ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHome Insurance AgentsIndiana › Chesterton

Find Home Insurance Agents Near You in Chesterton, IN

Browse home insurance agents serving Chesterton, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated home insurance agent in Chesterton, Indiana is Joshua Baumgartner - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 100 reviews. Other highly rated options include Thomas Wisch: Allstate Insurance, South Shore Insurance, Jim Wells - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 16 home insurance agents serving Chesterton.

Showing 16 home insurance agents in Chesterton, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Joshua Baumgartner - State Farm Insurance Agent218 S Calumet Rd(219) 728-6959
2Thomas Wisch: Allstate Insurance711 Plaza Dr Ste 1(219) 224-3244
3South Shore Insurance760 S Calumet Rd(219) 395-1747
4Jim Wells - State Farm Insurance Agent422 Broadway Ave(219) 926-7506
5Shepherd Insurance155 S Calumet Rd(219) 926-8681
6Cuna Mutual Group515 Broadway Ave # A(219) 600-5435
7AAA Insurance - Tom Little Insurance Agency802 Wabash Ave Ste. 110(219) 250-2841
8Justin Salamanca Agency, LLC American Family Insurance103 W Morgan Ave(219) 510-5405
9Jim Kristoff - State Farm Insurance Agent536 Indian Boundary Rd(219) 926-7649
10Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance402 Indian Boundary Rd(219) 926-1004
JB
218 S Calumet Rd
Joshua Baumgartner - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

Joshua Baumgartner - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Chesterton, Indiana area and Porter County with home insurance policies. The agency helps local homeowners protect their property and belongings against unexpected damage. Personalized coverage options are designed to fit individual needs and budgets. Services include assistance with policy claims and guidance on selecting appropriate deductibles. The agency also handles renters insurance for those leasing homes or apartments in the Chesterton area.

TW
711 Plaza Dr Ste 1
Thomas Wisch: Allstate Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

Thomas Wisch: Allstate Insurance provides a full range of home insurance services for customers in Chesterton, Indiana. The agency partners with policyholders to create customized coverage plans, including protection for the dwelling and personal belongings. It also offers service options such as liability coverage and additional living expense assistance. Maintenance plans are not offered directly, but the agent can help clients review policies to ensure adequate protection against local weather risks. This agent services single-family homes, apartments, retail businesses, and restaurants.

SS
760 S Calumet Rd
South Shore Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

South Shore Insurance in Chesterton, Indiana, serves local homeowners, landlords, and small business owners by providing coverage for houses, rental properties, and commercial structures. They assist clients in comparing policies for fire damage, storm protection, and basic liability needs. Typical services include helping property managers secure vacancy coverage and advising families on bundling home and auto policies for potential savings. Their service area also covers communities near the Indiana Dunes region, such as Porter and Beverly Shores.

JW
422 Broadway Ave
Jim Wells - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

Jim Wells - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Chesterton, Indiana, and the surrounding communities of Porter County. The agency handles home insurance policies that can cover dwelling structures, personal belongings, and liability protection for local homeowners. Jim Wells and his staff work directly with each client to understand their specific coverage needs based on the property's value and location. They then compare options from their company to tailor a policy that fits the individual situation, using a consultative approach that begins with a thorough review of the home and its risks.

SI
155 S Calumet Rd
Shepherd Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

For many property owners, choosing between securing a single policy for a new home or establishing an ongoing arrangement for yearly coverage updates is an important decision. Shepherd Insurance, located in Chesterton, IN, assists clients in understanding these approaches while offering home insurance to protect dwellings and personal belongings against common regional risks like storm damage and liability. Their service is available on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis to accommodate individual needs.

CM
515 Broadway Ave # A
Cuna Mutual Group
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

Cuna Mutual Group specializes in helping Chesterton homeowners create dwelling and personal property coverage plans. The agency guides clients through policy selections that address local weather risks and property protection needs. In the Indiana lakeshore area, heavy snow, ice dams, and strong winds can cause damage. The company also assists policyholders with reviewing their coverage before each winter season to help ensure they are adequately prepared for potential cold-weather claims.

AI
802 Wabash Ave Ste. 110
AAA Insurance - Tom Little Insurance Agency
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

After a harsh winter or heavy spring rain, Chesterton homes often need reassessment of coverage for storm damage. AAA Insurance - Tom Little Insurance Agency provides guidance for local homeowners navigating policy options and liability protection tailored to the region. As a home insurance agent, the agency helps clients understand deductibles and replacement-cost valuation for their property. For new policies or annual reviews, the initial step involves a thorough inspection of the home’s exterior, roof, and major systems to accurately document current conditions.

JS
103 W Morgan Ave
Justin Salamanca Agency, LLC American Family Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

From its base in Chesterton, Indiana, Justin Salamanca Agency, LLC American Family Insurance provides home insurance services for residential properties throughout the local area. The agency also offers commercial coverage tailored to the needs of business owners in the region. A dedicated agent works closely with each client to explain policy options and coverage details. After a policy is issued, the agency follows up periodically to discuss adjustments and ensures continued protection between regular visits to the property.

JK
536 Indian Boundary Rd
Jim Kristoff - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

Jim Kristoff’s agency provides home insurance policies that protect local residences from common property risks, with additional coverage options such as liability protection and personal property endorsements. Serving the Chesterton, Indiana area, the office helps clients customize policies to fit their coverage needs. Its services extend beyond residential properties, also offering tailored insurance solutions for commercial sectors including offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

IF
402 Indian Boundary Rd
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN

Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance is an agency providing home insurance to homeowners in Chesterton, Indiana. Its services include standard dwelling coverage, protection for personal belongings, and liability insurance for property owners. The agency helps clients assess risks specific to the local climate and housing stock, offering policies that address common regional concerns. It can also add coverage for identity theft recovery as a specialized endorsement to a standard homeowners policy.

PI
560-580 Indian Boundary Rd
Progress Insurance Co.
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN
(509) 790-6498
paulenedraughon089.wixsite.com/insure-co
AI
425 Sand Creek Dr N
AnchorPoint Insurance Solutions
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN
(219) 338-2090
anchorpointins.com
CN
751 E Porter Ave #4
Chris Nielsen - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN
(219) 926-7700
chestertonagent.com
PH
226 N Calumet Rd
Pat Hudson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN
(219) 926-5377
insurewithpathudson.com
KL
402 Indian Boundary Rd
Kyle Legler - Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN
(219) 926-1004
infarmbureau.com/agents/Kyle-Legler-Porter-Chesterton-IN
MM
209 S Calumet Rd #7
Mature Market Insurance Services, LLC
Home Insurance Agent · Chesterton, IN
(219) 395-9124
maturemarketinsurance.com

What Does a a Home Insurance Agent in Chesterton Cost?

The average cost of home insurance in Indiana is around $1,200 to $1,800 per year for a standard policy. Costs in Chesterton may be higher or lower based on your homes age, location, and coverage limits. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About home insurance agents in Chesterton

Home insurance agents in Chesterton, Indiana help you find coverage for your property and belongings. Indiana law requires insurers to offer coverage for wind and hail damage, but flood insurance is separate. A local agent can explain these options and help you compare policies from different companies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a home insurance agent in Chesterton do?

A home insurance agent helps you find a policy that fits your needs and budget. They explain coverage types like dwelling, personal property, and liability. They also assist with claims and policy changes.

Do I need flood insurance in Chesterton Indiana?

Standard home insurance does not cover flood damage. If your home is in a flood zone, your lender may require a separate flood policy. An agent can help you find flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private carrier.

How do Indiana insurance laws affect my home policy?

Indiana law requires insurers to offer coverage for wind and hail damage. The state also has a 30-day grace period for premium payments in some cases. Your agent can explain these rules and how they apply to your policy.

Home Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each home insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.