ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeBusiness Insurance AgentsOhio › Lancaster

Find Business Insurance Agents Near You in Lancaster, OH

Browse business insurance agents serving Lancaster, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated business insurance agent in Lancaster, Ohio is Vonnie McDonald - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 326 reviews. Other highly rated options include Xan Vargo - State Farm Insurance Agent, Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC, Bill Palmer Insurance Inc. This directory lists 20 business insurance agents serving Lancaster.

Showing 20 business insurance agents in Lancaster, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Vonnie McDonald - State Farm Insurance Agent3036 Columbus-Lancaster Rd NW(740) 785-5650
2Xan Vargo - State Farm Insurance Agent163 E 5th Ave(740) 571-0307
3Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC804 W Fair Ave(740) 653-4339
4Bill Palmer Insurance Inc725 E Main St(740) 687-5733
5Direct Auto Insurance2687 N Memorial Dr(740) 205-6061
6Wentz Insurance Agency Inc1601 E Main St(740) 653-5535
7Frear Insurance Services Inc343 E Main St(740) 653-1236
8McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services110 N Columbus St Ste 107(740) 653-5230
9Mitchell Insurance Agency1518 E Main St(740) 687-6258
10Putnam White Lewis Insurance824 N Columbus St(740) 653-0602
VM
3036 Columbus-Lancaster Rd NW
Vonnie McDonald - State Farm Insurance Agent
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Vonnie McDonald - State Farm Insurance Agent serves clients throughout Lancaster, OH, and the surrounding Fairfield County area. As a local business insurance agent, this office provides coverage options for small and mid-sized companies. Policies help protect against common commercial risks such as property damage and liability claims. Agents assess unique business needs to recommend appropriate coverage levels. This office handles general liability insurance and commercial property insurance for local enterprises.

XV
163 E 5th Ave
Xan Vargo - State Farm Insurance Agent
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Xan Vargo - State Farm Insurance Agent provides a full range of business insurance solutions tailored to local operations in Lancaster, OH. Its service model includes personalized policy reviews and claims assistance to ensure ongoing coverage adjustments as businesses grow or change. The agent also offers regular consultation to help clients reassess risk exposures and update liability limits. This practice services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants, addressing the specific liability and property needs of each property type.

MI
804 W Fair Ave
Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Miller Insurance & Financial Group, LLC serves homeowners, small business owners, and commercial property managers in Lancaster, Ohio. This business insurance agent helps local enterprises secure coverage for liability, property damage, and operational risks. The agency also advises clients on financial strategies related to their commercial insurance needs. It assists with claims management and policy renewals to ensure ongoing protection. Coverage extends to nearby communities such as Pickerington and the surrounding Fairfield County area.

BP
725 E Main St
Bill Palmer Insurance Inc
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

A business works with a business insurance agent to purchase a one-time policy for a specific project or recurring coverage for ongoing operations. Bill Palmer Insurance Inc in Lancaster, OH helps local companies select appropriate general liability and property coverage to protect their assets. The agent recognizes that each enterprise requires a unique risk assessment and tailored policy structure. Service is available on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis to accommodate changing business needs.

DA
2687 N Memorial Dr
Direct Auto Insurance
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Direct Auto Insurance serves Lancaster, Ohio, and the surrounding communities, handling a range of commercial insurance needs for local businesses. The agency helps clients secure coverage for general liability, property, and workers' compensation, among other essential protections. Every evaluation begins with a review of the customer's specific operations and risk exposure to identify appropriate policy limits and necessary endorsements. For a typical job, the agent then compares available options from multiple carriers to present a clear breakdown of coverage and costs before finalizing a tailored business policy.

WI
1601 E Main St
Wentz Insurance Agency Inc
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

As a business insurance agent in Lancaster, OH, Wentz Insurance Agency Inc offers specialty services such as tailored property coverage and liability protection for various local enterprises. It also provides general commercial insurance work to help small and midsize businesses manage their everyday operational risks. The agency assists with navigating common situational concerns, including preparing for seasonal inventory shifts that affect coverage limits during the holiday rush or summer market seasons in the Lancaster area.

FI
343 E Main St
Frear Insurance Services Inc
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

When Lancaster businesses face the seasonal shift of winter storms or summer heat waves, Frear Insurance Services Inc reviews coverage to address weather-related interruptions and property exposures. As a business insurance agent, this agency structures commercial policies that match local retail, service, and trades operations. After discussing operational risks and liability needs, the agent conducts a thorough on-site inspection of the business premises to identify any physical exposures.

MI
110 N Columbus St Ste 107
McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services in Lancaster, OH assists local residents with their personal insurance needs. The agency also provides commercial coverage for businesses needing protection for their operations and assets. Their service area includes the Lancaster community and surrounding parts of Fairfield County. They work with clients to explain policy details and potential gaps in coverage. When regular visits are made to update policies or review changes, the agency follows up to ensure any adjustments are properly applied before the next scheduled check-in.

MI
1518 E Main St
Mitchell Insurance Agency
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Mitchell Insurance Agency, located in Lancaster, OH, provides business insurance agent services. It sources coverage policies tailored for local companies to manage operational risks. The agency specializes in adding liability protection, property insurance, and crucial endorsements such as business interruption coverage. It works with clients to bundle policies for comprehensive asset security and compliance with regional regulations. Commercial sectors its services can serve include offices seeking general liability, warehouses requiring equipment and inventory coverage, and food service establishments needing protection against product and premises risks.

PW
824 N Columbus St
Putnam White Lewis Insurance
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
TM
345 E Main St
Tom Mertz Insurance
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 687-1010
insurancelancasteroh.com
BI
1424 Ety Pointe Dr NW
Brightway Insurance, The Kaminsky Agency
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 654-7782
brightwaykaminsky.com
OI
110 E Main St
Otto Insurance Group
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-4004
otto-ins.com/locations/lancaster-oh
CI
414 E Main St # 100
Clark Insurance
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-8623
clarkins.com
SI
169 W Fair Ave B
Shelter Insurance - Jessica Wilkins
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 785-5025
shelterinsurance.com/CA/agent/JWILKINS
GI
711 W Fair Ave
Gibson Insurance Agency
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-7111
garygibsoninsurance.com
EI
402 S Broad St
Easy Insurance Co
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 309-3203
FI
118 W Mulberry St
Farmers Insurance - Mark Reynolds
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(614) 808-4730
agents.farmers.com/oh/lancaster/dawn-reynolds
WI
400 N Memorial Dr
Wichert Insurance
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 654-0532
wichert.com
MI
802 W Fair Ave
Miller Insurance & Financial: Heston Rita
Business Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-4339
millerinsuranceandfinancialgroup.com/about-our-agency/meet-our-team

What Does a a Business Insurance Agent in Lancaster Cost?

Typical costs for a small business insurance policy in Ohio range from $500 to $3,000 per year for general liability. Workers compensation premiums vary by industry and payroll, often between $0.50 and $2.00 per $100 of payroll. Commercial property insurance may add $500 to $2,000 annually. These are estimates only. Your actual cost depends on your business type, location, claims history, and coverage limits. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About business insurance agents in Lancaster

Business insurance agents in Lancaster, Ohio help local companies find coverage for general liability, property damage, and workers compensation. Ohio law requires most employers to carry workers compensation insurance through the Ohio Bureau of Workers Compensation or a certified private carrier. A local agent can explain how these requirements apply to your business in Fairfield County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of business insurance are common in Lancaster Ohio?

Common policies include general liability, commercial property, workers compensation, and commercial auto. Many agents also offer business interruption and professional liability coverage. The right mix depends on your industry and number of employees.

Does Ohio require businesses to have workers compensation insurance?

Yes, Ohio law requires most employers to provide workers compensation coverage. You can get this through the Ohio Bureau of Workers Compensation or a certified private carrier. An agent can help you understand the specific requirements for your business.

How do I choose a business insurance agent in Lancaster?

Look for an agent who is licensed in Ohio and has experience with your type of business. Ask about their knowledge of local risks in Fairfield County. Compare quotes from multiple agents to find a policy that fits your budget and needs.

Business Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each business insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.