ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Cleveland, OH

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Cleveland, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Cleveland, Ohio is Mike Fabert - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 169 reviews. Other highly rated options include Ralph P. Sills Insurance Agency, Evarts Tremaine, Brooks & Stafford Company. This directory lists 11 supplemental insurance agents serving Cleveland.

Showing 11 supplemental insurance agents in Cleveland, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Mike Fabert - State Farm Insurance AgentHts, 2491 Lee Blvd(216) 932-6900
2Ralph P. Sills Insurance Agency13854 Cedar Rd(216) 321-8033
3Evarts Tremaine1111 Superior Ave Suite 1650(216) 621-7183
4Brooks & Stafford Company55 Public Square #1650(216) 696-3000
5Integrity First Insurance Agency12 Aetna Rd(216) 202-8393
6Washington & Co Insurance Agency10535 St Clair Ave.(216) 761-1500
7Rutledge Insurance13124 Shaker Square(216) 561-4444
8Unquoting Insurance Company3848 W 130th St Lowr(888) 928-9324
9Kelle N Smith Agency LLC1481 Warrensville Center Rd(216) 291-0100
10Anthony Galati Insurance10147 Royalton Rd # B(440) 230-5385
MF
Hts, 2491 Lee Blvd
Mike Fabert - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Mike Fabert - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Cleveland, Ohio, and the surrounding Cuyahoga County area. The agency provides supplemental insurance solutions to individuals and families. These policies can help cover expenses that primary health insurance does not fully address. Typical offerings include accident and hospital indemnity plans. The agency focuses on helping clients manage out-of-pocket costs after medical events. This local office handles cancer insurance and critical illness coverage for residents of the Cleveland metro area.

RP
13854 Cedar Rd
Ralph P. Sills Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Ralph P. Sills Insurance Agency in Cleveland, OH, provides supplemental insurance policies that help cover costs beyond primary health coverage, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. The agency offers ongoing support to help clients understand their benefits and file claims when necessary. They work with individuals and families seeking extra financial protection during medical events. The company also helps local business owners explore coverage options. Their services extend to clients in single‑family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants across the region.

ET
1111 Superior Ave Suite 1650
Evarts Tremaine
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Serving homeowners, local businesses, and property managers in Cleveland, Evarts Tremaine provides supplemental insurance coverage designed to address gaps that standard policies often leave behind. As an agent, it assists clients in selecting policies for unexpected deductibles, co-pays, or loss of income that may result from accidents, illnesses, or property damage. The company works to match individuals and organizations with plans that best suit their specific financial and coverage needs. Its service area also extends throughout the surrounding Cuyahoga County communities, including Lakewood.

BS
55 Public Square #1650
Brooks & Stafford Company
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Brooks & Stafford Company serves Cleveland, Ohio, and its surrounding communities as a supplemental insurance agent. It handles policies designed to cover expenses not fully addressed by primary health plans, including accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage. The agency assists clients in selecting suitable plans from available carriers, ensuring each policy aligns with individual needs and budgets. For a typical job, it follows a straightforward process of reviewing existing coverage, explaining policy options, and guiding clients through the enrollment steps.

IF
12 Aetna Rd
Integrity First Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Integrity First Insurance Agency in Cleveland, OH specializes in providing supplemental insurance policies that help cover gaps in major medical plans. The agency assists clients by explaining and offering products that address expenses like co-pays, deductibles, and hospital stays. Standard plan choices often include accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage. This no-pressure guidance helps individuals find options suited to their needs and budget. The agency is particularly helpful during annual open enrollment periods when many reconsider their overall coverage and seek to add extra protection for the upcoming year.

WC
10535 St Clair Ave.
Washington & Co Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

As winter approaches in Cleveland, residents often worry about gaps in their basic health coverage for unexpected medical expenses. Washington & Co Insurance Agency in Cleveland helps address this need by offering supplemental insurance that can assist with out-of-pocket costs from hospital stays or serious illnesses. For those seeking protection during flu season or unexpected health events, the company reviews individual circumstances and explains available policy options clearly. An initial consultation typically includes a straightforward review of current coverage to identify potential gaps and plan next steps.

RI
13124 Shaker Square
Rutledge Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Rutledge Insurance in Cleveland, Ohio offers both one-time policy reviews and ongoing service plans for supplemental insurance needs, helping clients fill gaps left by major medical coverage such as copays and deductibles. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company provides access to plans that address specific expenses like accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity benefits. Service coordination depends on the plan selected and client preference, operating on either a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis.

UI
3848 W 130th St Lowr
Unquoting Insurance Company
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Unquoting Insurance Company provides supplemental insurance solutions in the Cleveland, Ohio area. Its focus is on helping clients bridge coverage gaps that traditional health plans often leave unfilled, offering specialized add-ons for critical illness, accident recovery, and hospital indemnity. These tailored policies are designed to help individuals manage out-of-pocket costs and income loss during medical events. The company works with various commercial sectors, including corporate offices, industrial warehouses, and food service establishments.

KN
1481 Warrensville Center Rd
Kelle N Smith Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Kelle N Smith Agency LLC serves residential clients in and around Cleveland, Ohio, by helping them select Medicare supplements and other individual health insurance policies. Commercial coverage is also available for small business owners who need group supplemental plans for their employees. The agency focuses on explaining plan options and coordinating new enrollments. Between regular annual enrollment periods, the agent provides follow-up assistance with claims questions or coverage changes, ensuring policyholders remain supported throughout the plan year.

AG
10147 Royalton Rd # B
Anthony Galati Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH

Anthony Galati Insurance is known as a supplemental insurance agent serving the Cleveland, Ohio area. The company works with local residents to identify coverage gaps that standard health plans often leave uncovered, such as accident or critical illness policies. It offers a full range of supplemental products designed to provide financial support for out-of-pocket medical expenses. For clients who need more targeted protection, the agency can also tailor an additional plan specifically for hospital indemnity or specified disease coverage.

NI
18009 Hillgrove Ave
Nest Insurance Solutions
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Cleveland, OH
(216) 543-0114
nestlifehealth.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Cleveland Cost?

Supplemental insurance agent services in Cleveland are usually free to the consumer because agents earn commissions from insurance companies. Medicare Supplement Plan G premiums in Ohio typically range from $100 to $250 per month depending on age and location. Costs vary by case. This is general information not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Cleveland

Supplemental insurance agents in Cleveland Ohio help residents fill gaps in Medicare coverage. Ohio law requires agents to be licensed and follow strict rules when selling Medicare supplement plans. Many Cleveland agents also assist with dental vision and hospital indemnity policies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Cleveland?

A licensed professional who sells Medicare supplement and other gap coverage policies. They help Ohio residents choose plans that pay for costs not covered by Original Medicare.

How do I choose a supplemental insurance agent in Ohio?

Check that the agent is licensed with the Ohio Department of Insurance. Ask about their experience with Medicare Supplement plans and if they represent multiple insurance companies.

Are there Ohio laws for supplemental insurance agents?

Yes. Ohio Revised Code 3901.20 requires agents to provide a clear outline of coverage and disclose any commissions. Ohio also has a 30 day free look period for Medicare supplement policies.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.