ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Cicero, NY

Browse auto insurance agents serving Cicero, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Cicero, New York is Dan Tivnan - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 5.0 stars across 783 reviews. Other highly rated options include Mike Baltrusitis - State Farm Insurance Agent, Brittany Krywosa at Comparion Insurance Agency, Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc (Cicero Office). This directory lists 20 auto insurance agents serving Cicero.

Showing 20 auto insurance agents in Cicero, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Dan Tivnan - State Farm Insurance Agent8131 Brewerton Rd(315) 699-8000
2Mike Baltrusitis - State Farm Insurance Agent5720 S Bay Rd(315) 458-3255
3Brittany Krywosa at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 233-9516
4Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc (Cicero Office)8261 Brewerton Rd(315) 752-5100
5Andrew Cambria - State Farm Insurance Agent6257 NY-31 Ste 2(315) 699-2631
6Jessica Schwenn at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 233-9521
7Brittian Stock at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 233-9011
8Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 468-4000
9Christine Crosby at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(518) 612-6095
10Cherie Jean at Comparion Insurance Agency7997 Brewerton Rd(315) 233-3450
DT
8131 Brewerton Rd
Dan Tivnan - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Dan Tivnan - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Cicero, New York area and offers auto insurance policies to local drivers. The agency helps customers understand their coverage options, including liability and comprehensive plans. Policies are designed to meet New York state requirements while also providing protection against common risks like accidents and theft. Dedicated claims assistance and policy reviews are available to ensure proper vehicle and financial security. The office handles personalized auto insurance quotes and policy adjustments for drivers and families in this community.

MB
5720 S Bay Rd
Mike Baltrusitis - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Mike Baltrusitis - State Farm Insurance Agent in Cicero, NY, provides auto insurance policies along with related coverage options such as liability, collision, and comprehensive protection. The agency assists clients with selecting appropriate policy limits and deductibles, and offers guidance on filing claims and adjusting coverage as circumstances change. Regular policy reviews are conducted to ensure alignment with evolving needs and local driving conditions. The office services single-family homes, apartments, retail, and restaurants for additional insurance needs, including property and business-related coverages.

BK
7997 Brewerton Rd
Brittany Krywosa at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Homeowners, renters, and vehicle owners in Cicero, New York, turn to Brittany Krywosa at Comparion Insurance Agency for auto insurance coverage. This local agent assists clients in selecting personal auto policies tailored to their driving needs and budgets. Services include policy reviews and claims assistance for standard and specialty vehicles. The agency also provides guidance on bundling auto with other personal lines. Coverage extends to those living in the nearby Village of North Syracuse as well.

TI
8261 Brewerton Rd
Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc (Cicero Office)
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Serving Cicero and its surrounding communities in Central New York, Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc (Cicero Office) handles auto insurance policies for local drivers. The agency works to match clients with coverage that meets state requirements and protects their vehicles on area roads. For a typical job, it reviews a driver’s specific needs and circumstances, then compares options from its available carriers to find a suitable policy fit.

AC
6257 NY-31 Ste 2
Andrew Cambria - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Andrew Cambria - State Farm Insurance Agent in Cicero offers both one-time policy evaluations and ongoing coverage management for auto insurance needs. This agency helps drivers select liability, collision, and comprehensive protection tailored to their vehicles and daily driving habits. Clients can customize deductibles and policy limits to fit different budgets and risk preferences. Service is available on an as-needed basis for policy changes, claims assistance, or general insurance advice, as well as through scheduled reviews to update coverage as circumstances evolve.

JS
7997 Brewerton Rd
Jessica Schwenn at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Jessica Schwenn at Comparion Insurance Agency specializes in helping drivers in Cicero, New York, secure auto coverage tailored to their needs. The agency works with clients to navigate various policy options, providing ongoing service for existing customers looking to adjust their plans. Its general operations involve reviewing local requirements and personal driving habits to find suitable protection. During the winter months, the agency assists drivers in understanding how their policies address the increased risks of snow and ice on Central New York roads.

BS
7997 Brewerton Rd
Brittian Stock at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

As the snow piles up around Cicero, drivers need to know their coverage will carry them through winter hazards. Brittian Stock at Comparion Insurance Agency offers auto insurance policies tailored to local conditions. They help customers compare options from multiple carriers to find a plan that fits their budget and liability needs. To begin, an agent reviews the driver’s current policy and vehicle details during a quick initial consultation, identifying any gaps in protection. A personalized quote and coverage assessment follow this inspection step.

CI
7997 Brewerton Rd
Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Comparion Insurance Agency serves the Cicero, New York area and the greater Onondaga County region, offering auto insurance coverage for local drivers. The agency helps clients select policies that meet New York state requirements while addressing individual coverage needs. Policy options include liability protection and comprehensive coverage for vehicles. Comparative quotes from multiple carriers allow customers to review different rates and terms. This agency specifically handles personal auto insurance policies and offers guidance on uninsured motorist coverage for area residents.

CC
7997 Brewerton Rd
Christine Crosby at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Christine Crosby at Comparion Insurance Agency works with individuals and businesses in Cicero, NY to secure essential auto insurance coverage. The agency also helps clients add optional protections such as roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement to their personal policies. For commercial clients, it customizes coverage that safeguards vehicles used for daily operations. The agency can serve the needs of local offices, industrial warehouses, and food service establishments.

CJ
7997 Brewerton Rd
Cherie Jean at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY

Cherie Jean at Comparion Insurance Agency provides residential auto insurance services for drivers in Cicero and the surrounding area. Commercial vehicle coverage is also offered to local businesses needing liability and collision options. Service availability extends throughout Onondaga County and nearby communities. Clients are assisted with policy adjustments and renewal questions between regular visits to ensure consistent coverage and helpful follow-up.

HI
5702 S Bay Rd
Heritage Insurance Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 925-5300
heritageagencies.com
KK
7997 Brewerton Rd
Katie King at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 792-7492
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/katie-king
JK
7997 Brewerton Rd
James Kaffenberger at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 233-3302
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/james-kaffenberger
PJ
5797 NY-31
Potter-Jones Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 699-2761
pjagency.com
CC
7997 Brewerton Rd
Charmaine Castle at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 233-0707
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/charmaine-castle
JF
7997 Brewerton Rd
Jaclyn Freeland at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 233-9017
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/jaclyn-freeland
RT
7997 Brewerton Rd
Robert Thomas at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 233-0706
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/robert-thomas
NR
7997 Brewerton Rd
Nicholas Rizzo at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 233-3296
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/new-york/cicero-0885/nicholas-rizzo
MD
8114 Brewerton Rd
The Michael Dey & Jon Taylor Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 944-6494
NI
5885 Cir Dr E Suite 155
Nationwide Insurance: Lance D Wiltse
Auto Insurance Agent · Cicero, NY
(315) 452-3200

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Cicero Cost?

Auto insurance costs in Cicero, New York vary based on factors like age, driving history, and vehicle type. Average annual premiums in New York state range from 1,200 to 2,500 dollars for full coverage, but rates can be higher or lower depending on your personal profile. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Cicero

Auto insurance agents in Cicero, New York help drivers find coverage that meets state legal requirements. New York law mandates liability insurance with minimum limits of 25,000 dollars for bodily injury per person and 50,000 dollars per accident. A local agent can also explain optional coverages like comprehensive and collision for your specific needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in New York?

New York requires liability coverage of 25,000 dollars per person for bodily injury and 50,000 dollars per accident. You also need 10,000 dollars for property damage and 50,000 dollars for no-fault personal injury protection. An agent in Cicero can help you understand these requirements.

How do I choose an auto insurance agent in Cicero?

Look for an agent licensed in New York who has experience with local driving conditions. Ask about their knowledge of Cicero area risks and their ability to compare quotes from multiple carriers. A good agent will explain policy details clearly.

Can an auto insurance agent help me save money on my policy?

Yes, an agent can review your driving record and vehicle type to find discounts you may qualify for. Common New York discounts include safe driver, multi-policy, and anti-theft device discounts. They can also adjust your deductibles to fit your budget.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.