ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Umbrella Insurance Agents Near You in Carmel, IN

Browse umbrella insurance agents serving Carmel, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated umbrella insurance agent in Carmel, Indiana is Dean Ballenger Agency Inc, rated 5.0 stars across 610 reviews. Other highly rated options include Hittle Insurance, Penwell Insurance, BWC Insurance. This directory lists 21 umbrella insurance agents serving Carmel.

Showing 21 umbrella insurance agents in Carmel, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Dean Ballenger Agency Inc14767 Oak Rd(317) 867-5433
2Hittle Insurance14801 Market Center Dr Suite 130(317) 895-5555
3Penwell Insurance600 E Carmel Dr Suite 162(317) 559-3022
4BWC Insurance13295 Illinois St # 134(317) 324-1489
5ShieldPoint Insurance571 Monon Blvd Ste 200(317) 395-3877
6Goosehead Insurance - Ted King13295 Illinois St Suite 302(317) 975-0303
7The DeRoss Insurance Agency1905 S New Market St Suite 265(317) 219-3100
8Hoffman Insurance Strategies580 E Carmel Dr SUITE 301(317) 991-1101
9Paige Sutherlin at Comparion Insurance AgencyHamilton Crossing IV, 12900 N Meridian St Suite 250(317) 814-7853
10Rain or Shine Insurance231 Lark Dr Unit 1(317) 601-7472
DB
14767 Oak Rd
Dean Ballenger Agency Inc
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Dean Ballenger Agency Inc serves homeowners, property managers, and small businesses in Carmel, Indiana, that require added liability protection beyond standard policies. The agency specializes in securing umbrella insurance to cover significant claims or lawsuits that could otherwise exhaust primary coverage limits. Clients value the straightforward guidance through policy selection and the local knowledge of Indiana’s insurance landscape. The agency also extends its services to neighboring communities such as Fishers, providing updated coverage options for both residential and commercial policyholders throughout the surrounding suburban metro area.

HI
14801 Market Center Dr Suite 130
Hittle Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Umbrella insurance typically provides a one-time policy to extend liability coverage beyond standard policies, rather than recurring service schedules. Hittle Insurance, located in Carmel, IN, helps clients secure this extra layer of protection against major claims. The company assists individuals and businesses in choosing appropriate limits for their specific needs. This service operates on a one-time basis, as once an umbrella policy is purchased, it renews annually without requiring repeated enrollment procedures for each coverage period.

PI
600 E Carmel Dr Suite 162
Penwell Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

As spring rains and thaws increase the risk of water damage and liability across central Indiana, residents in Carmel and surrounding areas seek adequate protection beyond standard homeowner policies. Penwell Insurance in Carmel provides umbrella insurance policies designed to offer clients an extra layer of coverage against major claims and lawsuits. Focusing on tailored risk management, the company works with individuals to fill gaps often left by underlying auto or home insurance. The process begins with a thorough assessment of a client's existing policies to determine the appropriate coverage limit.

BI
13295 Illinois St # 134
BWC Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

BWC Insurance provides general liability and property coverage to individuals and businesses in Carmel, Indiana. It specializes in offering umbrella insurance policies that extend additional liability protection beyond standard policy limits. These policies help safeguard clients against large claims or lawsuits that could exceed underlying coverage. The agency’s umbrella insurance supports risk management for various commercial sectors, including offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

SI
571 Monon Blvd Ste 200
ShieldPoint Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

ShieldPoint Insurance provides residential umbrella liability coverage for homeowners in Carmel, Indiana, extending protection beyond standard policies. The agency also offers commercial umbrella insurance to safeguard local businesses against major claims or lawsuits. Serving the broader surrounding communities, the team works to assess each client’s unique risk profile and policy limits. Customers appreciate the clear explanations and personalized service, which encourages them to contact the office again when their coverage needs change or between regular policy review visits.

GI
13295 Illinois St Suite 302
Goosehead Insurance - Ted King
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Goosehead Insurance - Ted King in Carmel, Indiana, is known for offering personalized umbrella insurance solutions to local residents and businesses. The agency helps clients increase their liability coverage beyond standard home and auto policies, providing an extra layer of financial protection against major claims or lawsuits. Its services are tailored to the needs of the Carmel community, ensuring individuals and families can safeguard their assets from unexpected events. Additionally, the agency specializes in coordinating umbrella policies with existing homeowners and auto insurance for seamless coverage.

DI
1905 S New Market St Suite 265
The DeRoss Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

The DeRoss Insurance Agency serves the Carmel, Indiana area as a provider of umbrella insurance coverage. Umbrella insurance gives policyholders additional liability protection beyond the limits of their standard home and auto policies, offering a crucial safety net against major claims or lawsuits. This firm works with clients to assess their personal risk exposure and secure appropriate liability layers. The agency handles personalized policy reviews and coordination of higher-limit liability policies that protect assets.

HI
580 E Carmel Dr SUITE 301
Hoffman Insurance Strategies
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Hoffman Insurance Strategies provides comprehensive umbrella insurance coverage, extending liability protection beyond the limits of standard homeowners and auto policies. The company assists clients in reviewing existing coverage to identify potential gaps and tailors additional protection to address individual risk exposure. Regular policy reviews and adjustments are available to maintain appropriate coverage levels as circumstances change. This firm serves a variety of properties in Carmel, Indiana, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

PS
Hamilton Crossing IV, 12900 N Meridian St Suite 250
Paige Sutherlin at Comparion Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Serving homeowners, businesses, and property managers in Carmel, Indiana, Paige Sutherlin at Comparion Insurance Agency provides umbrella policies that extend extra liability coverage beyond standard home or auto limits. This additional layer of protection helps safeguard personal assets and future earnings against major claims or lawsuits. An umbrella insurance agent evaluates each client’s existing coverage to recommend an appropriate level of protection tailored to their individual risks and lifestyle needs. The agency also serves clients throughout the Indianapolis metro area, including nearby communities such as Fishers.

RO
231 Lark Dr Unit 1
Rain or Shine Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN

Rain or Shine Insurance serves Carmel, Indiana, and the surrounding communities in Hamilton County. The agency handles umbrella insurance policies that provide extra liability coverage beyond standard home and auto limits. Protecting clients from major claims and lawsuits is the core of what it does. An umbrella policy from this agent can cover legal defense costs and pay for damages when underlying insurance is exhausted. For each client, the agency first reviews existing personal coverage, then calculates the appropriate additional liability limit and issues the policy.

MI
11939 N Meridian St
Midwest Insurance Indiana
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 349-7943
SI
1320 City Center Dr
Special Insurance Brokers LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 349-7954
NI
11590 N Meridian St
National Insurance Services CO
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 349-4641
GI
4000 W 106th St PMB#125-272
Gregg Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 344-2009
greggins.com
SI
11455 N Meridian St
Superb Insurance IN
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(574) 281-9296
SI
301 E Carmel Dr SUITE C500
Sunday Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 571-5200
sundayins.com
SF
102 Congressional Blvd
Safe Fest Insurance Co
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 279-5023
CM
113 Veterans Wy
Cover Me Insurance Service
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 406-7819
MI
468 Gradle Dr
Mutual Insurance IN
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 207-6490
NI
160 W Carmel Dr Suite 228
NSB Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 575-2900
nsb-insurance.com
UI
472 E Carmel Dr
United Insurance IN
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Carmel, IN
(317) 814-8244

What Does an a Umbrella Insurance Agent in Carmel Cost?

Umbrella insurance in Indiana typically costs between 150 and 300 dollars per year for one million dollars in coverage. Higher limits of two to five million dollars may cost 300 to 600 dollars annually. Costs vary based on your personal risk factors and the insurance carrier. This is general information not insurance advice.

About umbrella insurance agents in Carmel

Umbrella insurance agents in Carmel Indiana help residents secure extra liability protection beyond standard auto and home policies. Indiana law does not require umbrella insurance but it can safeguard assets from large claims or lawsuits. Agents in Carmel guide clients through policy limits and coverage gaps specific to Indiana legal standards.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does an umbrella insurance agent in Carmel do?

An umbrella insurance agent in Carmel helps you purchase a personal liability umbrella policy that provides additional coverage above your existing auto and homeowners insurance. They assess your risk profile and recommend appropriate limits based on Indiana legal exposure.

How much umbrella coverage do I need in Indiana?

Most agents recommend starting with one million dollars in umbrella coverage for Indiana residents. Your specific needs depend on your assets income and potential liability risks such as a home pool or rental property.

Does Indiana law affect umbrella insurance requirements?

Indiana follows a modified comparative fault rule which can affect how liability is allocated in lawsuits. Umbrella insurance helps cover defense costs and judgments that exceed your primary policy limits regardless of Indiana fault rules.

Umbrella Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each umbrella insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.