ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsMichigan › St Joseph

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in St Joseph, MI

Browse auto insurance agents serving St Joseph, Michigan. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in St Joseph, Michigan is Jaden Gebbink - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.8 stars across 430 reviews. Other highly rated options include Jonah McDonough - State Farm Insurance Agent, Todd Heeter - State Farm Insurance Agent, The Batalis Agency - Farm Bureau Insurance. This directory lists 20 auto insurance agents serving St Joseph.

Showing 20 auto insurance agents in St Joseph, MIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Jaden Gebbink - State Farm Insurance Agent500 Renaissance Dr Ste 105-A(269) 932-4722
2Jonah McDonough - State Farm Insurance Agent2606 Lakeshore Dr(269) 408-8015
3Todd Heeter - State Farm Insurance Agent2600 Niles Ave(269) 983-7171
4The Batalis Agency - Farm Bureau Insurance2396 S Cleveland Ave Box 917(269) 983-0179
5Jason Vadney - State Farm Insurance Agent4062 Red Arrow Hwy(269) 408-8345
6Nulty Insurance Agency720 St Joseph Dr(269) 983-7161
7The Blaszczyk Agency- Farm Bureau Insurance2396 S Cleveland Ave(219) 306-6187
8IMS Insurance501 Main St(269) 983-7101
9Metzger Insurance Agency4146 M-139(269) 429-3160
10Farm Bureau Insurance2396 S Cleveland Ave(269) 983-8002
JG
500 Renaissance Dr Ste 105-A
Jaden Gebbink - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

Jaden Gebbink - State Farm Insurance Agent serves St. Joseph, Michigan, and the surrounding Berrien County area, providing auto insurance agentservices. The agency helps drivers obtain liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage for their vehicles. It also assists clients in managing policy changes, such as adding new drivers or vehicles. Additionally, this office handles bundling options that combine auto coverage with other personal insurance lines. By working with local residents directly, the agency tailors protection plans to fit individual driving needs and budgets common in Southwest Michigan.

JM
2606 Lakeshore Dr
Jonah McDonough - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

Jonah McDonough - State Farm Insurance Agent in St Joseph, MI provides a full range of coverage options, including auto, home, life, and renters insurance. The agency works closely with each client to tailor service plans that address their specific financial and protection needs. Regular policy reviews and claims assistance are offered to maintain appropriate coverage levels. This local agent serves single-family homes, apartments, retail, and restaurant properties seeking reliable insurance solutions.

TH
2600 Niles Ave
Todd Heeter - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

Homeowners, families, and drivers of all ages in St. Joseph, Michigan, receive personal auto insurance guidance from Todd Heeter - State Farm Insurance Agent. The agency assists customers in securing liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage tailored to individual driving needs and local road conditions. They also offer information on available discounts for safe driving and multiple policies. This service area further extends to nearby Benton Harbor, ensuring broader access for residents throughout the surrounding county seeking reliable insurance support.

BA
2396 S Cleveland Ave Box 917
The Batalis Agency - Farm Bureau Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

The Batalis Agency - Farm Bureau Insurance in St Joseph, MI, assists clients in distinguishing between one-time policy purchases and ongoing coverage plans to match individual driving needs. As an auto insurance agent, the agency helps drivers select appropriate protection levels and explains how deductibles influence policy premiums. Services, including policy review, claims guidance, and coverage adjustments, run on a scheduled basis for existing customers and as-needed for new inquiries or policy changes.

JV
4062 Red Arrow Hwy
Jason Vadney - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

Serving St. Joseph, Michigan, and the surrounding Berrien County communities, Jason Vadney’s State Farm Insurance Agency handles personal auto insurance policies for local drivers. This office works with clients to select appropriate liability and comprehensive coverage options that meet Michigan’s unique no-fault insurance requirements. The agent typically reviews each driver’s daily commute, vehicle type, and personal driving history to tailor a personalized policy that balances necessary protection with budgetary needs.

NI
720 St Joseph Dr
Nulty Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

Nulty Insurance Agency provides tailored auto insurance policies designed to meet individual needs in St Joseph, MI, covering liability, collision, and comprehensive options. The agency works to find protection that fits various budgets and driving profiles, offering clear explanations of coverage details for local clients. It assists drivers with understanding deductible choices and policy limits while navigating seasonal concerns like icy road conditions and winter driving risks in southwest Michigan.

BA
2396 S Cleveland Ave
The Blaszczyk Agency- Farm Bureau Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

The Blaszczyk Agency- Farm Bureau Insurance assists residential clients in St Joseph, MI with protecting their personal vehicles and property through tailored auto insurance plans. Commercial coverage for business vehicles and fleets is also available, serving the local community and surrounding areas. The agency provides clear guidance to help customers understand their policy options and coverage limits. Follow-up service and policy reviews are offered between regular visits to ensure ongoing protection.

II
501 Main St
IMS Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

As winter conditions create icy roads and unpredictable driving in St. Joseph, drivers rely on IMS Insurance to review coverage options tailored to local risks. This automotive insurance agent monitors evolving policy needs, from liability upgrades to comprehensive protection against storm damage or deer collisions. Technicians here assess vehicles for existing damage during policy setup, noting windshield chips or body dents that affect claim eligibility. New clients begin with a thorough inspection to document current vehicle condition before finalizing coverage details.

MI
4146 M-139
Metzger Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

Metzger Insurance Agency works with drivers in St Joseph, MI to secure reliable auto coverage that meets legal requirements and personal needs. The agency specializes in add-ons like roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, and comprehensive plans for added protection against unexpected events. Clear policy explanations help clients choose appropriate deductibles and liability limits. Residential and commercial auto insurance are both available. The agency can also serve local offices needing fleet policies, warehouses requiring vehicle coverage for logistics operations, and food service businesses with delivery fleets.

FB
2396 S Cleveland Ave
Farm Bureau Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI

Farm Bureau Insurance in St Joseph, MI, is a local auto insurance agent known for providing personalized coverage options to area drivers. The agency serves clients throughout Berrien County, helping them select policies that meet state requirements and personal needs. Customers can discuss liability, collision, and comprehensive plans during consultations. The office also assists with bundling auto insurance with other property protections for added convenience. For those needing immediate proof of coverage, the agency offers same-day policy issuance.

AO
830 Pleasant St # 201
Auto-Owners Insurance St. Joseph Claims
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 983-4150
auto-owners.com
SJ
2900 Niles Ave
Saint Joseph, MI AAA Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 982-5262
michigan.aaa.com/scott.bradford
RJ
818 Ship St
Ryan James Agency: Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 684-5200
agents.allstate.com/ryan-james-agency-saint-joseph-mi.html
SI
4146 Guest Dr
Stemm Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 556-9086
locator.meemic.com/mi/st-joseph/stemm-agency
WA
206 Court St Suite B
Wallace Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 932-7100
wallaceagency.com
LT
517 Broad Street
Liskey / TRICOR Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 983-1644
liskeyinsurance.com
FB
2396 S Cleveland Ave
Farm Bureau Insurance - Resseguie Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 983-2165
caseyresseguieinsurancequote.com
DI
800 Ship St # 105
Donnellan Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 983-3900
AI
2900 Niles Rd
AAA Insurance - Bradford Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 982-5262
locator.acg.aaa.com/mi/st-joseph/aaa-insurance-bradford-insurance-agency
AI
1901 Niles Ave Suite 101
Advasure Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · St Joseph, MI
(269) 841-1000
advasureinsurance.com

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in St Joseph Cost?

The average cost of full coverage auto insurance in Michigan is around $2,700 per year but rates in St Joseph can range from $1,500 to $4,000 annually depending on your driving record, vehicle type, and coverage choices. Michigan has higher rates due to unlimited medical benefits under no-fault law. Costs vary by case so compare quotes from multiple agents. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in St Joseph

Auto insurance agents in St Joseph Michigan help drivers navigate Michigan no-fault insurance laws which require unlimited personal injury protection. Local agents can explain the state minimum liability limits of 50/100/10 and assist with choosing deductibles. Working with an agent in Berrien County ensures you understand how local factors like lake effect weather affect your policy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the minimum auto insurance requirements in Michigan?

Michigan requires no-fault insurance with unlimited medical benefits for injuries. You must also have property protection insurance and residual bodily injury and property damage liability with minimum limits of 50/100/10. An agent in St Joseph can explain these requirements in detail.

How does Michigan no-fault insurance affect my claim?

Under Michigan no-fault law your own insurance pays for your medical bills and lost wages regardless of who caused the accident. You have one year from the accident date to file a claim for benefits. A local agent can help you understand how this applies in St Joseph.

Can I get a discount on auto insurance in St Joseph Michigan?

Many Michigan insurers offer discounts for safe driving, bundling home and auto policies, and completing defensive driving courses. Some companies also reduce rates for vehicles with anti-theft devices. Ask your St Joseph agent about available discounts for your specific situation.

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.