ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Columbia, MO

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Columbia, Missouri. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Columbia, Missouri is Senior Benefit Services: SBS, rated 5.0 stars across 458 reviews. Other highly rated options include Stephanie Wilmsmeyer - State Farm Insurance Agent, Insurance Plus, Shelter Insurance - Mitch Theede. This directory lists 20 supplemental insurance agents serving Columbia.

Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Columbia, MOListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Senior Benefit Services: SBS801 Gray Oak Dr(800) 627-2768
2Stephanie Wilmsmeyer - State Farm Insurance Agent2609 E Broadway Ste 214(573) 445-5774
3Insurance Plus1604 Business Loop 70 W(573) 615-0291
4Shelter Insurance - Mitch Theede3201 S Providence Rd Ste 203(573) 443-6080
5Acrisure Columbia, MO (Vogel Stuart Insurance Group)29 N 10th St(573) 449-5395
6Goosehead Insurance - Jeremy Kiesewetter124 E Nifong Blvd Suite C-1(573) 818-2988
7Kasmann Insurance Agency116 N Garth Ave(573) 442-1105
8Auto-Owners Insurance Missouri Regional Office1600 E Pointe Dr(573) 875-0289
9Columbia Insurance Group2102 Whitegate Dr(800) 877-3579
10Gallaher Insurance Group401 Locust St Suite 301(573) 777-9696
SB
801 Gray Oak Dr
Senior Benefit Services: SBS
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Serving the Columbia, Missouri area, Senior Benefit Services, or SBS, works as a supplemental insurance agent. This agency helps individuals manage costs that traditional health plans may not fully cover. It specializes in policies designed to fill coverage gaps. Clients often seek assistance with options that address medical out-of-pocket expenses and income protection. The firm handles specific products such as Medicare Supplement plans and hospital indemnity insurance for local residents.

SW
2609 E Broadway Ste 214
Stephanie Wilmsmeyer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Stephanie Wilmsmeyer - State Farm Insurance Agent offers a range of supplemental insurance solutions for residents and business owners in Columbia, MO. The agency provides personalized coverage options that help fill gaps left by standard health or life policies. Services include consultation for accident, disability, and critical illness plans, with ongoing support for policy maintenance and claims assistance. The company services a variety of local properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

IP
1604 Business Loop 70 W
Insurance Plus
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Serving Columbia, Missouri, and the surrounding communities, Insurance Plus specializes in supplemental insurance agency work. The company handles policies designed to fill coverage gaps left by primary health plans, addressing specific needs like accidents, critical illness, and hospital stays. Clients in the region receive detailed guidance on available policy options to complement their existing benefits. For a typical job, the agent begins with a personalized needs assessment to identify potential coverage shortfalls and then recommends suitable supplemental plans from available carriers.

SI
3201 S Providence Rd Ste 203
Shelter Insurance - Mitch Theede
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Shelter Insurance - Mitch Theede in Columbia, MO provides supplemental insurance that covers gaps left by primary health plans, differing from one-time major medical policies by offering recurring benefit options for specific needs. These ongoing plans typically address accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity costs. Policies are structured to deliver periodic cash benefits directly to policyholders when covered events occur. Service for these supplemental insurance products runs on a scheduled basis, with consistent premium payments and pre-defined coverage terms for as-long-as-needed protection.

AC
29 N 10th St
Acrisure Columbia, MO (Vogel Stuart Insurance Group)
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Serving homeowners, businesses, and property managers in Columbia, Missouri, Acrisure Columbia (Vogel Stuart Insurance Group) works as a supplemental insurance agent to help bridge gaps in standard coverage policies. It offers access to plans that address specific financial exposures not fully covered by primary insurance. These supplemental options can include products for accident recovery or critical illness support. The agency also covers clients in nearby mid-Missouri communities such as Jefferson City.

GI
124 E Nifong Blvd Suite C-1
Goosehead Insurance - Jeremy Kiesewetter
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Goosehead Insurance - Jeremy Kiesewetter in Columbia, MO specializes in providing supplemental insurance policies that help cover gaps left by major medical plans. As a supplemental insurance agent, it assists local residents with selecting coverage options, such as accident, hospital indemnity, or critical illness plans. These policies pay out benefits directly to the policyholder, offering financial flexibility during unexpected health events. Winter months in Columbia often see an increase in seasonal illnesses and slip-and-fall injuries, making supplemental income protection especially valuable around that time.

KI
116 N Garth Ave
Kasmann Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Kasmann Insurance Agency helps individuals and families manage financial gaps not covered by primary health plans. Located in Columbia, Missouri, the agency specializes in supplemental insurance products that provide additional support for expenses like medical deductibles and critical illness treatments. These plans work alongside existing coverage to offer broader financial protection. The agency serves a variety of commercial operations, including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

AO
1600 E Pointe Dr
Auto-Owners Insurance Missouri Regional Office
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

As the seasons change in mid-Missouri, homeowners and drivers often review their coverage for gaps in protection. Auto-Owners Insurance Missouri Regional Office, located in Columbia, helps clients find supplemental insurance policies that fill these voids beyond basic plans. Their agents explain how additional accident, hospital, or disability income policies can provide extra financial security. After a brief discussion of personal risk factors and existing coverage, the process typically moves to a straightforward inspection or assessment of the property or driving profile to confirm eligibility.

CI
2102 Whitegate Dr
Columbia Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO

Columbia Insurance Group focuses primarily on residential supplemental insurance in Columbia, MO, helping homeowners address coverage gaps that traditional plans leave behind. The company also offers commercial supplemental policies for local businesses seeking additional financial protection. Customers across the Columbia area benefit from personalized consultations designed to identify specific needs. After an initial enrollment, the agency provides consistent follow-up service between regular visits, ensuring policyholders can adjust their coverage as circumstances change without waiting for scheduled check-ins.

GI
401 Locust St Suite 301
Gallaher Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
NN
3928 S Providence Rd
Naught Naught Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 874-3102
assuredpartners.com/ColumbiaMO
HA
2100 Whitegate Dr
Harrison Agency Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 474-9537
harrisonagencyinc.com
WS
204 Peach Way Ste B
Wendy Sprouse
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 292-6373
wendysprouseagency.com
TA
200 E Southampton Dr
TIG Advisors
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 875-4800
tigadvisors.com
BL
1000 W Nifong Blvd #8-200
Bankers Life
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 449-3979
branches.bankerslife.com/mo/columbia/1000-w-nifong-blvd
MO
910 N College Ave
Mutual of Omaha
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 449-0359
mutualofomaha.com
LA
401 Locust St Ste 304
Legacy Advisors
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 554-5975
legacyadvisorsgroup.com
CA
2100 E Broadway #109
Coyne Agency Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 874-3124
coyneagency.com
WP
910 N College Ave Ste 5
Wally Pfeffer - Mutual of Omaha
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 449-0359
agents.mutualofomaha.com/agents/mo/columbia/wally-pfeffer
DI
116 N Garth Ave
Downes Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Columbia, MO
(573) 445-6548

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Columbia Cost?

Costs for supplemental insurance in Missouri vary by plan type age and insurer. Medigap Plan G for a 65-year-old in Columbia typically ranges from 120 to 200 dollars per month. Plan N may cost 90 to 150 dollars per month. Dental and vision supplemental plans often add 30 to 60 dollars per month. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Columbia

Supplemental insurance agents in Columbia Missouri help residents fill gaps in Medicare coverage. These agents can explain Medigap plans which are standardized by Missouri law under the Missouri Insurance Code. Local agents also assist with dental vision and hospital indemnity policies tailored to Boone County residents.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Columbia Missouri?

A supplemental insurance agent in Columbia Missouri is a licensed professional who sells policies that cover costs not paid by original Medicare. These agents must follow Missouri insurance regulations and can help you compare Medigap plans A through N.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Missouri?

In Missouri you have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time you can buy any Medigap policy without medical underwriting. Outside this window insurers may deny coverage or charge more based on health.

Are there Missouri-specific rules for supplemental insurance?

Yes Missouri has a guaranteed issue law that requires insurers to sell you a Medigap policy under certain conditions such as losing employer coverage. Missouri also allows insurers to use attained-age pricing which means premiums can increase as you get older.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Missouri Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.