ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in Amherst, NY

Browse renters insurance agents serving Amherst, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in Amherst, New York is Elmwood Agency, rated 5.0 stars across 395 reviews. Other highly rated options include Jacob Czaja - State Farm Insurance Agent, Michele Proietti - State Farm Insurance Agent, Butterson Agency, Inc. This directory lists 11 renters insurance agents serving Amherst.

Showing 11 renters insurance agents in Amherst, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Elmwood Agency90 Bryant Woods S #100(716) 206-3706
2Jacob Czaja - State Farm Insurance Agent3555 Sheridan Dr Ste 3557(716) 688-5700
3Michele Proietti - State Farm Insurance Agent3140 Sheridan Dr Ste 102(716) 838-3500
4Butterson Agency, Inc586 N French Rd # 4(716) 636-8815
5Scott Krevat - State Farm Insurance Agent4504 Main St Suite 140(716) 839-5433
6Michelle Liberta: Allstate Insurance626 N French Rd STE 1(716) 631-0030
7Brian Haseltine: Allstate Insurance2066 Eggert Rd Ste 2(716) 837-3000
8Donald L. Houck Agency, Inc.1940 Eggert Rd(716) 835-2525
9Dave Mcmahon Insurance Agency4476 Main Rd Suite 113(716) 832-0003
10The Mezzio Agency606 N French Rd #1(716) 710-7270
EA
90 Bryant Woods S #100
Elmwood Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Elmwood Agency serves renters in the Amherst, New York area, offering tailored renters insurance policies that protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage. The agency helps clients understand how a policy covers losses from theft, fire, or water damage while including additional living expenses if a rental becomes uninhabitable. Elmwood Agency handles customizing liability limits and reviewing scheduled personal property for high-value items.

JC
3555 Sheridan Dr Ste 3557
Jacob Czaja - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Jacob Czaja - State Farm Insurance Agent in Amherst, NY provides a range of services that include tailored renters insurance policies, liability coverage, and protection for personal belongings against theft or damage. The agency assists clients in selecting appropriate coverage limits and deductible options, offering ongoing policy management and claims support as needed. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

MP
3140 Sheridan Dr Ste 102
Michele Proietti - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Michele Proietti - State Farm Insurance Agent serves local homeowners, renters, and property managers in Amherst, New York. This agency provides renters insurance policies that help protect personal belongings like furniture and electronics against theft, fire, or water damage. Additional coverage options address liability for accidents that may occur inside a rented home or apartment. The office also assists landlords with commercial property protection policies. Service extends to residents in nearby communities such as Williamsville and the broader Buffalo Niagara region.

BA
586 N French Rd # 4
Butterson Agency, Inc
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Serving Amherst and the surrounding communities in Western New York, Butterson Agency, Inc provides renters insurance policies to local residents. It handles coverage for personal belongings and liability protection against common household risks. To determine a homeowner's needs, the agency first reviews the estimated value of their possessions and typical exposure to hazards like fire and theft. It then selects a policy from its carriers that aligns with that specific risk profile.

SK
4504 Main St Suite 140
Scott Krevat - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Some renters insurance policies are purchased as a one-time annual plan, while others offer monthly premium payments for ongoing coverage. Scott Krevat - State Farm Insurance Agent in Amherst, NY helps clients choose between these service options. Policies typically protect personal belongings against theft, fire, and liability for guest injuries. Coverage can also include additional living expenses if a home becomes uninhabitable. Service is available on an as-needed basis for new policies or when an existing renter needs to update coverage.

ML
626 N French Rd STE 1
Michelle Liberta: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Michelle Liberta: Allstate Insurance in Amherst, NY specializes in renters insurance policies that protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage within leased homes and apartments. The agency assists local tenants with tailoring coverage limits to individual needs and navigating policy options. With seasonal weather patterns affecting the area, it helps renters address coverage concerns related to winter pipe bursts or summer storm damage to stored property.

BH
2066 Eggert Rd Ste 2
Brian Haseltine: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

When winter storms and lake-effect snow bear down on Amherst, protecting personal belongings becomes a top concern for local renters. Brian Haseltine: Allstate Insurance helps residents secure their apartments and homes by offering tailored renters insurance policies that cover personal property and liability. Their team understands the specific challenges of renting in Western New York, from heavy snowfall to seasonal risks. An agent will discuss coverage options and often schedule a brief walk-through to assess the dwelling’s unique features before finalizing a policy.

DL
1940 Eggert Rd
Donald L. Houck Agency, Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

The Donald L. Houck Agency, Inc. specializes in renters insurance for residents across Amherst, NY, safeguarding personal belongings and providing liability protection. Coverage options typically extend to valuable items such as electronics, jewelry, and bicycles through scheduled add-ons. The agency assists clients with policies that can also offer temporary living expense reimbursement during covered losses. It serves a variety of commercial sectors, including local offices, warehouse facilities, and food service establishments.

DM
4476 Main Rd Suite 113
Dave Mcmahon Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Dave Mcmahon Insurance Agency in Amherst, NY offers residential renters insurance coverage for local tenants and property owners. The agency also handles commercial policies for area businesses and serves clients throughout the surrounding region. Policies assist with protecting personal belongings and liability risks in rental homes or apartments. The team provides attentive follow-up after policies are issued and remains available for repeat service between scheduled visits to adjust coverage as needs change.

MA
606 N French Rd #1
The Mezzio Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

The Mezzio Agency serves Amherst, NY, as a renters insurance agent known for helping tenants protect personal belongings from theft and fire. It assists clients in selecting coverage for liability claims and temporary living expenses if a rental becomes uninhabitable. The agency also guides policyholders through the process of documenting household items for accurate claim filing. An add-on specialty is identity theft protection, which can be attached to a standard renters policy for an extra layer of security.

NI
2277 Niagara Falls Blvd
NAC Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY
(716) 235-5910
nacinsuranceagency.com/locations

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in Amherst Cost?

The average cost of renters insurance in New York is about $15 to $30 per month for $30,000 in personal property coverage. In Amherst, rates may vary based on your rental location, credit score, and chosen deductible. Higher coverage limits or added endorsements for valuables like jewelry will increase the premium. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in Amherst

Renters insurance agents in Amherst, New York help tenants find policies that protect personal property and provide liability coverage. New York law does not require renters insurance, but many landlords in Erie County now include it as a lease condition. An agent can explain how local risks like snow damage or theft affect your coverage needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a renters insurance agent in Amherst do?

A renters insurance agent helps you compare policies from different carriers to find coverage that fits your budget and needs. They explain policy terms, deductibles, and exclusions specific to New York. The agent also assists with filing claims and adjusting coverage as your situation changes.

Is renters insurance required by law in New York State?

New York State law does not require renters insurance. However, many landlords in Amherst now require tenants to carry a policy as part of the lease agreement. Check your lease to see if proof of insurance is needed before moving in.

What does renters insurance typically cover in New York?

Standard renters insurance covers personal property against theft, fire, and certain water damage. It also includes liability protection if someone is injured in your rental unit. In New York, policies often exclude flood damage, so you may need separate flood insurance for basement units.

Renters Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.