ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeLandlord Insurance AgentsNew York › Middletown

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Middletown, NY

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Middletown, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Middletown, New York is James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 924 reviews. Other highly rated options include Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent, Joy Insurance, Curabba Insurance Agency. This directory lists 19 landlord insurance agents serving Middletown.

Showing 19 landlord insurance agents in Middletown, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent13 James P Kelly Way ste a(845) 344-3276
2Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent246 NY-211(845) 775-3277
3Joy Insurance639 E Main St(845) 683-5261
4Curabba Insurance Agency334 E Main St(845) 343-0855
5De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent809 NY-211(845) 692-3456
6Evergreen Insurance Agency -Peter Schmidt690, 4 NY-211 E(845) 673-6127
7The Premium Select Group Inc.32 County Rd 78(845) 520-9774
8Hutchings Agency Inc.682 E Main St # 2D(845) 343-2148
9Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency265 NY-211 Suite 106B(845) 394-6155
10Lori Buhagiar: Allstate Insurance125 Dolson Ave Ste 22b(845) 343-5909
JD
13 James P Kelly Way ste a
James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

James Demmer - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Middletown, NY area, providing landlord insurance policies designed to protect rental property owners. The agency helps residential and commercial property investors secure coverage that addresses property damage, liability risks, and potential loss of rental income. Tailored insurance solutions are offered for single-family homes, multi-unit dwellings, and apartment buildings. Specific services handled here include property damage protection and general liability coverage for landlords.

CG
246 NY-211
Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Cassie Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middletown, NY, provides landlord insurance services covering property damage, liability protection, and loss of rental income for property owners. The agency helps customize coverage plans to address the specific maintenance and risk needs of different rental properties. Regular policy reviews ensure that protections align with current property conditions and local market requirements. Its clientele includes owners of single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

JI
639 E Main St
Joy Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Joy Insurance serves landlords and property managers in Middletown, New York, offering coverage tailored to rental properties. Its policies help protect residential and commercial landlords from common risks such as property damage, liability claims, and lost rental income. The agency works to match property owners with plans that meet local regulations and insurance requirements. Joy Insurance also provides support for claims and policy adjustments as landlord needs change. Its coverage area extends to nearby communities throughout Orange County.

CI
334 E Main St
Curabba Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Curabba Insurance Agency serves Middletown, New York, and the surrounding communities in Orange County. The company handles landlord insurance policies tailored specifically for property owners who rent out residential or commercial units. It addresses coverage needs such as property damage, liability protection, and loss of rental income. To handle a typical job, the agency begins by assessing the specific risks associated with each local property structure and its tenancy situation before recommending a customized policy that aligns with the property owner's financial exposure.

DA
809 NY-211
De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

De Anne Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent in Middletown, NY, offers landlord insurance on both a one-time policy purchase for a single rental property and as part of an ongoing, scheduled portfolio of coverage options. The agency’s approach helps protect landlords against property damage, liability claims, and loss of rental income due to covered incidents. Service is provided on an as-needed basis, allowing clients to request policy reviews, adjustments, or new quotes whenever their rental situation changes.

EI
690, 4 NY-211 E
Evergreen Insurance Agency -Peter Schmidt
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
PS
32 County Rd 78
The Premium Select Group Inc.
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

As rental property owners in the Ulster County region prepare for the changing seasons, they face shifting liabilities from winter freeze risks to spring storm damage. The Premium Select Group Inc. in Middletown, NY serves local landlords by offering customized landlord insurance agent services built around each property's unique exposures. Policies are structured to protect both the structure and rental income. To begin, an agent arranges a thorough property inspection to assess existing coverage gaps and structural vulnerabilities, ensuring all risks are identified before the policy is finalized.

HA
682 E Main St # 2D
Hutchings Agency Inc.
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Hutchings Agency Inc. provides residential landlord insurance services for property owners in the Middletown, New York area, along with coverage for commercial rental properties. The agency works with landlords to tailor policies that address common local risks such as tenant liability and property damage. After an initial consultation, they remain available to adjust coverage as leases or buildings change, ensuring consistent protection between regular reviews.

NF
265 NY-211 Suite 106B
Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Nicole Feichtl at Comparion Insurance Agency is a landlord insurance agent in Middletown, New York, known for providing coverage tailored to rental property owners. The agency serves local landlords seeking protection for residential or commercial rental units, addressing risks such as property damage, liability, and loss of rental income. For policyholders, the company can also add on specialized coverage for vacant properties or short-term rental exposures, ensuring more complete risk management.

LB
125 Dolson Ave Ste 22b
Lori Buhagiar: Allstate Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY

Lori Buhagiar: Allstate Insurance in Middletown, NY provides general landlord insurance coverage to protect rental properties. The firm can also offer specialty add-ons such as liability protection and loss of rental income coverage. These policies help safeguard residential and commercial income properties from common risks like fire and weather damage. The same comprehensive protection extends to commercial sectors including offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

MS
90 Crystal Run Rd
Marshall+Sterling
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 343-2138
marshallsterling.com/middletown
GG
15 Dolson Ave
Glenn Gleeson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 342-5721
glenngleeson.com
LA
22 County Rd 78 #2
The Lang Agency LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 342-5264
thelangagency.com
MI
593 NY-211
Macri Isola Catherine Insurance Agency Inc.
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 692-2277
cmiinsuranceagency.com
PI
265 Ballard Rd
Priority Insurance New York
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(315) 230-0587
RI
112 North St
Reineke Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 343-8000
curabba.com/reineke-insurance-agency
MI
610 Route 211 E, Ste 2
The Misner Insurance Agency, Inc.
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 434-7755
misneragency.com
EI
117 North St
Estrella Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 535-0095
agents.estrellainsurance.com/en-us/ny/middletown/402.html
NI
1934 NY-211
Nationwide Insurance: Vogel And Moore Inc.
Landlord Insurance Agent · Middletown, NY
(845) 692-4441
agency.nationwide.com/ny/middletown/10941/vogel-and-moore-inc

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Middletown Cost?

The cost of landlord insurance in New York typically ranges from 15 to 30 percent more than standard homeowners insurance, with annual premiums for a single-family rental in Middletown averaging between 800 and 1,500 dollars. Factors such as property age, location, number of units, and coverage limits affect the price. This is general information and does not constitute insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Middletown

Landlord insurance agents in Middletown, NY help property owners protect their rental investments with policies that cover property damage, liability, and loss of rental income. New York law requires landlords to maintain certain safety standards, and a local agent can explain how these requirements affect your coverage needs. Working with an agent familiar with Orange County regulations ensures your policy meets both state and local guidelines.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in New York?

Landlord insurance typically covers the dwelling structure, liability protection, and loss of rental income if the property becomes uninhabitable. In New York, policies may also include coverage for ordinance or law changes that require upgrades after a loss. An agent can help you customize a policy for your specific rental property in Middletown.

Is landlord insurance required by law in New York?

New York state law does not require landlord insurance, but most mortgage lenders and property management companies require it. Without coverage, you could be personally liable for injuries or property damage. An agent can explain the legal risks of operating without insurance in New York.

How do I choose a landlord insurance agent in Middletown NY?

Look for an agent who specializes in rental properties and has experience with New York insurance regulations. Ask about their knowledge of local property values and common risks in Orange County. A good agent will review your lease agreements and property condition to recommend appropriate coverage limits.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.