ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeLandlord Insurance AgentsIndiana › Indianapolis

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Indianapolis, IN

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Indianapolis, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Indianapolis, Indiana is Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group, rated 5.0 stars across 1,179 reviews. Other highly rated options include Steffey Insurance Agency, Breneman Insurance Group, Conner Insurance. This directory lists 20 landlord insurance agents serving Indianapolis.

Showing 20 landlord insurance agents in Indianapolis, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group7212 Shadeland Ave # 201(317) 350-1598
2Steffey Insurance Agency3091 E 98th St SUITE 125(317) 334-3743
3Breneman Insurance Group5329 S Emerson Ave Suite A(317) 786-2200
4Conner Insurance8445 Keystone Crossing #200
5McGowan Insurance Group345 Massachusetts Ave # 250(317) 464-5000
6GJ Insurance Group2050 E 96th St(317) 751-5001
7Killion & Hall Insurance Agency6316 W Thompson Rd(317) 856-4550
8Burns Family Insurance1800 N Meridian St #103a(317) 377-1100
9CMR Insurance & Services4955 W Washington St D(317) 953-1850
10Central Insurance Associates70 91st St #200(317) 846-4622
SW
7212 Shadeland Ave # 201
Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group serves the Indianapolis, Indiana, metro area as a landlord insurance agent. It helps property owners secure coverage for rental dwellings, including single-family homes and multi-unit properties. The agency works with clients to select policies that address liability protection and property damage risks common in the local rental market. Specific services it handles include dwelling fire insurance for residential rentals and liability coverage tailored for individual landlords and small-scale rental operators.

SI
3091 E 98th St SUITE 125
Steffey Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Steffey Insurance Agency provides landlord insurance policies for rental property owners in the Indianapolis area. It offers standard property coverage options and can assist with liability protection specific to residential landlords. The agency helps clients understand the differences between homeowner and landlord policies, ensuring appropriate coverage for income-producing assets. It services a range of properties, including single-family homes, apartment buildings, retail storefronts, and restaurants.

BI
5329 S Emerson Ave Suite A
Breneman Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Breneman Insurance Group serves homeowners, rental property owners, and property managers in Indianapolis needing specialized landlord insurance coverage. The agency provides policies that protect against property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income. It helps local investors secure appropriate coverage for single-family rentals, duplexes, and small apartment buildings. Tailored plans address the unique risks of leasing residential properties in the market. The company also extends its landlord insurance services to nearby communities such as Carmel in the northern Indianapolis metro area.

CI
8445 Keystone Crossing #200
Conner Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
MI
345 Massachusetts Ave # 250
McGowan Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

At McGowan Insurance Group in Indianapolis, landlord clients choose between a single occurrence policy or ongoing coverage for their rental properties. Both options address property damage and liability from tenant claims. Coverage can be discussed for individual units or portfolios across multiple locations. Standard protections including loss of rental income and building repairs are available. Their service runs on either a one-time basis for a specific property transaction or as scheduled renewals for continuous protection.

GI
2050 E 96th St
GJ Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

GJ Insurance Group specializes in crafting customized policies for residential and commercial rental properties. It assists Indianapolis landlords with essential coverage, including property damage, liability protection, and loss of rental income. The agency works closely with clients to assess individual property risks and navigate standard policy options. It also helps landlords prepare for common seasonal concerns, such as severe Midwest winter weather that can cause frozen pipes or roof damage requiring immediate claims support.

KH
6316 W Thompson Rd
Killion & Hall Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

As winter ice and spring storms threaten Indianapolis rental properties, Killion & Hall Insurance Agency provides tailored landlord coverage designed to protect against property damage and liability claims. This agency focuses on policies that account for local building codes and common midwestern weather risks. By reviewing specific rental structures and current lease requirements, their process begins with a detailed assessment of your property’s unique exposures and coverage gaps during an initial on-site inspection.

BF
1800 N Meridian St #103a
Burns Family Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Burns Family Insurance works with Indianapolis property owners to secure essential landlord coverage, including protection for rental dwelling structures and liability. Its specialty add-ons cover loss of rental income and coverage for other structures like fences and sheds. The company can serve clients who own commercial office spaces, warehouse facilities, and food service operations that require tailored liability and property insurance solutions for leased premises.

CI
4955 W Washington St D
CMR Insurance & Services
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

CMR Insurance & Services offers residential landlord insurance in Indianapolis, protecting rental properties from common perils such as fire and liability. Commercial coverage is also available for larger multi-unit buildings and business properties throughout the greater Indianapolis area. Policies are designed to help manage the unique risks property owners face with tenants. The agency can assist with reviewing existing coverage and adjusting limits as needs change. Follow-up support between regular policy reviews helps ensure continued protection as properties evolve over time.

CI
70 91st St #200
Central Insurance Associates
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
MM
6329 Hollister Dr
McClain Matthews Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 298-7500
mcclainmatthewsinsurance.com
CI
6330 E 75th St Suite 200
Capitol Insurance & Risk Management Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 253-1155
shepherdins.com
II
2818 N High School Rd
IAL Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 480-4111
ialinsurance.com
IS
4202 E New York St
Indy Select Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 875-1522
indyselectinsurance.com
II
7360 E Washington St
Irvington Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 322-1000
irvingtoninsurance.com
MI
10475 Crosspoint Blvd Suite 250
Multiline Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 476-6141
multi-lineins.com
LM
350 E 96th St
Liberty Mutual
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 581-6400
libertymutual.com
IA
10412 Swiftsail Ln
Insurance Associates of Indiana
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(463) 255-9844
insai.biz
AI
3115 S Keystone Ave
Anchor Insurance Services LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 559-3347
myanchorins.com
DC
8152 Zionsville Rd
Don Culberson Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 298-3888

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Indianapolis Cost?

The cost of landlord insurance in Indiana typically ranges from 15 to 30 percent more than standard homeowners insurance. For a single family rental, annual premiums often fall between 800 and 1,800 dollars. Factors include property value, location in Indianapolis, coverage limits, and deductible. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Indianapolis

A landlord insurance agent in Indianapolis helps property owners protect their rental investments. Indiana law does not require landlord insurance but mortgage lenders often do. Agents in Indianapolis understand local risks like weather and tenant laws specific to Indiana.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in Indiana?

Landlord insurance typically covers property damage, liability, and lost rental income. In Indiana, policies often exclude flood damage, which requires separate coverage. Agents can explain how Indiana landlord tenant law affects your policy needs.

Is landlord insurance required by Indiana law?

Indiana does not legally require landlord insurance. However, most mortgage lenders require it for rental properties. An agent can help you meet lender requirements while avoiding gaps in coverage.

How do I choose a landlord insurance agent in Indianapolis?

Look for an agent licensed in Indiana with experience in rental property coverage. Ask about their knowledge of Indianapolis specific risks like severe storms. Compare quotes from multiple agents to find suitable coverage and pricing.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.