ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeLandlord Insurance AgentsOhio › Lancaster

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Lancaster, OH

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Lancaster, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Lancaster, Ohio is Xan Vargo - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 5.0 stars across 208 reviews. Other highly rated options include Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC, Bill Palmer Insurance Inc, Wentz Insurance Agency Inc. This directory lists 19 landlord insurance agents serving Lancaster.

Showing 19 landlord insurance agents in Lancaster, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Xan Vargo - State Farm Insurance Agent163 E 5th Ave(740) 571-0307
2Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC804 W Fair Ave(740) 653-4339
3Bill Palmer Insurance Inc725 E Main St(740) 687-5733
4Wentz Insurance Agency Inc1601 E Main St(740) 653-5535
5Frear Insurance Services Inc343 E Main St(740) 653-1236
6McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services110 N Columbus St Ste 107(740) 653-5230
7Mitchell Insurance Agency1518 E Main St(740) 687-6258
8Putnam White Lewis Insurance824 N Columbus St(740) 653-0602
9Tom Mertz Insurance345 E Main St(740) 687-1010
10Otto Insurance Group110 E Main St(740) 653-4004
XV
163 E 5th Ave
Xan Vargo - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Xan Vargo - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Lancaster, OH area, offering landlord insurance policies designed to protect rental property investments. The agency provides coverage for residential income properties, addressing risks such as property damage and liability claims that may arise from tenants. Policy options typically include dwelling protection and loss of rental income coverage. Claims assistance is available through the local office. Xan Vargo handles policy customization for single-family rentals and multi-unit dwellings.

MI
804 W Fair Ave
Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Miller Insurance & Financial Group, LLC provides comprehensive landlord insurance solutions for property owners in the Lancaster, OH area. Their service plans include tailored coverage for rental dwellings, safeguarding against property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income. Regular policy reviews help clients maintain appropriate protection as their portfolios evolve. They service single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants, addressing the distinct insurance needs for each type of leased commercial or residential property.

BP
725 E Main St
Bill Palmer Insurance Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Bill Palmer Insurance Inc in Lancaster, OH provides landlord insurance services for property managers, real estate investors, and homeowners who rent out residential units. The agency helps secure coverage to protect rental properties against common risks like property damage, liability claims, and lost rental income. Policies are tailored to the specific needs of landlords managing single-family homes or small multifamily buildings. Its service area also extends to the surrounding Fairfield County communities and neighboring metro areas such as Columbus.

WI
1601 E Main St
Wentz Insurance Agency Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Wentz Insurance Agency Inc serves Lancaster, Ohio, and the surrounding Fairfield County communities with landlord insurance policies. It handles liability coverage and property protection for residential rental properties in the local area. The agency works with property owners to secure policies that safeguard their investments against common risks such as fire damage and tenant-related issues. For a typical job, it assesses each client’s rental portfolio to recommend appropriate coverage limits that match the specific property and owner requirements.

FI
343 E Main St
Frear Insurance Services Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Frear Insurance Services Inc in Lancaster, OH distinguishes between a one-time policy for a single property and a recurring plan covering multiple rentals, adjusting liability and dwelling limits accordingly. The agency structures landlord coverage to protect the building structure and address loss of rental income from covered events. Service arrangements are available on a stand-alone, scheduled review, or as-needed claim basis depending on the client’s portfolio needs.

MI
110 N Columbus St Ste 107
McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services in Lancaster, Ohio provides landlord insurance for residential rental properties, such as single-family homes and duplexes. Commercial coverage is also available for larger multi-unit buildings. The company serves property owners throughout Fairfield County and the surrounding central Ohio region, helping them secure policies tailored to their rental portfolios. Clients regularly return for policy reviews between visits to adjust coverage as properties, tenants, and market conditions evolve over time.

MI
1518 E Main St
Mitchell Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Specializing in tailored coverage for rental properties, Mitchell Insurance Agency in Lancaster, OH assists landlords with protecting their residential and commercial investments. The agency provides general landlord insurance services, including policies that address property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income. Navigating the specific risks of the local real estate market, the team also offers guidance on safeguarding against tenant-related incidents. During Ohio's harsh winter months, this agency further helps landlords secure coverage for burst pipes and ice dam damage, ensuring properties remain protected through seasonal challenges.

PW
824 N Columbus St
Putnam White Lewis Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Putnam White Lewis Insurance serves residential landlords in Lancaster, Ohio, with property coverage tailored for rental dwellings. It also offers commercial policies for small apartment buildings and mixed-use properties throughout Fairfield County and the surrounding region. The agency assists property owners in managing liability exposure, fire risks, and weather-related damage claims. Clients often return for policy reviews after lease renewals or renovations, allowing the firm to adjust coverage between regular inspections or seasonal property turnovers.

TM
345 E Main St
Tom Mertz Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Tom Mertz Insurance provides property coverage for local landlords, offering protection for rental homes and apartments in Lancaster. Its specialty add-ons include coverage for loss of rental income and liability protection for tenant injuries. This agency serves owners of commercial structures such as office buildings, warehouses, and food service establishments, ensuring each property type receives appropriate risk management.

OI
110 E Main St
Otto Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

As Lancaster rental property owners prepare for the seasonal freeze and thaw cycles, Otto Insurance Group assists with annual policy reviews tailored to landlord needs in the Ohio region. The agency focuses on structuring coverage for both long-term leases and short-term rentals, protecting against liability and property damage risks common to local homes. Their approach includes evaluating current replacement costs for structures and loss-of-rent calculations. To begin a policy assessment, an agent schedules an inspection of the rental property.

CI
414 E Main St # 100
Clark Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-8623
clarkins.com
SI
169 W Fair Ave B
Shelter Insurance - Jessica Wilkins
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 785-5025
shelterinsurance.com/CA/agent/JWILKINS
GI
711 W Fair Ave
Gibson Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-7111
garygibsoninsurance.com
FI
850 E Main St
Farmers Insurance - Bruce Hajost
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 901-4440
agents.farmers.com/oh/lancaster/bruce-hajost
SF
351 S Columbus St
State Farm Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 687-1961
statefarm.com
FI
118 W Mulberry St
Farmers Insurance - Mark Reynolds
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(614) 808-4730
agents.farmers.com/oh/lancaster/dawn-reynolds
WI
400 N Memorial Dr
Wichert Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 654-0532
wichert.com
DJ
402 E Main St
Derflinger Jones Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 687-5808
derflingerjonesins.com
MI
802 W Fair Ave
Miller Insurance & Financial: Heston Rita
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-4339
millerinsuranceandfinancialgroup.com/about-our-agency/meet-our-team

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Lancaster Cost?

The cost of landlord insurance in Ohio typically ranges from $800 to $2,500 per year for a single family home. Factors include property location, age, and coverage limits. Lancaster rates may be slightly lower than Columbus due to lower replacement costs. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Lancaster

Landlord insurance agents in Lancaster, Ohio help rental property owners protect their investments with specialized policies. Ohio law does not require landlords to carry insurance, but mortgage lenders often mandate it. A local agent can explain how Ohio landlord-tenant laws affect your coverage needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in Lancaster Ohio?

Landlord insurance typically covers property damage, liability protection, and loss of rental income. In Ohio, policies may also cover legal costs if you need to evict a tenant. Your agent can tailor coverage to your specific property type.

Is landlord insurance required by Ohio law?

Ohio law does not require landlords to carry insurance. However, most mortgage lenders require a landlord policy. Without it, you could face significant financial loss from tenant damage or liability claims.

How do I choose a landlord insurance agent in Lancaster?

Look for an agent with experience insuring rental properties in Fairfield County. Ask about their knowledge of Ohio specific risks like winter freeze damage. Compare quotes from multiple agents to find suitable coverage.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.