ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeRenters Insurance AgentsNew York › Bay Shore

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in Bay Shore, NY

Browse renters insurance agents serving Bay Shore, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in Bay Shore, New York is Sound Harbor Insurance, rated 5.0 stars across 343 reviews. Other highly rated options include Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance, Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent, Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 15 renters insurance agents serving Bay Shore.

Showing 15 renters insurance agents in Bay Shore, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Sound Harbor Insurance91 E Main St Suite 3(631) 517-9211
2Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance67 E Main St(631) 440-9226
3Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent87 Park Ave(631) 666-8350
4Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent1656 5th Ave A(631) 478-6669
5Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent1805 5th Ave Ste 14(631) 456-4603
6ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC.1716 Sunrise Hwy(631) 665-6464
7Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd25 4th Ave(631) 434-6666
8C Walsh Agency28 W Main St(631) 251-6050
9Jay Tee Insurance1655 5th Ave A(631) 231-3200
10AllSafe Insurance Agency1175 Sunrise Hwy(631) 517-1173
SH
91 E Main St Suite 3
Sound Harbor Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Sound Harbor Insurance serves Bay Shore and all of Suffolk County as a provider of renters insurance. It helps tenants protect their personal belongings against theft, fire, and water damage from faulty plumbing. Policies may include liability coverage if someone is injured inside a rental unit. Renters often seek this company for affordable plans that safeguard electronics, furniture, and clothing from unexpected loss. The agent also assists clients with filing claims for stolen items or repairing property damaged in a kitchen fire.

AM
67 E Main St
Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance provides renters insurance coverage in the Bay Shore, NY area, offering policies that protect personal belongings and provide liability protection for tenants. The agency assists clients in selecting appropriate coverage limits and deductibles. Maintenance plans are not standard for rental policies, but the agency helps customers review their coverage annually. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

MS
87 Park Ave
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent in Bay Shore, NY, serves homeowners, renters, and property managers seeking renters insurance. The agency helps customers protect personal belongings and provides liability coverage for apartments, houses, and condos. It also offers guidance on policy limits and deductibles to meet individual needs. This office additionally works with clients in neighboring communities throughout Suffolk County on Long Island.

BD
1656 5th Ave A
Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Bay Shore, New York, and the surrounding communities, handling renters insurance policies for local residents. The agency helps tenants protect their personal belongings and provides liability coverage against common household accidents. Renters insurance typically covers losses from events like fire, theft, or vandalism, and the agent works to tailor policies to individual living situations. Each job receives a straightforward, personalized consultation to assess coverage needs and explain policy options clearly.

DC
1805 5th Ave Ste 14
Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insurance Agent offers renters insurance in Bay Shore, NY, with services structured around either a one-time policy purchase or a recurring monthly premium billing cycle. Coverage typically protects personal belongings against theft, fire, and certain weather-related damage, often including liability protection for incidents occurring inside the rental unit. Additional living expenses may be covered if the property becomes uninhabitable. For clients requiring flexible protection, this agent provides renters insurance on an as-needed basis, allowing policy adjustments or cancellations as living situations change.

AI
1716 Sunrise Hwy
ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC.
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

As a renters insurance agent in Bay Shore, NY, ACME Insurance Brokerage of Bay Shore INC. specializes in crafting personal property coverage plans that protect belongings from theft, fire, and water damage. It also provides liability protection for accidents occurring inside a rented home or apartment. Agents here help tenants evaluate their specific inventory and policy limits. During the start of the summer rental season, the agency commonly assists clients with updating coverage to reflect new purchases or seasonal relocations.

OM
25 4th Ave
Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

As coastal storms become more frequent on Long Island, renters in Bay Shore increasingly seek coverage that protects personal belongings from water and wind damage. Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd meets this need by working with multiple carriers to secure policies tailored for apartment and condo dwellers. Their agents help clients understand liability limits and replacement cost options. New policy discussions typically begin with a brief conversation about a renter’s inventory and budget, followed by a recommendation of suitable coverage levels and a walkthrough of any required property inspection.

CW
28 W Main St
C Walsh Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

C Walsh Agency helps individuals and families in Bay Shore, New York, secure renters insurance to protect personal belongings against theft, fire, and water damage. The company specializes in offering add-ons such as liability coverage for accidents occurring inside a rented home. It also assists with additional protections for high-value jewelry, electronics, and temporary living expenses if a unit becomes uninhabitable. The agency serves a range of commercial sectors, including local offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

JT
1655 5th Ave A
Jay Tee Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

Jay Tee Insurance in Bay Shore, NY assists residents in protecting personal belongings and liability through renters insurance policies. The agency also helps local business owners with commercial coverage options. Services extend throughout Bay Shore and surrounding Suffolk County communities. Clients typically receive guidance tailored to individual rental situations and coverage needs. The agent can review policies with policyholders before renewal, offering follow-up support between regular service visits to address any questions or changes in circumstances.

AI
1175 Sunrise Hwy
AllSafe Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY

AllSafe Insurance Agency in Bay Shore, NY is known for helping local renters secure coverage that protects their personal belongings and provides liability protection. Serving tenants throughout the area, the agency works to match each client with a policy that fits their living situation and budget. Renters insurance from AllSafe typically covers losses from theft, fire, and certain water damage, as well as temporary living expenses if a unit becomes uninhabitable. A specialty service it can add on is scheduled personal property coverage for high-value items like jewelry or electronics.

UI
214 5th Ave
Universal Insurance Co
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(315) 239-3997
FC
194 N Fehr Way Suite D-3
First Choice Insurance New York
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 729-9572
SI
90 Millpond Ln
SafeCity Insurance Agency NY
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(917) 310-3567
CI
21 Third Ave Suite 1
Cochrane Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 665-3100
AI
1784 5th Ave Unit B
Alpine Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Bay Shore, NY
(631) 435-0001

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in Bay Shore Cost?

The average cost of renters insurance in New York is around 15 to 30 dollars per month, or 180 to 360 dollars per year. In Bay Shore, rates may vary based on the value of your belongings, your deductible choice, and the crime rate in your neighborhood. Policies with higher liability limits or additional riders for expensive items like jewelry will cost more. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in Bay Shore

Renters insurance agents in Bay Shore, New York help tenants protect their personal property and liability. New York law does not require renters insurance, but many landlords in Suffolk County now ask for proof of coverage in lease agreements. An agent can explain how policies cover theft, fire damage, and temporary living expenses if your rental becomes uninhabitable.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a renters insurance agent in Bay Shore do?

A renters insurance agent helps you find a policy that fits your needs and budget. They explain coverage options like personal property protection and liability insurance. Agents also help you file claims and adjust coverage as your situation changes.

Is renters insurance required by law in New York?

New York state law does not mandate renters insurance for tenants. However, many landlords in Bay Shore and across Long Island now require it in lease agreements. Check your lease to see if you need to show proof of coverage.

How much personal property coverage should I get in Bay Shore?

Most experts recommend enough coverage to replace all your belongings. A typical Bay Shore renter may need 20,000 to 50,000 dollars in personal property coverage. An agent can help you estimate the value of your items based on a home inventory.

Renters Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.