ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeRenters Insurance AgentsNew York › Middletown

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in Middletown, NY

Browse renters insurance agents serving Middletown, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in Middletown, New York is James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 924 reviews. Other highly rated options include Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent, Joy Insurance, Curabba Insurance Agency. This directory lists 20 renters insurance agents serving Middletown.

Showing 20 renters insurance agents in Middletown, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent13 James P Kelly Way ste a(845) 344-3276
2Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent246 NY-211(845) 775-3277
3Joy Insurance639 E Main St(845) 683-5261
4Curabba Insurance Agency334 E Main St(845) 343-0855
5De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent809 NY-211(845) 692-3456
6Evergreen Insurance Agency -Peter Schmidt690, 4 NY-211 E(845) 673-6127
7The Premium Select Group Inc.32 County Rd 78(845) 520-9774
8Hutchings Agency Inc.682 E Main St # 2D(845) 343-2148
9Katelyn Schaffner - State Farm Insurance Agent4 E Main St Ste 3B(845) 394-2622
10Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency265 NY-211 Suite 106B(845) 394-6155
JD
13 James P Kelly Way ste a
James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Middletown, New York area as a renters insurance agent. This agency helps local tenants find coverage for personal belongings and liability protection. Renters insurance policies can aid in replacing items lost to theft or fire. Policyholders also receive protection if someone is injured inside their rented home. The agency typically assists with tailoring deductible levels and adding valuable items to a tenant's policy. It handles requests for both standard renters insurance and coverage for higher-value personal property.

CG
246 NY-211
Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middletown, NY, provides a comprehensive range of renters insurance services, including policy setup, coverage reviews, and claim assistance to protect personal belongings and liability. Clients can access account management tools and schedule regular policy check-ins to ensure their coverage keeps pace with changes in their residence or inventory. The agency serves individuals renting single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants throughout the local area.

JI
639 E Main St
Joy Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Joy Insurance serves tenants and property owners in Middletown, New York, with renters insurance policies that protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage. The company helps clients understand policy options to safeguard against theft, fire, and water damage common in rental homes and apartments. It also assists property managers in securing appropriate coverage for their units. Joy Insurance extends its services to nearby communities, including the greater Orange County area around Monroe and Chester.

CI
334 E Main St
Curabba Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Curabba Insurance Agency serves Middletown, New York, and the surrounding communities of Orange County. It handles renters insurance policies to protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage for tenants in apartments, houses, and condominiums. The agency helps safeguard clients from financial loss due to theft, fire, or water damage. For a typical job, it begins by reviewing a renter’s specific possessions and living situation before recommending appropriate coverage limits and deductibles.

DA
809 NY-211
De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

For renters insurance, clients can choose between a one-time liability policy or a recurring plan that also covers personal belongings. De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middletown, NY, offers both options to match different needs. Coverage includes protection for theft, fire damage, and temporary living expenses if a rented home becomes uninhabitable. This local agent provides personalized guidance on selecting the right policy for each tenant. Service is available on an as-needed basis for policy inquiries or claims assistance.

EI
690, 4 NY-211 E
Evergreen Insurance Agency -Peter Schmidt
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
PS
32 County Rd 78
The Premium Select Group Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

When autumn storms pass through the Hudson Valley, tenants in Middletown often seek protection for their belongings against unexpected water or wind damage. The Premium Select Group Inc. offers standard renters insurance policies designed to cover personal property, liability, and additional living expenses if a unit becomes uninhabitable. As a local agent, the company assists policyholders in understanding coverage limits and deductibles before a claim occurs. Every new application begins with a walk-through or a digital survey to document existing conditions.

HA
682 E Main St # 2D
Hutchings Agency Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Hutchings Agency Inc. in Middletown, NY is recognized for providing renters insurance policies tailored to local apartment dwellers and homeowners leasing their properties. Its service range includes coverage for personal belongings, liability protection, and temporary living expenses if a rental becomes uninhabitable. The agency guides clients through selecting appropriate deductible levels and policy limits. For those with high-value items such as jewelry or electronics, a specialty service it can add on is scheduled personal property coverage.

KS
4 E Main St Ste 3B
Katelyn Schaffner - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Katelyn Schaffner - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middletown, NY, provides residential renters insurance to protect personal belongings and liability. Commercial coverage options are also available for local business owners and tenants. The agency serves policyholders throughout the Middletown area, offering personalized consultations to help select appropriate policy limits. Clients appreciate the convenience of contacting the office between renewals to review coverage changes or update personal information, ensuring continued protection with every policy period.

NF
265 NY-211 Suite 106B
Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency serves the Middletown, New York area as a renters insurance agent. The company works with local residents to secure policies that cover personal belongings against risks like theft and fire damage. Liability protection is also a key aspect of these policies, helping tenants manage costs if someone is injured within a rental property. Additional loss-of-use coverage is available when a dwelling becomes temporarily uninhabitable. The agency handles policy customization and claims assistance for renters in Middletown.

LB
125 Dolson Ave Ste 22b
Lori Buhagiar: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 343-5909
agents.allstate.com/lori-buhagiar-middletown-ny.html
MS
90 Crystal Run Rd
Marshall+Sterling
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 343-2138
marshallsterling.com/middletown
GG
15 Dolson Ave
Glenn Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 342-5721
glenngleeson.com
LA
22 County Rd 78 #2
The Lang Agency LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 342-5264
thelangagency.com
MI
593 NY-211
Macri Isola Catherine Insurance Agency Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 692-2277
cmiinsuranceagency.com
RI
112 North St
Reineke Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 343-8000
curabba.com/reineke-insurance-agency
FI
32 County Rd 78 Ste 2
Farmers Insurance - Steve Derrizzo
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 520-9774
MI
610 Route 211 E, Ste 2
The Misner Insurance Agency, Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 434-7755
misneragency.com
EI
117 North St
Estrella Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 535-0095
agents.estrellainsurance.com/en-us/ny/middletown/402.html
NI
1934 NY-211
Nationwide Insurance: Vogel And Moore Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 692-4441
agency.nationwide.com/ny/middletown/10941/vogel-and-moore-inc

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in Middletown Cost?

In New York, renters insurance typically costs between $15 and $30 per month for a standard policy with $20,000 to $50,000 in personal property coverage. Actual premiums depend on your location in Middletown, the value of your belongings, your deductible choice, and your claims history. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in Middletown

Renters insurance agents in Middletown, NY help tenants protect their personal property from theft, fire, and other covered losses. New York law does not require renters insurance, but many landlords in Orange County now include it as a lease condition. A local agent can explain how coverage limits and deductibles apply to your specific rental situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does renters insurance cover in Middletown NY?

Standard policies cover personal belongings, liability for injuries to others, and additional living expenses if your rental becomes uninhabitable. In New York, flood and earthquake damage are typically not covered and require separate policies.

Is renters insurance required by law in New York?

New York state law does not require renters insurance. However, many landlords in Middletown and across NY now require tenants to carry a policy as part of the lease agreement. Check your lease for specific requirements.

How do I choose a renters insurance agent in Middletown?

Look for agents licensed in New York who specialize in tenant policies. Ask about replacement cost versus actual cash value coverage. Compare quotes from multiple agencies to find a policy that fits your budget and needs.

Renters Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.