MedicarePaul American Senior Benefits
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

MedicarePaul American Senior Benefits assists local seniors with their healthcare coverage needs, specializing in supplemental insurance policies designed to fill gaps in primary medical plans. These additional options help manage out-of-pocket costs like copays and deductibles, often including benefit periods in skilled nursing facilities. The agency serves residents across Syracuse, working directly with individuals to review plan options. Its services can be utilized by commercial settings including offices, warehouses, and food service environments.

SG
6003 S Salina St #6
Sarah Galutz - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

Serving residents across Syracuse with supplemental insurance needs, Sarah Galutz provides coverage options that complement primary health plans. This agency also assists local businesses by offering commercial insurance solutions tailored to their specific requirements. The service area extends throughout the Syracuse region, ensuring accessibility for clients both at home and at work. Existing policyholders are encouraged to schedule periodic reviews, allowing the agent to adjust coverage and follow up on any new needs between regular visits.

AD
3460 Erie Blvd E
AAA - DeWitt
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

AAA - DeWitt offers supplemental insurance solutions, including coverage for accidents and critical illnesses, to residents in and around Syracuse, New York. The agency works with individuals to identify policies that address gaps left by primary health plans, aiming to provide financial support during unexpected medical events. Its consultants review existing coverage and explain plan options for different health circumstances. The agency helps customers prepare for higher out-of-pocket costs often encountered during winter flu season or unexpected hospital stays.

MA
824 N State St
MY Agency of CNY, Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY

MY Agency of CNY, Inc in Syracuse, NY is known for helping fill coverage gaps left by major medical plans. Its supplemental insurance agent services include accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity policies. These plans provide direct cash benefits to clients for unexpected medical events. The agency also offers optional dental and vision add-ons for comprehensive daily care support.

CJ
3680 Erie Blvd E
Cindy Jackson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 445-0019
cindyjacksonagent.com
DM
4875 South Ave
Don Marsh Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 498-4642
donmarshagency.com
RL
108 E Washington St # 1
Robert L Kelly General Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 425-8101
rlkellyinsurance.com
BI
708 W Belden Ave
business insurance rochester, ny | liability insurance rochester ny | steve donigan agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 428-8600
MM
1524 W Fayette St
Masterpole-Murphy Agency Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 473-9622
masterpolemurphy.com
FF
112 Dewitt St #202
Fiscal Fitness
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 477-1906
yourfiscalfitness.com
SA
306 Hawley Ave
Sinclair & Andrews Insurance, Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 472-1010
sinclairandandrews.com
AS
805 S Geddes St
Archer's Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 471-0992
PT
210 N Geddes St
Policy Trust Insurance Co
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 230-0916
GP
450 S Salina St
Genius Policy Place
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 228-0325
PA
440 S Warren St #704
Parsons & Associates Inc - Syracuse Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 472-5420
parsonsinsurance.com
RL
440 S Salina St
Radiant Life Insurance NY
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 230-0241
BL
251 Salina Meadows Pkwy Ste 130
Bankers Life
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 431-2980
branches.bankerslife.com/ny/syracuse/251-salina-mdws-pkwy
GM
9090 Destiny USA Dr
Giovanni McClain: Hill Insurance Service
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 949-0606
hillinsurancellc.com
MI
959 Hiawatha Blvd W
Maguire Insurance Agency - Syracuse
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(607) 261-1301
maguireinsuranceagency.com
HF
231 Salina Meadows Pkwy
Haylor Freyer & Coon Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 451-1500
MF
251 Salina Meadows Pkwy Ste 130
Michelle Fuller, Bankers Life Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 431-2980
agents.bankerslife.com/ny/syracuse/251-salina-mdws-pkwy/michelle-fuller
BH
251 Salina Meadows Pkwy Ste 130
Brynner Holland, Bankers Life Agent and Bankers Life Securities Financial Representative
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 431-2980
agents.bankerslife.com/ny/syracuse/251-salina-mdws-pkwy/brynner-holland
NM
251 Salina Meadows Pkwy Ste 130
Norman Miles, Bankers Life Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 431-2980
agents.bankerslife.com/ny/syracuse/251-salina-mdws-pkwy/norman-miles
SM
251 Salina Meadows Pkwy Ste 130
Sheena Moore, Bankers Life Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 431-2980
agents.bankerslife.com/ny/syracuse/251-salina-mdws-pkwy/sheena-moore
JT
205 Westfall Dr
Joseph Terek Medicare Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 466-1984
medcarevalue.com/Joe
MA
4863 W Seneca Turnpike
MetLife Auto&Home Ins. Joe Rescigno
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 400-3029
upstatenyinsurance.com
NF
251 Salina Meadows Pkwy Ste 130
Nicholas Field, Bankers Life Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 720-0250
agents.bankerslife.com/ny/syracuse/251-salina-mdws-pkwy/nicholas-field
SL
220 Salina Meadows Pkwy # 255
Sentry Life Insurance Co of New York
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 453-6301
sentry.com
CR
231 Salina Meadows Pkwy Ste 100
Christina Rusnak, Bankers Life Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Syracuse, NY
(315) 431-2980
agents.bankerslife.com/ny/syracuse

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Syracuse Cost?

Medigap Plan G premiums in Syracuse typically range from $120 to $250 per month depending on your age and the insurer. Medicare Advantage plans often have $0 monthly premiums but include copays and deductibles. New York does not limit how much insurers can charge based on age. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Syracuse

Supplemental insurance agents in Syracuse help residents fill gaps in Medicare coverage. New York law guarantees a six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting when you turn 65. Local agents can explain how state rules affect plan options for Onondaga County residents.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Syracuse?

A supplemental insurance agent in Syracuse helps you buy Medigap or Medicare Advantage plans. These agents are licensed in New York and can explain how state laws like guaranteed issue rights apply to you.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in New York?

New York offers a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you first enroll in Medicare Part B. During this time you can buy any Medigap plan without medical underwriting.

Do New York agents charge fees for their services?

Most supplemental insurance agents in New York are paid by insurance companies through commissions. You typically do not pay a fee directly to the agent for their help selecting a plan.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.