ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Broken Arrow, OK

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma is Derby Insurance Solutions - Broken Arrow Health Insurance Agency, rated 5.0 stars across 337 reviews. Other highly rated options include Bob Derby Insurance, Swinehart Insurance Agency, Hometown Insurance - Jada Phillips. This directory lists 20 supplemental insurance agents serving Broken Arrow.

Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Broken Arrow, OKListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Derby Insurance Solutions - Broken Arrow Health Insurance Agency820 N Sycamore Ave(918) 451-9783
2Bob Derby Insurance820 N Sycamore Ave(918) 451-9783
3Swinehart Insurance Agency2604 W Kenosha St # 201(918) 258-4678
4Hometown Insurance - Jada Phillips832 W Jasper St(918) 615-8488
5HealthMarkets Insurance - Mike Ross801 N Elm Pl(918) 286-4949
6Harmon Insurance709 West Washington St S(918) 251-2511
7Leisure Insurance Group1408 W Detroit St Suite 104(918) 438-7388
8Rick Thomas Health Medicare Life Insurance Independent Agent / Broker409 N Aspen Ave Suite 104(918) 872-0495
9Steward Insurance Group411 N Main St(918) 779-0140
10Lighthouse Insurance3104 S Elm Pl c(918) 615-9585
DI
820 N Sycamore Ave
Derby Insurance Solutions - Broken Arrow Health Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

Derby Insurance Solutions serves the Broken Arrow, Oklahoma area as a supplemental insurance agent. This company helps local residents fill coverage gaps left by major medical plans, offering policies for unexpected health events and income loss. As a supplemental agent in this region, it assists clients with understanding these optional plans and coordinating them with existing benefits. It handles specific services such as hospital indemnity and accident insurance policies.

BD
820 N Sycamore Ave
Bob Derby Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

Bob Derby Insurance provides a range of supplemental insurance agent services to fill gaps left by primary health plans. The company offers guidance on policy selection and assists with plan maintenance, including claims support and coverage reviews. These services help clients manage out-of-pocket medical costs and unexpected expenses. The agency services individual homeowners, renters in apartment complexes, and local retail store owners who need supplemental coverage for their families or employees.

SI
2604 W Kenosha St # 201
Swinehart Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

Homeowners, retirees, and small business owners in Broken Arrow, OK rely on Swinehart Insurance Agency for supplemental insurance coverage. The agency provides policies that help fill gaps left by primary health or property plans, offering financial protection for unexpected medical costs or income loss. Serving the local community with personalized guidance, the agency ensures clients understand their options for accident, hospital, or critical illness plans. Its service area also extends to the neighboring communities of Bixby and Jenks in the Tulsa metropolitan region.

HI
832 W Jasper St
Hometown Insurance - Jada Phillips
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

Hometown Insurance – Jada Phillips serves Broken Arrow and the surrounding communities of northeastern Oklahoma with supplemental insurance policies. The agency handles products that cover gaps left by major medical plans, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. Clients commonly work with the agency to secure additional financial protection for unexpected health events. To handle a typical job, the agency first reviews the client’s existing coverage, then recommends specific supplemental policies to address identified gaps and budgets.

HI
801 N Elm Pl
HealthMarkets Insurance - Mike Ross
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

HealthMarkets Insurance - Mike Ross specializes in Medicare supplement plans, dental insurance, and life insurance policies. As a licensed supplemental insurance agent, it serves residents of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, by helping them compare coverage options and enroll in individual or family plans. The agency assists clients in navigating enrollment periods and understanding plan benefits. Before the annual Medicare open enrollment period ends each December, it helps seniors review their existing coverage and make necessary adjustments to avoid late enrollment penalties.

HI
709 West Washington St S
Harmon Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

Harmon Insurance, located in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, helps clients decide between one-time policies and recurring supplemental coverage options. Supplemental insurance agents in this area typically offer plans that fill gaps left by primary health or Medicare coverage, such as accident or critical illness protection. These agents meet with individuals to review specific needs and recommend appropriate supplementary plans. Service runs on an asneeded basis, with clients able to request consultations or policy adjustments whenever their circumstances require them.

LI
1408 W Detroit St Suite 104
Leisure Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

As the summer travel season and open enrollment windows prompt residents of Broken Arrow to review their coverage gaps, Leisure Insurance Group offers personalized supplemental plans that help manage out-of-pocket costs for hospital stays and routine care. These policies work alongside major medical coverage to address deductibles and coinsurance. The company meets with clients in their homes or offices to explain plan options and answer questions about eligibility. An initial needs assessment is conducted to match each individual with appropriate coverage before providing a written quote and policy details.

RT
409 N Aspen Ave Suite 104
Rick Thomas Health Medicare Life Insurance Independent Agent / Broker
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

Rick Thomas Health Medicare Life Insurance Independent Agent / Broker works as a supplemental insurance agent serving Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. This general practice helps clients address gaps in primary health coverage through Medicare and life insurance supplements. The agent can assist with adding specific benefits that standard plans often do not fully address, such as routine dental, vision, or hearing services. Commercial sectors this agency can serve include local offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

SI
411 N Main St
Steward Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

Steward Insurance Group in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, is recognized for helping individuals and families address financial gaps that traditional health plans may leave uncovered. The company focuses on supplemental insurance options that provide additional support for unexpected medical expenses or income loss. Its agents work closely with clients to explain plan benefits and match coverage to personal needs. Steward Insurance Group also specializes in offering tailored accident protection policies to further secure policyholders from out-of-pocket costs.

LI
3104 S Elm Pl c
Lighthouse Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK

Lighthouse Insurance in Broken Arrow, OK assists residents with supplemental plans. The agency also arranges commercial coverage for local businesses throughout the area. Agents carefully assess each individual's needs to provide suitable policy options that fill Medicare or employer coverage gaps. They schedule personal consultations to explain how different supplemental plans work in practice. After enrolling, clients receive follow-up support between regular service visits to adjust their coverage as health needs change.

AL
4500 W Houston St
AllInsure
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(609) 408-9517
allinsurebusiness.com
GT
2608 W Kenosha St #143
Greater Tulsa Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 984-9448
greatertulsainsurance.com
RI
828 W Jasper St
Ray Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 496-0089
rayagencyinfo.com
AG
2720 N Hemlock Ct # A
The Arrow Group, A Division of Alliant Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 258-6681
arrow-group.com
OF
110 W Kenosha St
Oklahoma Farm Bureau Insurance - Broken Arrow
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 258-6030
okfbinsurance.com/broken-arrow
FI
1024 N Elm Pl
Flippo Insurance Agency - Timothy Brooks
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 994-6494
flippoinsurance.com
PI
1700 W Albany St Suite 240
Petra Insurance Company LLC.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 897-3872
coveredbypetra.com
AI
753 W New Orleans St
Aspen Insurance Coaches
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 771-0957
facebook.com/Aspenicba
FI
1024 N Elm Pl
Flippo Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 994-6494
flippoinsurance.com
RZ
1701 S Main St #999
Rachel Zimmer - Mutual of Omaha
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Broken Arrow, OK
(918) 957-5500
agents.mutualofomaha.com/agents/ok/broken-arrow/rachel-zimmer

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Broken Arrow Cost?

Supplemental insurance agent services are usually free to you because agents earn commissions from insurance companies. Medigap Plan G in Oklahoma typically costs between 100 and 250 dollars per month for a 65-year-old. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums but may have copays. Costs vary by age health and plan type. This is general information not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Broken Arrow

Supplemental insurance agents in Broken Arrow Oklahoma help residents find Medigap Medicare Advantage and other health plans. Oklahoma law allows a six-month open enrollment period for Medigap policies starting when you turn 65. Local agents can explain how state regulations affect your coverage choices.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Broken Arrow?

A supplemental insurance agent helps you buy policies that fill gaps in Medicare or employer health plans. They are licensed in Oklahoma and can compare plans from multiple carriers.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Oklahoma?

Oklahoma gives you a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts the month you turn 65 and enroll in Medicare Part B. During this time you cannot be denied coverage for health reasons.

Do I need a local agent for supplemental insurance in Broken Arrow?

A local agent can help you understand which plans are available in Tulsa County and how Oklahoma insurance laws apply. They can also assist with claims and annual plan reviews.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Oklahoma Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.