ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Mentor, OH

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Mentor, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Mentor, Ohio is Farmers Insurance - Matt Mormile, rated 4.8 stars across 196 reviews. Other highly rated options include Bosu Insurance Group, Baehr Insurance Agency, Inc, Furlong & Co. Insurance Agency Inc. This directory lists 18 supplemental insurance agents serving Mentor.

Showing 18 supplemental insurance agents in Mentor, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Farmers Insurance - Matt Mormile7538 Mentor Ave(440) 901-5596
2Bosu Insurance Group8619 Mentor Ave(440) 954-9500
3Baehr Insurance Agency, Inc7464 Mentor Ave(440) 525-3923
4Furlong & Co. Insurance Agency Inc8810 Tyler Blvd(216) 486-4170
5Slowey Insurance Agency, LTD7352 Center St(440) 255-3411
6Corsaro Insurance Group8039 Broadmoor Rd(440) 946-4950
7Platinum Insurance7200 Center St Suite 328(833) 299-2100
8Thomas E. Pyle Ins Now w/ Dan Snyder Ins Agency9930 Johnnycake Ridge Rd Suite 5B(440) 357-8001
9Lake Shore Insurance Agency9167 Mentor Ave(440) 701-6900
10Mutsko Insurance Services, LLC6982 Spinach Dr(440) 255-5700
FI
7538 Mentor Ave
Farmers Insurance - Matt Mormile
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Farmers Insurance - Matt Mormile serves Lake County, Ohio, including the Mentor area, as a supplemental insurance agent. This agency helps clients fill coverage gaps left by standard health or life policies, offering protection for unexpected medical and income needs. Supplemental insurance plans can provide direct cash benefits for hospital stays, accidents, or critical illnesses. The agency assists local residents and small businesses in selecting policies that support financial stability during emergencies. Services include accident and hospital indemnity insurance.

BI
8619 Mentor Ave
Bosu Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Based in Mentor, OH, Bosu Insurance Group provides supplemental insurance coverage to help fill gaps in primary health plans. It offers assistance with selecting and enrolling in policies that address specific needs like accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity. The agency supports clients throughout the year with claims guidance, policy updates, and periodic coverage reviews to ensure plans remain suitable. It services a diverse range of local properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants within the Mentor area.

BI
7464 Mentor Ave
Baehr Insurance Agency, Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Homeowners and property managers in the Mentor area turn to Baehr Insurance Agency, Inc for supplemental insurance coverage that helps fill gaps left by standard policies. This local agency assists clients in selecting plans that address specific needs not covered by primary insurance, offering guidance on available options. Its services cater to individuals and small businesses seeking added protection. The agency also serves communities throughout Lake County, including the surrounding parts of northeastern Ohio.

FC
8810 Tyler Blvd
Furlong & Co. Insurance Agency Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Furlong & Co. Insurance Agency Inc serves clients in Mentor, OH, and the surrounding Lake County communities. As a supplemental insurance agent, it handles gap coverage for Medicare beneficiaries, along with ancillary policies for dental, vision, and accident-related expenses. The agency works with individuals to identify specific coverage needs that traditional health plans leave unmet. For a typical job, it follows a consultation process to compare available plans, explain policy details clearly, and then facilitate the enrollment with the appropriate carrier.

SI
7352 Center St
Slowey Insurance Agency, LTD
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

At Slowey Insurance Agency, LTD in Mentor, OH, a client first chooses between a single-policy purchase and an ongoing plan for continuous protection, with supplemental insurance covering expenses major medical plans often leave out. These policies typically include benefits for hospital stays, accidents, or critical illnesses, bridging gaps like deductibles and copayments. Service appointments are arranged on an as-needed basis, with no set schedule for claims or consultations.

CI
8039 Broadmoor Rd
Corsaro Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Corsaro Insurance Group specializes in supplemental insurance, offering policies such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage. It assists individuals and families in Mentor, Ohio, with bridging the gaps left by primary health plans. Its consultation process focuses on identifying personal coverage needs through a straightforward, no-pressure approach. The company helps clients manage the financial strain that often accompanies seasonal health concerns, such as the increased need for medical care during peak winter illness months.

PI
7200 Center St Suite 328
Platinum Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

As the seasons change in Mentor, supplemental insurance agents like Platinum Insurance help residents prepare for unexpected health or financial gaps that traditional plans may not cover. They assist clients in selecting policies that address specific needs, such as accident or hospital indemnity coverage tailored to local lifestyles. The process begins with a no-obligation review of the client’s current coverage to identify where supplemental benefits would be most valuable, followed by a straightforward in-person inspection of individual circumstances.

TE
9930 Johnnycake Ridge Rd Suite 5B
Thomas E. Pyle Ins Now w/ Dan Snyder Ins Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

As a supplemental insurance agent, Thomas E. Pyle Ins Now w/ Dan Snyder Ins Agency assists individuals and businesses in Mentor, OH, by providing policies that fill gaps left by primary health coverage. These specialized add-ons can include accident, critical illness, and disability income plans. The agency helps clients manage out-of-pocket costs with tailored supplemental benefits. Its coverage options can serve various commercial sectors, including professional offices, distribution warehouses, and food service operations.

LS
9167 Mentor Ave
Lake Shore Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Based in Mentor, Ohio, the Lake Shore Insurance Agency serves clients throughout Lake County and the surrounding communities of northeast Ohio. It handles supplemental insurance plans designed to cover gaps left by major medical policies. This includes options for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage. The agency works by first assessing each individual’s specific healthcare needs and financial situation to recommend appropriate policy features.

MI
6982 Spinach Dr
Mutsko Insurance Services, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH

Mutsko Insurance Services, LLC in Mentor, OH provides supplemental insurance coverage for residential clients, helping to fill gaps left by primary health plans. The agency also offers similar commercial insurance options for local businesses in the Mentor area and surrounding communities. Their agents assist customers in understanding various policy types and selecting appropriate plans. After an initial enrollment, the office schedules follow‑up reviews to adjust coverage as needs change, ensuring clients receive ongoing support between regular visits.

SI
9354 Mentor Ave #15th
Sposito Insurance Agency Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 255-1766
spositoagency.com
SH
7523 Tyler Blvd
Smart Home Insurance Agency Mentor
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 252-0241
LI
7316 Center St
Luikart Insurance Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 974-6700
RS
8339 Tyler Blvd
Risk Strategies
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 205-7400
IE
7519 Mentor Ave Suite A108
Insurance Exchange
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 942-2424
HP
7850 Mentor Ave
Health Plan Superstore
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 508-6757
healthplansuperstore.com
HI
7015 Center St
HealthMarkets Insurance - Dat Thanh Nguyen
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(404) 775-0828
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/dnguyen
LI
8390 Paddock Ct
Lincoln Insurance Group LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mentor, OH
(440) 840-9527
lincolnig.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Mentor Cost?

Costs for supplemental insurance in Ohio vary by plan type and provider. Medigap plans typically range from 100 to 300 dollars per month for a 65-year-old. Rates can change based on age, health, and location. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Mentor

Supplemental insurance agents in Mentor Ohio help residents choose plans that fill gaps in Medicare or employer coverage. Ohio law requires agents to be licensed through the Ohio Department of Insurance. Local agents can explain how Ohio regulations affect plan options and enrollment periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Mentor Ohio?

A licensed professional who helps you compare and enroll in Medigap or other gap-filling plans. They must follow Ohio Department of Insurance rules and can explain local plan availability.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Ohio?

You have a six-month open enrollment period starting when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. Outside this window, Ohio law does not guarantee issue of Medigap policies.

Do Ohio agents have to follow specific rules?

Yes. Ohio law requires agents to disclose their license status and any compensation they receive. They must also follow state guidelines for marketing and plan comparisons.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.