ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsIndiana › Mishawaka

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Mishawaka, IN

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Mishawaka, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Mishawaka, Indiana is McCarthy Insurance Group, rated 4.9 stars across 170 reviews. Other highly rated options include Backstrom Insurance Group, HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher, Pilot Insurance Agency. This directory lists 13 medicare insurance agents serving Mishawaka.

Showing 13 medicare insurance agents in Mishawaka, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1McCarthy Insurance Group802 Lincolnway W(574) 259-5622
2Backstrom Insurance Group3006 Lincolnway E(574) 360-8182
3HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher1736 E Day Rd Suite 400 Suite 400(574) 307-8882
4Pilot Insurance Agency822 W 8th St(574) 855-4837
5HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry1736 E Day Rd #400(574) 229-8147
6DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency1117 Lincolnway E(574) 256-6707
7Dennis Insurance Agency2401 Lincolnway W(574) 254-1010
8Summers Insurance Agency12415 McKinley Hwy(574) 252-0502
9HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding1736 E Day Rd Ste 200 #400(574) 240-4013
10Mike Woods Insurance Agency INC American Family Insurance105 E Grove St(574) 259-4400
MI
802 Lincolnway W
McCarthy Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

McCarthy Insurance Group serves the Mishawaka, Indiana area as a local medicare insurance agent. The company helps clients navigate Medicare plan options, including both Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans. It also assists with understanding Part D prescription drug coverage and Medicare Supplement insurance policies. Its work focuses on finding suitable health coverage plans for seniors and eligible individuals. Services include annual plan review and enrollment assistance for new beneficiaries seeking Part D prescription drug plans.

BI
3006 Lincolnway E
Backstrom Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Backstrom Insurance Group provides a full range of Medicare insurance agent services in Mishawaka, Indiana. The company helps clients compare and enroll in Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D prescription drug plans. It offers ongoing plan reviews to ensure coverage adapts to changing health needs and annual enrollment assistance. The agency services single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

HI
1736 E Day Rd Suite 400 Suite 400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher helps individuals and families in Mishawaka find suitable Medicare coverage to address their healthcare needs. The agency assists with navigating plan options, including Medicare Advantage and supplemental policies, to match varying budgets and medical circumstances. Clients receive guidance on enrollment periods and plan comparisons from a local insurance agent. These services also extend to seniors and retirees in surrounding communities such as Granger and the greater South Bend metro area.

PI
822 W 8th St
Pilot Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Pilot Insurance Agency serves the Mishawaka area and surrounding communities in northern Indiana. This Medicare insurance agent handles the annual enrollment process for Parts A, B, and D plans, as well as Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement options. The agency explains how each plan coordinates with existing coverage like employer group health. For a typical client, the agent first reviews the person’s current prescriptions and preferred doctors before comparing available local plan networks and costs, then presents the most suitable choices that meet the individual’s health needs and budget.

HI
1736 E Day Rd #400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry in Mishawaka, IN serves clients by distinguishing between one-time plan comparisons and ongoing advisory support, ensuring understanding of how Medicare coverage coordinates with existing needs. As a local medicare insurance agent, the agent assists with initial enrollment, plan changes, and annual reviews. Service runs on both a one-time and as-needed basis to accommodate individual schedule preferences for appointments or phone consultations.

DI
1117 Lincolnway E
DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency specializes in Medicare supplements and Medicare Advantage plans, helping individuals compare their coverage options. As a local Medicare insurance agent in Mishawaka, it also guides clients through the complexities of Part D prescription drug plans and Original Medicare. The agency works with people new to Medicare eligibility and those reviewing their current policies. It regularly assists clients during the annual open enrollment period to ensure their health coverage aligns with changing needs and deadlines.

DI
2401 Lincolnway W
Dennis Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

With the annual Medicare open enrollment period, residents of Mishawaka review their coverage options against changing health needs. Dennis Insurance Agency helps local beneficiaries understand plan differences. The company guides clients through the complex Medicare landscape, explaining the distinctions between Medicare Advantage, Medigap, and Part D drug plans. They compare licensed options available in the area, focusing on how each choice fits individual prescriptions and budgets. An initial consultation typically begins with a no-obligation review of a person’s current coverage and upcoming medical expenses to determine the most suitable path forward.

SI
12415 McKinley Hwy
Summers Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Summers Insurance Agency provides guidance on Medicare insurance options for individuals navigating their healthcare coverage in Mishawaka, Indiana. The agency specializes in helping clients understand the nuances of Medicare plans, including supplemental policies and prescription drug coverage. Their services assist people in selecting appropriate insurance solutions for their specific needs. The agency can serve commercial sectors such as local offices, warehouses, and food service establishments that also require employee or individual coverage assistance within the region.

HI
1736 E Day Rd Ste 200 #400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding provides Medicare coverage services for individuals residing in Mishawaka. The agency also assists local business owners with commercial plan options. Their service area covers Mishawaka and the surrounding communities in Indiana. Clients benefit from professional guidance during enrollment periods and plan comparisons. Zack Spaulding ensures customers understand their coverage choices. Follow-up assistance is offered between regular annual visits to address any changes in healthcare needs or policy questions.

MW
105 E Grove St
Mike Woods Insurance Agency INC American Family Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
SI
13800 Jackson Rd
Synergy Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 258-5555
synergyinsurancegroup.com
TI
1602 N Main St
Trevino Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 256-5712
trevinoinsurance.com
MM
509 W McKinley Ave Ste 1
Medicare Michiana
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 370-8555

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Mishawaka Cost?

Medicare insurance agent services in Indiana are typically free to you because agents receive commissions from insurance carriers. Plan premiums vary widely from zero dollars for some Medicare Advantage plans to over 200 dollars per month for certain Medigap policies. Costs depend on your chosen plan location and health status. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Mishawaka

Medicare insurance agents in Mishawaka Indiana help residents compare Medicare Advantage Medigap and Part D plans. Indiana law requires agents to be licensed through the state Department of Insurance. Local agents understand the specific network options available in St. Joseph County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Mishawaka do?

A Medicare insurance agent helps you review plan options explain coverage details and assist with enrollment. They work with multiple insurance carriers to find plans that fit your budget and healthcare needs.

When can I enroll in Medicare in Indiana?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before your 65th birthday month and ends three months after. Indiana also has an Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 each year.

Do Medicare agents charge fees in Indiana?

Most Medicare insurance agents in Indiana are paid by the insurance companies not by you. They provide free consultations and do not charge extra fees for their services.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.