ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Umbrella Insurance Agents Near You in St Peters, MO

Browse umbrella insurance agents serving St Peters, Missouri. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated umbrella insurance agent in St Peters, Missouri is Sarah Schwartz at Comparion Insurance Agency, rated 5.0 stars across 134 reviews. Other highly rated options include Marc Bernstein at Comparion Insurance Agency, Mathenia Insurance Group LLC, Jennifer Wadlow at Comparion Insurance Agency. This directory lists 12 umbrella insurance agents serving St Peters.

Showing 12 umbrella insurance agents in St Peters, MOListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Sarah Schwartz at Comparion Insurance Agency6141 Mid Rivers Mall Dr(314) 270-0951
2Marc Bernstein at Comparion Insurance Agency6141 Mid Rivers Mall Dr(314) 270-0927
3Mathenia Insurance Group LLC1405 Jungermann Rd D(636) 922-5250
4Jennifer Wadlow at Comparion Insurance Agency6141 Mid Rivers Mall Dr(314) 543-4635
5Risinger Insurance Agency330 Jungermann Rd(636) 441-7700
6Brightside Insurance Agency (MO)111 Main St(636) 346-7021
7Goosehead Insurance - Derek Burr1000 Mid Rivers Mall Dr Suite #5(636) 534-1446
8Farmers Insurance - Jeffrey Flowerree4101 Mexico Rd Ste H(636) 946-8280
9Katelyn McCarty at Comparion Insurance Agency6141 Mid Rivers Mall Dr(314) 270-0928
10AAA Saint Peters Insurance and Member Services591 Mid Rivers Mall Dr(636) 279-2299
SS
6141 Mid Rivers Mall Dr
Sarah Schwartz at Comparion Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

Sarah Schwartz at Comparion Insurance Agency serves the St. Peters, Missouri, metro area and specializes in umbrella insurance agent services. An umbrella policy provides an extra layer of personal liability coverage beyond standard home and auto limits. This professional helps clients protect their assets against large claims or lawsuits. The agency assists local residents with increasing their overall liability protection and securing coverage for emergencies that exceed primary policy ceilings.

MB
6141 Mid Rivers Mall Dr
Marc Bernstein at Comparion Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

At Marc Bernstein at Comparion Insurance Agency in St Peters, MO, the range of services includes providing umbrella insurance policies that extend additional liability coverage beyond standard home and auto policies. Their service involves assessing individual risk exposures to recommend appropriate policy limits for broader protection. Routine maintenance includes policy reviews to adjust coverage as personal assets or circumstances change. This agency services properties such as single-family homes, apartments, retail stores, and restaurants seeking an extra layer of financial security.

MI
1405 Jungermann Rd D
Mathenia Insurance Group LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

Mathenia Insurance Group LLC serves homeowners, businesses, and property managers in St Peters, MO, by securing umbrella insurance policies that provide additional liability coverage beyond standard limits. This type of policy helps protect assets from major claims and lawsuits. The agent works with clients to assess their unique risk exposures and find appropriate coverage levels. Serving the greater metro area, the company also offers its services to residents and commercial operations in the neighboring community of O’Fallon.

JW
6141 Mid Rivers Mall Dr
Jennifer Wadlow at Comparion Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

Serving the St Peters, Missouri area and surrounding communities, Jennifer Wadlow at Comparion Insurance Agency handles high-risk personal liability coverage through umbrella policies. This type of insurance provides additional liability limits above standard auto and homeowners policies, protecting clients against significant financial losses from major accidents or lawsuits. For each client, the agency assesses existing coverage limits and risk exposures, then recommends an umbrella policy that seamlessly extends additional layers of protection to provide comprehensive financial security.

RI
330 Jungermann Rd
Risinger Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

Risinger Insurance Agency, serving St. Peters, MO, offers umbrella insurance through one-time policy purchases and recurring annual renewal options. Coverage extends beyond standard auto or home liability limits to provide an extra layer of financial protection against major claims and lawsuits. This supplemental policy helps safeguard personal assets from unforeseen, catastrophic events that exceed underlying policy ceilings. As a versatile solution, the service operates on a scheduled basis, with policies typically renewed each year to maintain continuous coverage.

BI
111 Main St
Brightside Insurance Agency (MO)
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

Brightside Insurance Agency in St Peters, MO, helps local residents and businesses manage personal liability risks that exceed standard policy limits. The agency specializes in umbrella coverage, offering extended protection against major lawsuits and catastrophic claims. This additional layer of liability insurance safeguards assets like savings and future earnings. Broader policy options can cover incidents not included in underlying homeowners or auto coverage. Appointments are available for commercial entities including offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

GI
1000 Mid Rivers Mall Dr Suite #5
Goosehead Insurance - Derek Burr
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

As spring storms often bring unexpected risks from fallen trees or flash flooding in St. Peters, Goosehead Insurance - Derek Burr helps local homeowners secure umbrella policies to cover major liability claims. This agency focuses on bridging coverage gaps when standard auto or home insurance limits are exhausted. The process begins with a no-obligation review of existing policies to assess how much additional protection a family might need, then moves to an initial risk evaluation.

FI
4101 Mexico Rd Ste H
Farmers Insurance - Jeffrey Flowerree
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

Farmers Insurance - Jeffrey Flowerree provides residential umbrella insurance coverage for homeowners in St Peters, MO seeking added liability protection beyond standard policies. The agency also serves commercial clients in the surrounding area, offering broader coverage layers for business-related risks. Regular policy reviews ensure clients maintain appropriate limits as their circumstances change. After securing initial protection, customers can return to discuss adjustments or additional needs during subsequent visits, allowing the agent to update coverage between scheduled annual check-ins.

KM
6141 Mid Rivers Mall Dr
Katelyn McCarty at Comparion Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

Katelyn McCarty at Comparion Insurance Agency, based in St Peters, MO, is known for providing umbrella insurance coverage designed to extend liability protection beyond standard home and auto policies. The agency serves area residents seeking to safeguard their assets from major claims or lawsuits. Its offerings include personal umbrella policies that address a broad range of risk exposures. For added security, the agency can also integrate excess liability insurance into a client’s existing coverage portfolio.

AS
591 Mid Rivers Mall Dr
AAA Saint Peters Insurance and Member Services
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO

AAA Saint Peters Insurance and Member Services specializes in personal umbrella liability coverage in St Peters, MO. Its agents help clients secure extra liability protection beyond standard auto and homeowners policies, offering broader coverage for accidents or lawsuits. The company also handles general insurance service work, including policy reviews and coverage guidance for local households. For homeowners hosting summer pool parties or holiday gatherings, umbrella insurance can protect assets if a guest is injured on the property.

SI
121 Main St
Shelter Insurance - Michael Flynn
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO
(636) 441-8177
shelterinsurance.com/CA/agent/MFLYNN
TB
7934 Mexico Rd
Tom Bax & Associates LLC American Family Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · St Peters, MO
(314) 298-7770
amfam.com/agents/missouri/saint-peters/Thomas-Bax

What Does an a Umbrella Insurance Agent in St Peters Cost?

In Missouri umbrella insurance costs between 150 and 300 dollars per year for one million dollars of coverage. A two million dollar policy typically costs 250 to 500 dollars annually. Your actual premium depends on your number of vehicles driving record and home value. This is general information not insurance advice.

About umbrella insurance agents in St Peters

Umbrella insurance provides extra liability coverage beyond standard home and auto policies. In St Peters Missouri this coverage can protect your savings and future income from large lawsuits. Missouri law does not require umbrella insurance but it is a smart choice for homeowners and drivers in the St Charles County area.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does an umbrella insurance agent in St Peters do?

An umbrella insurance agent helps you buy a policy that adds one million dollars or more in liability coverage on top of your existing insurance. The agent reviews your current home and auto policies to find the right amount of extra protection. They also explain how Missouri liability laws affect your coverage needs.

How much umbrella coverage do I need in St Peters Missouri?

Most agents recommend at least one million dollars in umbrella coverage for homeowners with a pool or rental property. In Missouri the average home value in St Peters is around 250 thousand dollars so two million dollars of coverage is common for families with significant assets. Your agent can run a personal risk assessment to suggest a specific limit.

Does umbrella insurance cover legal fees in Missouri?

Yes umbrella insurance typically pays for your legal defense costs in covered lawsuits. In Missouri the policy usually covers lawyer fees court costs and settlements up to your coverage limit. This protection applies after your underlying home or auto policy has paid its limit.

Umbrella Insurance Agents in Other Missouri Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each umbrella insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.