ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsNew York › Buffalo

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Buffalo, NY

Browse auto insurance agents serving Buffalo, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Buffalo, New York is Willoughby Insurance, rated 4.8 stars across 996 reviews. Other highly rated options include Matthew Dorr at Comparion Insurance Agency, Austin Czaja - State Farm Insurance Agent, Anthony Lorigo at Comparion Insurance Agency. This directory lists 38 auto insurance agents serving Buffalo.

Showing 38 auto insurance agents in Buffalo, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Willoughby Insurance1523 Main St(716) 885-8100
2Matthew Dorr at Comparion Insurance Agency400 Essjay Rd #300(716) 809-9161
3Austin Czaja - State Farm Insurance Agent765 Wehrle Dr(716) 748-8942
4Anthony Lorigo at Comparion Insurance Agency400 Essjay Rd #300(716) 276-7249
5Dan Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent615 Elmwood Ave(716) 783-9460
6Damien Lawrence at Comparion Insurance Agency400 Essjay Rd #300(716) 276-7247
7Freeway Insurance1526 Walden Ave Suite 500(716) 250-9472
8Dan Hawrylczak - State Farm Insurance Agent1335 Hertel Ave(716) 873-3771
9Comparion Insurance Agency400 Essjay Rd #300(716) 677-2734
10Lawley361 Delaware Ave(716) 849-8618
WI
1523 Main St
Willoughby Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Willoughby Insurance serves the Buffalo, New York metro area as a local auto insurance agent. The agency helps drivers select personal auto policies that meet state requirements. It works with clients to compare coverage options for liability, collision, and uninsured motorist protection. The office assists with policy changes, such as adding new vehicles or updating coverage after a life event. For those needing proof of insurance, it handles the issuance of ID cards and binders for both new and renewing customers.

MD
400 Essjay Rd #300
Matthew Dorr at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Matthew Dorr at Comparion Insurance Agency supplies personal and commercial auto insurance policies for drivers in Buffalo, NY. The team assists clients with new policy applications, coverage adjustments, renewal management, and claims support. It also offers periodic policy reviews to ensure coverage meets changing needs. The office provides these plans for families, individuals, small business owners, and operators of personal or company vehicles. Typical properties serviced include single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

AC
765 Wehrle Dr
Austin Czaja - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Austin Czaja’s State Farm Insurance Agency serves local homeowners, renters, and business owners in Buffalo, NY, specializing in auto insurance coverage. The agency helps clients select policies that meet state requirements and protect personal vehicles from common road risks. Services include policy reviews, claims assistance, and guidance on coverage options for various driving situations. The agency also assists clients in the nearby community of Cheektowaga and throughout the greater Buffalo metropolitan area.

AL
400 Essjay Rd #300
Anthony Lorigo at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Anthony Lorigo at Comparion Insurance Agency in Buffalo, NY, offers both one-time policy purchases and ongoing coverage management as recurring service options, helping clients meet auto insurance requirements through liability and collision plans. As a local agent, the business advises on coverage levels to align with individual driving needs and regional regulations. Scheduled services include periodic policy reviews and updates for renewals, while new quotes and instant coverage changes are handled on an as-needed basis.

DS
615 Elmwood Ave
Dan Schmidt - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Serving Buffalo, New York, and the surrounding communities, Dan Schmidt’s State Farm Insurance Agency provides auto insurance policies for local drivers. The office handles coverage options for personal vehicles, helping clients meet New York state requirements. Each client’s situation is reviewed individually, with an agent who discusses liability limits, collision protection, and deductible choices. To handle a typical job, the agency reviews a driver’s specific needs and commuting patterns before recommending suitable policy options.

DL
400 Essjay Rd #300
Damien Lawrence at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Damien Lawrence at Comparion Insurance Agency in Buffalo serves local residents seeking coverage for their personal vehicles. The agency also writes commercial policies for businesses requiring auto protection for company fleets or work-related driving. Service extends throughout the Buffalo area, addressing the needs of drivers across the region. After an initial policy is issued, the agent follows up with clients to adjust coverage as their situations change, offering continued support between regular review visits.

FI
1526 Walden Ave Suite 500
Freeway Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Freeway Insurance helps clients in Buffalo, NY obtain necessary auto coverage. The agency also assists with adding specialty protections such as roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement. Policies are arranged to address common risks including accidents, theft, and weather damage typical to the area. This service is available to individual drivers, families, and commercial accounts operating offices, warehouses, or food service establishments.

DH
1335 Hertel Ave
Dan Hawrylczak - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Buffalo winters can make driving unpredictable, and Dan Hawrylczak - State Farm Insurance Agent helps local drivers protect their vehicles against the specific perils of harsh weather and busy city streets. As an auto insurance agent in Buffalo, NY, this agency assists customers in reviewing liability options, collision coverage, and uninsured motorist protection suited to everyday commutes and seasonal road hazards. The process begins with a straightforward consultation to assess individual driving needs, review current or desired coverage levels, and proceed to an initial policy review.

CI
400 Essjay Rd #300
Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Comparion Insurance Agency specializes in helping drivers in Buffalo find auto insurance policies that suit their unique needs. The agency works with individuals to navigate coverage options, from liability to collision, and assists with policy changes or claims filing. Serving the local area, it provides guidance on required New York state minimums and additional protections. Before winter weather arrives, the agency helps customers review their policies to ensure they are adequately covered for potential accidents or damage from snow and ice.

LA
361 Delaware Ave
Lawley
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY

Lawley, an auto insurance agent in Buffalo, NY, assists clients in securing coverage for personal vehicles against common risks like collision and liability. The agency works with local drivers to evaluate their specific protection needs and navigate available policy options from various insurers. Lawley’s service range helps customers manage factors such as deductibles and coverage limits. For those seeking additional security, the agency offers an add-on rental car reimbursement option to cover costs when a vehicle is in for repairs.

NB
686 Main St Suite 201
New Buffalo Insurance Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 332-1570
newbuffaloinsurance.com
DM
400 Essjay Rd #300
Donna Medina at Comparion Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 730-4909
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/northeast-region/donna-medina
FI
1832 Main St Apartment 1
Freeway Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 588-0715
locations.freeway.com/buffalo-car-insurance-14208-ny
DA
37 Elmwood Ave
The Decker Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 883-1455
deckeragency.com
NM
3407 Delaware Ave Ste 101
Nick Messuro - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 873-6015
insurancebuf.com
NN
5001 Genesee St
Niagara National Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 684-6000
niagaranational.com
WI
726 Exchange St Ste 200
Walsh Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 853-3820
walshins.com
NI
1840 Clinton St
NYCM Insurance Agency - Home, Auto & Business
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 404-0300
truecutinsurance.com
MA
36 Hopkins Rd
Maranto Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 633-1818
marantoagency.com
AI
333 International Dr
Amherst Insurance Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 580-1200
amherstinsurance.com
CC
735 Delaware Ave
Clauss & Company Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 886-6600
claussinsurance.com
FI
257 Allen St
Freeway Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 404-4175
locations.freeway.com/auto-insurance-buffalo-ny-14201
NI
1926 Clinton St
Nationwide Insurance: Cynthia Woltz Insurance Agency Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 822-6874
woltzinsurance.com
JC
2221 South Park Ave
Jim Corley - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 322-1239
insuringbuffalo.com
FS
16 Lake Ave
Father Son & Associates LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 823-1801
fsains.com
TD
1439 Main St
Toni DuBois Agency, LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 931-5200
toniduboisagency.com
HI
2333 Elmwood Ave
Hoch Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 881-1975
hochinsuranceagency.com
FA
Inside the Plan Room, 2075 Kenmore Ave Suite 1113
Franco Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 424-3123
francoinsure.com
AI
4550 Bailey Ave
Axxcess Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 833-1131
axxcessinsurance.com
VI
1459 Kensington Ave
VitalGuard Insurance, New York
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 577-9159
CI
1274 Bailey Ave
Centinello Insurance Agency LLC
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 893-4332
centinelloinsurance.com
LA
2476 William St
Lelonek Agency Inc
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 893-8188
lelonekagency.com
QI
454 Franklin St
QuickWard Insurance NY
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 666-4006
LC
4433 Genesee St #405
Low Cost Auto Insurance Market
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 527-2909
UI
90 Bryant Woods S
United Insurance Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 632-6118
FS
628 Washington St
Full Shield Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 356-2401
WI
2477 Union Rd
Wny Insurance Agency Llc
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 771-0012
HA
265 Delaware Ave
Henry Auto Insurance Agency: Progressive
Auto Insurance Agent · Buffalo, NY
(716) 641-2250
progressive.com/auto

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Buffalo Cost?

The average cost of auto insurance in New York is around $1,300 to $2,200 per year for full coverage. In Buffalo rates may be slightly lower than in New York City but can vary based on your driving history, age, and the type of vehicle you drive. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Buffalo

Auto insurance agents in Buffalo New York help drivers find coverage that meets New York state minimum requirements. New York law mandates liability insurance of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury. Agents can also explain supplemental coverage options like no-fault benefits and uninsured motorist protection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in New York?

New York requires liability coverage of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury. It also requires $10,000 for property damage, $50,000 for no-fault benefits, and $25,000 for uninsured motorist coverage per person.

How do I choose an auto insurance agent in Buffalo?

Look for an agent licensed in New York who has experience with local driving conditions and Buffalo weather risks. You can check the New York State Department of Financial Services website to verify an agents license status.

Can an agent help me lower my auto insurance premium in Buffalo?

Yes agents can review your driving record, vehicle type, and coverage needs to find discounts. Common discounts in New York include safe driver discounts, multi-policy discounts, and good student discounts.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.