ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Elkhart, IN

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Elkhart, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Elkhart, Indiana is Acceptance Insurance, rated 4.8 stars across 456 reviews. Other highly rated options include HealthMarkets Insurance - Jill Weiss, Patrick Mulroy: Allstate Insurance, Weaver Insurance. This directory lists 20 medicare insurance agents serving Elkhart.

Showing 20 medicare insurance agents in Elkhart, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Acceptance Insurance138 W Hively Ave Ste 8(574) 633-3035
2HealthMarkets Insurance - Jill Weiss23929 Norwood Ct(574) 381-5550
3Patrick Mulroy: Allstate Insurance23987 US-33(574) 241-3700
4Weaver Insurance601 E Bristol St(574) 333-3094
5HealthMarkets Insurance - Michelle Gavarrete**By Appointment Only**, 3714 E Mishawaka Rd(574) 361-7987
6Salinas Insurance Agency, Inc.2938 S Main St(574) 970-0312
7Horner Insurance/ Horner Investment Group LLC2300 Middlebury St(574) 293-5737
8McCartney Insurance1100 N Nappanee St(574) 970-3000
9Fawne Atkinson - State Farm Insurance Agent23241 Old U.S. 20(574) 294-4906
10Mike Wain - State Farm Insurance Agent1014 E Bristol St(574) 262-3502
AI
138 W Hively Ave Ste 8
Acceptance Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

Acceptance Insurance serves the Elkhart, Indiana area as a medicare insurance agent. The company helps local seniors navigate their Medicare options by explaining plan differences and coverage choices. In this capacity, they assist individuals with understanding the various components of the federal health insurance program. Typical work involves guiding clients through initial enrollment periods and annual election changes. Acceptance Insurance specifically handles Medicare Advantage plans and Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage for the Elkhart community.

HI
23929 Norwood Ct
HealthMarkets Insurance - Jill Weiss
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Jill Weiss provides a full range of Medicare insurance options, including plan comparisons and enrollment assistance for local beneficiaries. The agency offers ongoing support to help clients understand their coverage and adjust plans during annual enrollment periods. Regular policy reviews ensure that clients’ healthcare needs remain matched with suitable plans. Jill Weiss services individuals and families in single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants throughout Elkhart, Indiana.

PM
23987 US-33
Patrick Mulroy: Allstate Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

Serving local residents, homeowners, and retirees in Elkhart, Patrick Mulroy: Allstate Insurance provides Medicare insurance agent services, helping individuals navigate plan options and enrollment. Agents work with clients to explain coverage details, compare Part D prescription drug plans, and coordinate with Medicare Supplement policies during annual enrollment periods. The agency assists with understanding changes in plan regulations and provider networks each year. It extends these services to nearby cities such as Goshen and the greater Elkhart County area.

WI
601 E Bristol St
Weaver Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

Serving Elkhart, Indiana, and the surrounding communities of the greater Michiana area, Weaver Insurance handles Medicare insurance agent services. The agency helps residents navigate Medicare selection, including both Medicare Advantage and Supplement plans. It also guides clients through the annual enrollment period to ensure proper coverage. Their general approach to a typical job involves meeting with clients to review their current healthcare needs, then comparing available plans from multiple carriers to present straightforward, personalized options.

HI
**By Appointment Only**, 3714 E Mishawaka Rd
HealthMarkets Insurance - Michelle Gavarrete
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
SI
2938 S Main St
Salinas Insurance Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

Salinas Insurance Agency, Inc. specializes in Medicare supplement and Advantage plan guidance for residents of Elkhart, Indiana. The agency provides comprehensive support in comparing coverage options, enrolling in plans during the annual Open Enrollment Period, and understanding the complexities of Part D prescription drug coverage. With a focus on clear explanations of plan benefits and costs, the agency works to ensure clients find policies that align with their healthcare needs. It also helps individuals manage their coverage during Special Enrollment Periods triggered by life changes such as relocating or losing employer-based insurance.

HI
2300 Middlebury St
Horner Insurance/ Horner Investment Group LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

With annual Medicare enrollment periods approaching in Elkhart, many older adults seek clarity on their coverage options and possible plan changes. Horner Insurance, operating as Horner Investment Group LLC, assists local residents by explaining the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans. Their agents focus on matching individual health needs and budget considerations with appropriate supplemental policies. A typical first step involves scheduling a complimentary in-person or virtual consultation to review current coverage and assess eligibility for new plans during the upcoming enrollment window.

MI
1100 N Nappanee St
McCartney Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

McCartney Insurance assists individuals in navigating their healthcare coverage options. It specializes in Medicare insurance plans, helping clients understand enrollment periods and plan benefits in Elkhart. The agency arranges appointments to explain the differences between Medicare Advantage and supplement policies. Its providers work with small business owners seeking health benefits for their teams. The firm serves commercial sectors such as local offices, warehouse facilities, and food service establishments requiring group coverage solutions.

FA
23241 Old U.S. 20
Fawne Atkinson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

Fawne Atkinson - State Farm Insurance Agent in Elkhart, IN, is known for providing Medicare insurance coverage options to local residents navigating their healthcare needs. The agency guides clients through plan selection, including Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage policies suited to individual budgets and medical requirements. Assistance with annual enrollment periods and understanding coverage benefits forms a core part of its service range. The agency also offers consultations to help evaluate prescription drug plans as an additional specialty service.

MW
1014 E Bristol St
Mike Wain - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN

Mike Wain - State Farm Insurance Agent in Elkhart, IN, assists residents with their Medicare insurance needs, helping them navigate plan options for prescription drug coverage, hospital visits, and medical services. The agency also provides commercial insurance solutions for local business owners in the Elkhart area. Service includes Medicare annual enrollment and special election period consultations. Clients are invited to reach out for follow-up assistance or schedule repeat service between their regular annual review visits to address any changing health needs.

RW
2410 Middlebury St
Rachel Wain - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(574) 293-8130
rachelwain.com
KN
29966 Old U.S. 20
Kathy Nobles - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(574) 522-1148
kjnobles.com
MH
23492 US-33
Mark Hinds American Family Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(574) 875-5723
amfam.com/agents/indiana/elkhart/Mark-Hinds
SI
123 N Main St
Secured Insurance Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(463) 348-1099
HI
803 County Rd 6 W Suite 2
HealthMarkets Insurance - Mariah Himes
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(574) 276-4991
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/mariahhimes
HI
803 County Rd 6 W Suite B
HealthMarkets Insurance - Ashly Connaughton
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(269) 312-1410
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/awelch
BI
3801 S Main St
Becker Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(574) 875-1350
HI
3714 E Mishawaka Rd
HealthMarkets Insurance - Troy Gill
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(574) 360-0791
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/troygill
FI
53846 N Park Ave
Farmers Insurance - Rodney Hohman
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(574) 206-4757
agents.farmers.com/in/elkhart/rodney-hohman
HI
803 Co Rd 6
HealthMarkets Insurance - Sheryl Noblitt
Medicare Insurance Agent · Elkhart, IN
(574) 903-3848
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/sherylnoblitt

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Elkhart Cost?

Medicare insurance agent services in Indiana are typically free to you because agents earn commissions from insurance carriers. Plan premiums vary widely for example Medicare Advantage plans may have zero monthly premium while Medigap plans often cost between 100 and 300 dollars per month depending on age and plan type. This is general information not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Elkhart

Medicare insurance agents in Elkhart Indiana help residents compare Medicare Advantage Medigap and Part D drug plans. Indiana law requires agents to be licensed through the state Department of Insurance. Local agents understand Elkhart County healthcare networks and can guide you through annual enrollment periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Elkhart do?

A Medicare insurance agent helps you review plan options explain coverage details and assist with enrollment. They are licensed in Indiana and can show plans from multiple carriers. They do not provide legal advice but focus on insurance choices.

When can I enroll in Medicare in Elkhart Indiana?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before your 65th birthday and ends three months after. Indiana also follows the Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 each year. Special Enrollment Periods may apply for certain life changes.

Are Medicare agent services free in Elkhart?

Most Medicare insurance agents are paid by the insurance companies not by you. You do not pay extra for their help. Always confirm that the agent is licensed in Indiana and ask about any fees before starting.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.