ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Carmel, IN

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Carmel, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Carmel, Indiana is Dean Ballenger Agency Inc, rated 5.0 stars across 610 reviews. Other highly rated options include Hittle Insurance, Penwell Insurance, BWC Insurance. This directory lists 20 landlord insurance agents serving Carmel.

Showing 20 landlord insurance agents in Carmel, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Dean Ballenger Agency Inc14767 Oak Rd(317) 867-5433
2Hittle Insurance14801 Market Center Dr Suite 130(317) 895-5555
3Penwell Insurance600 E Carmel Dr Suite 162(317) 559-3022
4BWC Insurance13295 Illinois St # 134(317) 324-1489
5ShieldPoint Insurance571 Monon Blvd Ste 200(317) 395-3877
6Goosehead Insurance - Ted King13295 Illinois St Suite 302(317) 975-0303
7Shepherd Insurance111 Congressional Blvd Suite 200(317) 846-5554
8Binford Insurance600 E Carmel Dr #269(317) 588-3825
9Independent Senior Insurance, Inc3309 E 146th St(317) 921-5919
10The DeRoss Insurance Agency1905 S New Market St Suite 265(317) 219-3100
DB
14767 Oak Rd
Dean Ballenger Agency Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Dean Ballenger Agency Inc serves the Carmel, Indiana metro area as a landlord insurance agent providing coverage for residential and commercial rental properties. It helps property owners protect their investments against common risks such as property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income through foreclosure or fire. The agency also handles vacant property endorsements and umbrella liability policies for landlords with multiple units.

HI
14801 Market Center Dr Suite 130
Hittle Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Hittle Insurance provides a comprehensive array of landlord insurance solutions tailored to property owners in the Carmel area. Its services include building and liability coverage, loss of rent protection, and customized risk assessments for rental portfolios. The agency also offers assistance with managing policy renewals and adjusting coverage as property values change. Hittle Insurance services a diverse range of rental properties, including single-family homes, apartment complexes, retail spaces, and local restaurants.

PI
600 E Carmel Dr Suite 162
Penwell Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Penwell Insurance works with homeowners and property managers seeking landlord insurance coverage in Carmel, Indiana. The agency advises clients on policies tailored for residential rental properties, helping to protect against common risks. Services emphasize clear explanation of coverage options for single-family and multi-unit rentals. Landlords receive guidance on liability protection and property damage policies relevant to local regulations. Penwell Insurance extends its landlord insurance services to property owners in nearby Zionsville and the broader Indianapolis metropolitan area as well.

BI
13295 Illinois St # 134
BWC Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

BWC Insurance serves the Carmel, Indiana, area and its surrounding communities, handling landlord insurance policies for property owners. It covers common needs such as property damage, liability protection, and loss of rental income for residential and commercial units. The agency focuses on explaining coverage options clearly so landlords can match policies to their specific rental properties. For each client, it assesses local risks like weather damage or tenant issues to recommend a tailored policy that balances necessary protection with manageable costs.

SI
571 Monon Blvd Ste 200
ShieldPoint Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

ShieldPoint Insurance specializes in crafting tailored liability and property coverage plans for residential and commercial landlords in the Carmel area. The agency routinely assesses local rental risks to ensure policies address both routine maintenance issues and major structural damages. Its general service work includes monthly policy reviews and claims support. Particularly during the harsh Indiana winter months, it helps property owners address potential ice dam damage, frozen pipe liability, and tenant safety concerns that arise from seasonal weather extremes.

GI
13295 Illinois St Suite 302
Goosehead Insurance - Ted King
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

As winter approaches in Carmel, property owners look for coverage that includes frozen pipe protection and liability for slip-and-fall claims. Goosehead Insurance - Ted King focuses specifically on landlord insurance for single-family rentals and multi-unit properties in the area. They review each policy to confirm it matches local vacancy requirements and common tenant damage risks. An initial property assessment is scheduled to identify specific coverage needs before quoting.

SI
111 Congressional Blvd Suite 200
Shepherd Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Shepherd Insurance serves property owners in Carmel, IN, by offering both one-time policy setups for new acquisitions and recurring coverage plans for ongoing rental portfolios. Their landlord insurance agent work addresses liability protection and property damage risks common to local residential rentals. Service operates on both a scheduled and an as-needed basis, accommodating seasonal updates or emergency policy adjustments as tenant circumstances change.

BI
600 E Carmel Dr #269
Binford Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Binford Insurance provides landlord insurance coverage for property owners in the Carmel, Indiana area. The agency specializes in additional policy options such as liability protection and loss of rental income coverage to safeguard investment properties. Commercial property owners can secure policies tailored to risks associated with managing offices, warehouses, and food service operations. Each policy is structured to address the specific liability and property damage exposures that arise when leasing different types of commercial spaces.

IS
3309 E 146th St
Independent Senior Insurance, Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Independent Senior Insurance, Inc in Carmel, IN serves as a landlord insurance agent providing residential coverage for rental properties. The agency also offers commercial insurance solutions for local real estate investors and property owners throughout the Carmel area. Policies are designed to protect against common risks such as property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income. Property owners can expect clear guidance when selecting appropriate coverage options and reliable assistance with claims processing. The agency maintains regular contact with clients and coordinates follow-up service between annual policy reviews.

DI
1905 S New Market St Suite 265
The DeRoss Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

The DeRoss Insurance Agency in Carmel, IN, is recognized for its focus on landlord insurance, providing property owners with coverage options tailored to rental dwellings. It serves local investors by addressing risks such as property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income. The agency assists with policies that combine cost-effective protection with essential financial safeguards for residential and commercial rental properties. Its specialty includes offering flood and earthquake endorsements as practical add-ons for comprehensive risk management.

GI
600 E Carmel Dr SUITE 136
Goosehead Insurance - Simon Sefton
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 522-6910
goosehead.com/agents/in/carmel/simon-sefton
RO
231 Lark Dr Unit 1
Rain or Shine Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 601-7472
rainorshineinsurance.com
RI
40 Executive Dr # C
Rupp Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 848-7241
rjruppinsurance.com
FI
110 N Rangeline Rd
Fearrin Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 846-4275
fearrininsurance.com
SI
301 E Carmel Dr SUITE C500
Sunday Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 571-5200
sundayins.com
AS
10 E Main St Suite 400
AssuredPartners
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 844-7759
assuredpartners.com/Carmel
JA
4728 Lisborn Dr
James Allen Insurance Brokers
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(800) 965-5580
jamesalleninsurance.com
RJ
40 Executive Dr # C
R.J. Rupp Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 848-7241
rjruppinsurance.com
MI
468 Gradle Dr
Mutual Insurance IN
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 207-6490
SA
580 E Carmel Dr #209
Schindel Agency LLC - Nationwide Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 846-1000
schindelagency.com

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Carmel Cost?

The cost of landlord insurance in Indiana typically ranges from 500 to 1500 dollars per year for a single family rental property. Factors include property value location and coverage limits. In Carmel rates may be higher due to property values and claims history. This is general information not insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Carmel

A landlord insurance agent in Carmel Indiana helps property owners protect their rental investments. Indiana law does not require landlord insurance but mortgage lenders often do. Agents in Carmel understand local risks like severe weather and tenant liability issues specific to Hamilton County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in Indiana?

Landlord insurance typically covers property damage liability and loss of rental income. In Indiana policies often include coverage for vandalism fire and weather events like hail. It does not cover tenant personal property.

Is landlord insurance required by Indiana law?

Indiana law does not require landlord insurance. However your mortgage lender may require it as a condition of the loan. Many landlords also carry it to protect against liability claims and property damage.

How do I choose a landlord insurance agent in Carmel?

Look for an agent who specializes in rental property coverage and knows Indiana landlord tenant laws. Ask about coverage for specific risks like water damage from frozen pipes. Compare quotes from multiple agents to find a suitable policy.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.