ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Ithaca, NY

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Ithaca, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Ithaca, New York is Bailey Place Insurance, rated 5.0 stars across 81 reviews. Other highly rated options include True Insurance, Kris Yelverton - State Farm Insurance Agent, Moscato & Associates Inc. This directory lists 18 supplemental insurance agents serving Ithaca.

Showing 18 supplemental insurance agents in Ithaca, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Bailey Place Insurance2428 N Triphammer Rd(607) 319-0094
2True Insurance124 Seneca Way(607) 273-7511
3Kris Yelverton - State Farm Insurance Agent401 Elmira Rd Suite 6(607) 229-1111
4Moscato & Associates Inc950 Danby Rd(607) 216-1450
5Andrews Agency Insurance804 W State St(607) 273-7551
6Warren Insurance Agency223 Elmira Rd(607) 277-0267
7State Farm: Lee Newhart Jr1011 W State St(607) 273-6391
8Security Mutual Insurance Co2417 N Triphammer Rd(607) 257-5000
9P W Wood & Son Inc2333 N Triphammer Rd Suite 501(607) 266-3303
10Stability Insurance New York430 W State St(315) 230-0517
BP
2428 N Triphammer Rd
Bailey Place Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

Bailey Place Insurance serves Ithaca, New York, and the surrounding Tompkins County area as a supplemental insurance agent. The company helps individuals obtain policies that cover out-of-pocket expenses traditional health plans may not fully pay. These supplemental plans can include coverage for accidents, critical illnesses, and hospital stays. By guiding clients through available options, the agency aims to simplify the process of securing added financial protection tailored to specific needs. Among the supplemental solutions it facilitates are accident insurance and hospital indemnity plans.

TI
124 Seneca Way
True Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

True Insurance provides supplemental insurance policies designed to fill coverage gaps not addressed by standard health plans. Their service plans include helping clients evaluate their current coverage and offering policy options tailored for specific needs like accidents, critical illness, or hospital indemnity. Maintenance services involve reviewing policy changes and assisting with claims for residents and business owners in the Ithaca area. The company services single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants in the local community.

KY
401 Elmira Rd Suite 6
Kris Yelverton - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

Kris Yelverton - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Ithaca, New York, and the surrounding Tompkins County communities, handling supplemental insurance policies. These plans help cover gaps in primary health coverage, offering financial protection for unexpected medical events. The agency works with local clients to identify policies that fit their individual lifestyles and budgets. For a typical job, it begins by reviewing a client’s existing coverage to find potential shortfalls, then presents clear options without pressure. This process ensures each plan is selected based on personal circumstances.

MA
950 Danby Rd
Moscato & Associates Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

Homeowners, renters, and small business owners in Ithaca, New York turn to Moscato & Associates Inc for supplemental insurance agent services. They assist clients in understanding options that help cover gaps often left by standard health or property policies. This agency focuses on offering clear guidance for local residents seeking financial protection against unexpected medical or property-related expenses. Their knowledge of regional insurance needs supports informed decision-making for the community. Moscato & Associates Inc also serves clients throughout Tompkins County and the surrounding towns.

AA
804 W State St
Andrews Agency Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

Andrews Agency Insurance serves Ithaca, New York, and its surrounding communities, handling supplemental insurance policies that cover gaps left by major medical plans. These policies help local residents manage out-of-pocket costs for specific events like accidents or critical illnesses. The agency generally begins a typical job by first reviewing a client’s existing coverage to identify potential exposures. It then works to present policy options that address those specific financial risks, often tailoring recommendations to fit individual needs and budgets while guiding clients through the selection and enrollment process step by step.

WI
223 Elmira Rd
Warren Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

Supplemental insurance agents provide either one-time policy solutions, such as fixed-benefit hospital plans, or ongoing service options that allow clients to adjust coverage over time. Operating in Ithaca, New York, Warren Insurance Agency helps individuals evaluate these recurring needs versus single-purchase protection. Supplemental coverage typically fills gaps left by major medical plans. Clients may receive help with enrollment, claims questions, and plan reviews. For customers, the agency offers service on an as-needed basis, responding to requests for policy changes or information updates as they arise.

SF
1011 W State St
State Farm: Lee Newhart Jr
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

As the cold months settle over Ithaca, residents often review their financial safety nets to prepare for unexpected health events. State Farm: Lee Newhart Jr works with individuals and families in the area to identify gaps in their existing plans. This agency specializes in supplemental insurance coverage designed to manage out-of-pocket costs and offer additional peace of mind during medical incidents. Understanding each client’s unique situation is central to their approach. The process typically begins with a no-obligation assessment of current policies to recommend appropriate supplemental solutions.

SM
2417 N Triphammer Rd
Security Mutual Insurance Co
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

Security Mutual Insurance Co in Ithaca, NY specializes in supplemental insurance agency services, offering policies designed to fill gaps left by primary health and life coverage. It helps individuals manage out-of-pocket expenses, including deductibles and copays, through accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. The agency regularly works with local residents to tailor benefits for both new and existing policyholders. During open enrollment periods, it assists clients in reviewing and adjusting their supplemental options to match changing healthcare needs or life events.

PW
2333 N Triphammer Rd Suite 501
P W Wood & Son Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

P W Wood & Son Inc serves residents of Ithaca, New York, by helping them select supplemental insurance policies that fill gaps in primary health coverage. The agency also works with local commercial clients, providing similar gap coverage solutions for businesses in the surrounding area. Agents explain policy options for Medicare, accident, or hospital indemnity plans, ensuring clients understand their choices. After the initial enrollment, the agency contacts policyholders for periodic policy reviews and addresses any coverage questions during the year, maintaining contact until the next regular visit is scheduled.

SI
430 W State St
Stability Insurance New York
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY

Stability Insurance New York distinguishes between one-time policy evaluations and recurring benefit adjustment services, offering supplemental coverage to meet gaps in health or life insurance plans. Located in Ithaca, New York, the agency provides plans that help manage out-of-pocket expenses from primary policies. Clients may choose from accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity products. Service appointments for this Supplemental Insurance Agent operate on a scheduled basis, with options for as-needed follow-up discussions throughout the coverage year.

LI
401 N Aurora St
Larkin Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY
(607) 273-4732
larkininsuranceagency.com
TT
102 E State St
Tower of Trust Insurance CO
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY
(315) 227-3577
BW
903 Hanshaw Rd
The Becker-Well Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY
(607) 257-1003
AR
950 Danby Rd Suite 100D RM 3
Al Rateb - Medicare Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY
(866) 836-4743
TI
119 E Seneca St
Tompkins Insurance Agencies
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY
(607) 257-4440
tompkinsins.com
MI
370 Elmira Rd
Maguire Insurance Agency - Ithaca
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY
(607) 261-1301
maguirefamilyinsurance.com
TI
124 Seneca Way
True Insurance: Hildreth Becki
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY
(607) 273-7511
trueinsurance.com
LI
401 N Aurora St
Larkin Insurance Inc: Sharp Teresa
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Ithaca, NY
(607) 273-4732
larkininsuranceagency.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Ithaca Cost?

Costs for supplemental insurance in New York vary by plan type and provider. Medigap Plan G for a 65-year-old in Ithaca typically ranges from 150 to 250 dollars per month. Cancer plans may cost 30 to 80 dollars per month. Accident plans often range from 20 to 50 dollars per month. These are general estimates; actual costs depend on your age, health, and the insurer. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Ithaca

Supplemental insurance agents in Ithaca, New York help residents find plans that cover gaps in primary health insurance. These agents can assist with Medigap policies, which are standardized under New York law and have guaranteed issue rights for many enrollees. Local agents also offer cancer, critical illness, and accident plans to provide extra financial protection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Ithaca?

A supplemental insurance agent in Ithaca helps you buy policies that pay benefits for specific events like accidents or hospital stays. These agents are licensed by the New York State Department of Financial Services and must follow state regulations.

Do I need a supplemental insurance agent in New York?

You may benefit from an agent if you want to compare Medigap plans or add coverage for cancer or critical illness. New York law allows you to change Medigap plans during the annual open enrollment period without medical underwriting.

How do I choose a supplemental insurance agent in Ithaca?

Look for an agent who is licensed in New York and has experience with the specific coverage you need. You can verify a license through the New York State Department of Financial Services website.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.