ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Bay Shore, NY

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Bay Shore, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Bay Shore, New York is Sound Harbor Insurance, rated 5.0 stars across 343 reviews. Other highly rated options include Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community Office, Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance, Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 16 supplemental insurance agents serving Bay Shore.

Showing 16 supplemental insurance agents in Bay Shore, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Sound Harbor Insurance91 E Main St Suite 3(631) 517-9211
2Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community Office1656-G 5th Ave(631) 231-3696
3Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance67 E Main St(631) 440-9226
4Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent87 Park Ave(631) 666-8350
5Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent1656 5th Ave A(631) 478-6669
6Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent1805 5th Ave Ste 14(631) 456-4603
7ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC.1716 Sunrise Hwy(631) 665-6464
8Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd25 4th Ave(631) 434-6666
9C Walsh Agency28 W Main St(631) 251-6050
10Jay Tee Insurance1655 5th Ave A(631) 231-3200
SH
91 E Main St Suite 3
Sound Harbor Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Sound Harbor Insurance serves Bay Shore, New York, and the surrounding Suffolk County area as a supplemental insurance agent. The company assists clients in bridging coverage gaps left by major medical plans. Their focus includes helping individuals manage out-of-pocket expenses not addressed by standard health insurance. Common policies offered may include accident indemnity plans and critical illness coverage. Additionally, the agency works with clients on hospital indemnity insurance for covered stays.

FC
1656-G 5th Ave
Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community Office
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community Office provides supplemental insurance agent services for the greater Bay Shore area. It assists clients in understanding and selecting policies designed to cover gaps left by primary health insurance. The office offers ongoing support to help policyholders manage their coverage needs and periodic plan options. Services include guidance on Medicare supplements, accident plans, and critical illness policies available in the region. The company serves individuals residing in single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and local restaurants.

AM
67 E Main St
Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Serving homeowners, businesses, and property managers in Bay Shore, this supplemental insurance agent helps clients fill coverage gaps that standard policies often leave. It offers voluntary products designed to provide additional financial protection during unexpected events or accidents. The agent assists local residents and commercial operators in reviewing their existing plans to identify where extra security may be needed. Support extends to nearby communities such as Islip, helping ensure broader access around Suffolk County for tailored insurance solutions.

MS
87 Park Ave
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Serving Bay Shore and the surrounding communities of Suffolk County, Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent operates as a supplemental insurance agent. This office handles Medicare supplement policies, accident and health plans, and critical illness coverage to help fill gaps in primary insurance. Each client receives an individual needs assessment to identify specific coverage shortfalls. The agent then presents tailored plan options from available products, explaining the effects of each deductible and benefit limit during a straightforward comparison process.

BD
1656 5th Ave A
Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

For one-time coverage, clients handle a specific financial event like a serious illness with a single claim payment, while scheduled supplemental insurance offers recurring benefits for ongoing needs such as accident recovery or hospital stays. Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent in Bay Shore, NY, assists local residents in selecting these policy types to address gaps left by primary health plans. Service is available on both a one-time basis for individual claims and as needed for policy adjustments or questions.

DC
1805 5th Ave Ste 14
Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent in Bay Shore, NY, specializes in supplemental insurance coverage that fills gaps left by primary health plans. It also provides general insurance services such as auto, home, and life policies to local residents. This agency helps clients manage out-of-pocket expenses from medical events like accidents or hospitalization. As winter approaches and seasonal illnesses become more prevalent, it assists customers in reviewing their policies to ensure adequate protection against unexpected medical costs and related financial strain.

AI
1716 Sunrise Hwy
ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Residents in the Bay Shore area often look to bridge gaps in their primary health coverage, particularly after annual enrollment changes or seasonal shifts in income. ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC. serves as a supplemental insurance agent, helping individuals evaluate policies designed to cover out-of-pocket expenses from conventional plans. Working with local providers, they assist in understanding options for accident, hospital, or critical illness needs. The process typically begins with a brief in-person or phone assessment to review current medical coverage and identify potential supplementary gaps.

OM
25 4th Ave
Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd in Bay Shore, NY assists clients with their general supplemental insurance agent needs, addressing gaps left by primary health coverage. A core aspect of its work involves offering add-on policies that help manage out-of-pocket expenses and unexpected financial burdens. This local agency focuses on tailoring coverage to individual circumstances, helping policyholders navigate the complexities of supplemental plans. The company serves a diverse range of commercial sectors, including offices, warehouses, and food service operations, providing specialized insurance solutions adapted to each industry’s unique risk profile.

CW
28 W Main St
C Walsh Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

C Walsh Agency serves residential clients in Bay Shore and the surrounding area with supplemental insurance policies that help cover gaps in primary health coverage. Commercial clients likewise receive assistance with additional coverage options tailored to their business needs. The agency provides clear explanations of plan benefits and assists with claims when necessary. After an initial policy is in place, the agency follows up regularly to adjust coverage as circumstances change and arranges periodic reviews between regular service visits.

JT
1655 5th Ave A
Jay Tee Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Jay Tee Insurance is known as a supplemental insurance agent based in Bay Shore, NY, serving local residents seeking additional coverage beyond primary health plans. The company focuses on helping clients fill gaps in their existing policies with various supplemental product options tailored to individual needs. Its service range includes assisting with plan selection and enrollment for benefits that address specific financial vulnerabilities. Among its offerings, the agency provides a specialty service in accident and critical illness coverage for those seeking extra protection during medical events.

AI
1175 Sunrise Hwy
AllSafe Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 517-1173
UI
214 5th Ave
Universal Insurance Co
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(315) 239-3997
FC
194 N Fehr Way Suite D-3
First Choice Insurance New York
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 729-9572
SI
90 Millpond Ln
SafeCity Insurance Agency NY
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(917) 310-3567
CI
21 Third Ave Suite 1
Cochrane Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 665-3100
AI
1784 5th Ave Unit B
Alpine Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 435-0001

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Bay Shore Cost?

Supplemental insurance premiums in New York typically range from $100 to $300 per month for Medigap plans, depending on the plan letter and insurer. Medicare Advantage plans often have lower monthly premiums, sometimes $0, but include cost-sharing for services. Costs vary by your age, location, and chosen plan. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Bay Shore

Supplemental insurance agents in Bay Shore, New York help residents choose Medigap or Medicare Advantage plans that fill gaps in Original Medicare. New York state law guarantees a 30-day open enrollment period for Medigap policies after you first enroll in Medicare Part B. Local agents can explain how these plans work with your existing coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a supplemental insurance agent in Bay Shore do?

A supplemental insurance agent helps you compare and enroll in private insurance plans that cover costs not paid by Medicare, such as deductibles and copayments. They review your health needs and budget to find a suitable policy from carriers licensed in New York.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in New York?

In New York, you have a 30-day Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time, you can buy any Medigap policy without medical underwriting. Outside this window, insurers may use health questions to decide coverage.

Are supplemental insurance costs regulated in New York?

Yes, New York regulates Medigap premiums and requires insurers to offer community-rated policies, meaning your premium cannot increase based on your age or health. Rates still vary by company and plan type, so an agent can help you compare options.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.