ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeLandlord Insurance AgentsOhio › Columbus

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Columbus, OH

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Columbus, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Columbus, Ohio is Compare Quote Insurance, rated 5.0 stars across 904 reviews. Other highly rated options include Grange Insurance Companies, Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent, A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio. This directory lists 28 landlord insurance agents serving Columbus.

Showing 28 landlord insurance agents in Columbus, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Compare Quote Insurance5959 Scarborough Blvd #4500(888) 667-1212
2Grange Insurance Companies671 S High St(800) 422-0550
3Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent2140 Riverside Dr ste b(614) 485-9077
4A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio1180 W Broad St(614) 221-7007
5Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio4701 Olentangy River Rd Ste 102(614) 475-3583
6John Dawson Associates6025 Cleveland Ave(614) 890-1660
7Janna Bidlack - State Farm Insurance Agent2500 W Dublin-Granville Rd(614) 764-2411
8Lisa Diemer American Family Insurance3040 Riverside Dr #209(614) 488-9445
9Solid Insurance986 Morse Rd(614) 854-0000
10Isner Insurance Associates, Inc3695 N High St(614) 236-8691
CQ
5959 Scarborough Blvd #4500
Compare Quote Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Compare Quote Insurance in Columbus, OH provides a range of services for property owners seeking landlord insurance coverage. Its service plans include arranging policies that protect rental properties against common risks such as fire, theft, and liability claims. The company offers guidance on maintenance-related insurance requirements, helping landlords address everyday property upkeep issues. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

GI
671 S High St
Grange Insurance Companies
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Grange Insurance Companies serves the Columbus metro area and the surrounding county, providing landlord insurance agent services for residential and small commercial property owners. As a local agent, it connects property investors with general liability coverage and policies that protect against property damage. The company also assists with loss of rental income protection, helping landlords manage financial disruptions caused by tenant vacancies or uninhabitable units. Its services further include arranging coverage for fire, wind, and water damage on rental properties in this region.

KR
2140 Riverside Dr ste b
Katie Rider - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Katie Rider’s agency serves local homeowners, rental property managers, and small business owners seeking tailored landlord insurance coverage. As a Columbus, OH-based agent, she provides policies protecting rental dwellings, liability, and loss of income. The office guides clients through coverage options to secure appropriate protection for their investment properties in the area. The agency additionally serves clients throughout Franklin County, including the nearby neighborhoods of Clintonville and Bexley.

AI
1180 W Broad St
A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio serves landlord and property owner clients in Columbus and the surrounding central Ohio communities. It handles property coverage and liability protection for residential or small commercial rental units that owners lease to tenants. The agency works closely with each client to understand the unique exposure of their rental property. It then matches that risk profile with a policy from an appropriate carrier. This tailored approach helps ensure the coverage addresses the specific demands of a typical landlord insurance job.

AH
4701 Olentangy River Rd Ste 102
Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Auto and Home Insurance in Columbus Ohio | Slyman Insurance Group Ohio provides both one-time landlord policy placements for single events and recurring coverage options for ongoing property management. Their landlord insurance agents focus on structuring protection that addresses liability and property damage risks unique to rental real estate in the Columbus area. Service runs on either a one-time or scheduled renewal basis, allowing clients to choose according to their specific leasing cycle needs.

JD
6025 Cleveland Ave
John Dawson Associates
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

John Dawson Associates in Columbus, OH offers landlord insurance agent services that specialize in protecting rental property investments. The agency provides various coverage options, including policies for property damage and liability risks common among local landlords. It assists clients in understanding insurance needs for single-family rentals, multi-unit buildings, and other residential properties. A specific concern it helps with is addressing coverage gaps that can arise during the winter months, such as freeze-related pipe bursts and slip-and-fall claims after snow or ice accumulation.

JB
2500 W Dublin-Granville Rd
Janna Bidlack - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

With Columbus rental properties facing seasonal wear from Ohio winters and humid summers, Janna Bidlack - State Farm Insurance Agent helps local landlords protect their investments with tailored coverage. As a landlord insurance agent, this office addresses the specific risks of rental properties, such as liability concerns and property damage from tenants or weather. Each policy is designed to cover structures and lost rental income. To get started, the agent schedules an initial inspection of the premises to evaluate current conditions and determine appropriate coverage needs for the property.

LD
3040 Riverside Dr #209
Lisa Diemer American Family Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Lisa Diemer American Family Insurance provides residential landlord insurance to property owners in Columbus, Ohio. Coverage is also available for qualifying commercial rental properties throughout the local area. Policies help address risks specific to leased dwellings, including property damage and liability exposures. The agency coordinates protection for both short-term and long-term rental situations. Follow-up communication between scheduled visits ensures that coverage adjustments can be made when lease terms or property conditions change.

SI
986 Morse Rd
Solid Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Solid Insurance works with property owners in Columbus to secure appropriate liability and property protection for rental holdings. The agency helps clients add tailored endorsements for issues like vandalism, erosion, or legal liability from tenant injuries. Their service focuses on creating policies that match each landlord's property type and financial needs. They assist residential investors along with those managing commercial spaces such as offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

II
3695 N High St
Isner Insurance Associates, Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH

Isner Insurance Associates, Inc in Columbus, OH is known for providing landlord insurance to property owners protecting rental incomes. It offers standard coverage for dwelling and liability against tenant damages or injuries. The company additionally works with clients to secure protection for vacant structures and short-term rental properties. A specialty service it can add on is coverage for loss of rents during necessary repairs after a covered claim.

SE
1620 E Broad St #103
Sokol Eisenberg Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
sokoleisenberg.com
GI
4131 Worth Ave Suite 200
Goosehead Insurance - Columbus
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(800) 474-1377
goosehead.com
BI
21 E State St #200
Brown Insurance Company LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 324-6980
browninsco.com
PW
4161 N High St
Putnam White Lewis Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 267-1269
pwlinsurance.com
BW
1335 Dublin Rd #110-D
Briggs & Williams Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 486-7646
briggswilliamsinsurance.com
TV
2000 W Henderson Rd #340
Town & Village Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 457-6913
townvillageins.com
DC
1080 Fishinger Rd
Dan Coonfare Agency LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 486-5400
coonfareinsurance.com
GI
1500 W 3rd Ave #300F
Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 915-0977
grandviewinsuranceservice.com
SI
891 S James Rd
Soller Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 235-2815
localinsurancecolumbusohio.com
FI
5898 Cleveland Ave
Ferrell Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 899-8867
progressiveagent.com/ferrell-insurance-agency-columbus
GI
3040 Riverside Dr Suite 205
Goosehead Insurance - Scott Krouse & Mike Dunson
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(419) 296-1347
goosehead.com/agents/oh/columbus/scott-krouse-and-mike-dunson
LI
1820 Northwest Blvd Ste 200
Loy Insurance Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 891-0093
loyinsurance.com
RI
1580 Fishinger Rd
Ray Insurance Agency, Inc.
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 459-1122
rayinsurance.com
SG
4449 Easton Way 2nd floor
Sylvia A. Garrett Agency, LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 665-9801
sylviaagarrettagency.com
SI
120 Mill St
Schneider Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 471-8444
schneiderins.com
EI
2242 S Hamilton Rd #101
Enterprise Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 759-6411
MS
301 S Hamilton Rd
Murray & Sons Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 237-0291
murrayandsonsins.com
OL
480 S 3rd St
Ohio Landlord Insurance Pros
Landlord Insurance Agent · Columbus, OH
(614) 230-0276

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Columbus Cost?

Landlord insurance in Ohio typically costs 15 to 25 percent more than standard homeowners insurance. For a single-family rental in Columbus annual premiums often range from 800 to 1,500 dollars depending on property value location and coverage limits. Multi-unit properties and older homes may cost more. This is general information not insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Columbus

Landlord insurance agents in Columbus Ohio help property owners protect their rental investments with specialized policies. Ohio law does not require landlord insurance but mortgage lenders often mandate it. Local agents understand Columbus market risks like older homes in historic districts and seasonal weather patterns.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in Columbus Ohio?

Landlord insurance typically covers property damage liability and loss of rental income. In Ohio policies often include coverage for vandalism and weather damage common in the region. Personal property of tenants is not covered by your policy.

Is landlord insurance required by Ohio law?

Ohio does not legally require landlord insurance but mortgage lenders usually mandate it. Without coverage you could face significant out-of-pocket costs for repairs or lawsuits. Many Columbus landlords also require tenants to carry renters insurance.

How do I choose a landlord insurance agent in Columbus?

Look for an agent licensed in Ohio who specializes in rental property coverage. Ask about policy options for single-family homes multi-unit buildings and short-term rentals. Verify the agent works with multiple insurers to compare quotes.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.