ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Fishers, IN

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Fishers, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Fishers, Indiana is Clint Wilson - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 315 reviews. Other highly rated options include DeWitt Insurance Group, Priority Risk Management Inc., Ray Insurance Group. This directory lists 17 landlord insurance agents serving Fishers.

Showing 17 landlord insurance agents in Fishers, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Clint Wilson - State Farm Insurance Agent13577 126th St(317) 578-1100
2DeWitt Insurance Group8100 E 106th St Suite 260(317) 537-9054
3Priority Risk Management Inc.7050 E 116th St #200(317) 713-2959
4Ray Insurance Group11411 Overlook Dr(317) 841-9995
5Osborn Insurance Agency8665 Edison Plaza Dr Suite 1101(317) 577-2445
6Butler Insurance10765 Allisonville Rd(317) 849-7121
7Mehar Insurance Agency, Inc12574 Promise Creek Ln STE 114(317) 900-5151
8Source Insurance Group8388 E 116th St(317) 565-2320
9Brent Turner Agency10079 Forest Meadow Circle(317) 363-0752
10First Priority Insurance9742 Olympia Dr(317) 602-1306
CW
13577 126th St
Clint Wilson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

Clint Wilson - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Fishers, Indiana, metro area as a specialized landlord insurance agent. The agency helps property owners secure coverage for rental homes, duplexes, and multi-unit dwellings. It focuses on protecting against common risks, such as property damage from tenants or weather events. Policies also address liability claims that arise from rented premises. For local landlords, the agency handles claims assistance and policy adjustments for new rental properties.

DI
8100 E 106th St Suite 260
DeWitt Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

DeWitt Insurance Group provides a full range of landlord insurance solutions, including property coverage and customizable liability protection for rental investments. It offers preventative risk assessments and responsive claims assistance to help owners recover quickly from damage or tenant issues. Maintenance plans focus on routine property upkeep to reduce long-term hazards and claims. The firm serves properties such as single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants in and around Fishers, Indiana.

PR
7050 E 116th St #200
Priority Risk Management Inc.
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

Priority Risk Management Inc. provides residential landlord insurance services for property owners in Fishers, Indiana, and also offers commercial coverage to meet broader investment needs. Their agents work with local landlords to structure policies that protect rental properties from common risks. They then ensure ongoing support and policy adjustments are available between regular property visits for their clients.

RI
11411 Overlook Dr
Ray Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

Ray Insurance Group serves Fishers, Indiana, and the surrounding communities in Hamilton County. As a landlord insurance agent, it handles policies for residential rental properties, from single-family homes to small multi-unit buildings. It helps property owners protect against losses from property damage, liability claims, and lost rental income. For a typical job, the agent begins by assessing the landlord's specific property types and coverage needs, then compares policy options from multiple carriers before recommending a tailored plan.

OI
8665 Edison Plaza Dr Suite 1101
Osborn Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

Osborn Insurance Agency serves landlords and property managers in Fishers, Indiana, offering tailored coverage for residential and small commercial rental properties. The agency helps clients protect their investments against common risks such as property damage and liability claims. Its policies are designed to support both experienced investors and those new to renting out homes. In addition to serving Fishers, the agency also provides landlord insurance solutions to property owners in the surrounding Carmel area.

BI
10765 Allisonville Rd
Butler Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

For landlords in Fishers, IN, Butler Insurance offers both one-time policy placements for single properties and recurring portfolio management for multiple units. Their coverage typically safeguards rental income, building structures, liability exposures, and loss of rents. Services address common local landlord risks such as weather damage, tenant disputes, and maintenance-related claims. Scheduling is available on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis to match each property owner’s unique rental cycle.

MI
12574 Promise Creek Ln STE 114
Mehar Insurance Agency, Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

Mehar Insurance Agency, Inc offers tailored landlord insurance policies, covering property damage and liability protection. It serves property owners in Fishers, IN, by addressing risks unique to rental units and helping secure appropriate coverage. The agency assists landlords in managing insurance needs throughout the leasing process, from tenant turnover to routine maintenance. During harsh Indiana winters, it helps clients address potential losses from frozen pipes or ice dam damage that can affect rental properties.

SI
8388 E 116th St
Source Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

Source Insurance Group provides property insurance solutions for owners who rent out residential or commercial real estate in the Fishers area. The company helps landlords protect their properties against risks such as fire, weather damage, and liability claims. Their specialty add-ons include coverage for loss of rental income and protection for structures under renovation. This insurance agent serves commercial sectors ranging from small office buildings to warehouses and food service establishments.

BT
10079 Forest Meadow Circle
Brent Turner Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN

With temperatures dropping in Fishers, rental property owners often prepare plumbing systems for freezing risks. Brent Turner Agency provides landlord insurance agents who tailor coverage for these seasonal exposures. Policies focus on liability protection and property damage to residential or commercial rentals. Each client’s portfolio is analyzed for vacancy hazards, tenant-related claims, and seasonal maintenance gaps. Before issuing a policy, the agent schedules an initial property inspection to document current conditions and confirm the structure meets underwriting requirements.

FP
9742 Olympia Dr
First Priority Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN
AI
8475 Nightfall Ln
AMJ Insurance, Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN
(317) 735-4072
associationmembersinsurance.com
LI
14074 Trade Center Dr #104
Luxor Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN
(317) 774-7740
luxorinsgrp.com
BA
10106 Brooks School Rd #200
Bozzelli & Associates Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN
(317) 451-9501
bozzelliins.com
GI
12574 Promise Creek Ln
The George Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN
(317) 524-1555
thegeorgeagency.com
RG
10765 Lantern Rd
Realty Group Insurance LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN
(888) 608-2780
realtygroupinsurance.com
WI
11650 Lantern Rd #133
Winchell Insurance Group
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN
(317) 544-8091
winchellinsurance.com
WC
11650 Lantern Rd # 229
Warner-Cox Insurance Services
Landlord Insurance Agent · Fishers, IN
(317) 576-8509
warnercox.com

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Fishers Cost?

Landlord insurance in Indiana typically costs 15 to 25 percent more than standard homeowners insurance. For a single-family rental in Fishers expect annual premiums between 800 and 1,500 dollars. Costs depend on property value location and coverage limits. This is general information not insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Fishers

Landlord insurance agents in Fishers Indiana help rental property owners protect their investments. Indiana law does not require landlord insurance but mortgage lenders often do. Local agents can explain coverage options for single-family homes and multi-unit properties in Hamilton County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in Indiana?

Landlord insurance typically covers property damage, liability, and lost rental income. In Indiana policies may also cover vandalism and weather damage common in the Midwest. Each policy is different so ask your agent for details.

Do I need landlord insurance for a rental in Fishers?

While Indiana law does not require landlord insurance most mortgage lenders do. Without it you could be personally liable for tenant injuries or property damage. An agent can help you meet lender requirements and protect your assets.

How do I find a landlord insurance agent in Fishers Indiana?

You can search online for independent agents in Fishers who specialize in rental properties. Many local agencies offer quotes for multiple insurers. Ask about coverage for short-term rentals if you use platforms like Airbnb.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.