ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Tallahassee, FL

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Tallahassee, Florida. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Tallahassee, Florida is McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency, rated 5.0 stars across 1,257 reviews. Other highly rated options include Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services, The Medicare Help Desk, Alliance Insurance. This directory lists 20 supplemental insurance agents serving Tallahassee.

Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Tallahassee, FLListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency2367 Centerville Rd(850) 329-6996
2Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services2880 Apalachee Pkwy(850) 412-1099
3The Medicare Help Desk3184 Hawks Landing Dr(850) 632-0033
4Alliance Insurance1138 E Tennessee St(850) 878-9664
5Woodham Insurance2286 Wednesday St STE 1(850) 597-9503
6Doug Croley Insurance Services2814 Remington Green Cir(850) 386-1922
7Fuqua Insurance Agency1836 Hermitage Blvd(850) 386-2300
8Tyre Insurance Agency1114 N Adams St(850) 385-2093
9GreatFlorida Insurance: Tara Smith2522 Capital Cir NE STE 4(850) 523-0605
10McKee Insurance Agency1701 Hermitage Blvd Suite 201(850) 224-6055
MH
2367 Centerville Rd
McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency serves the Tallahassee, Florida, metro area as a supplemental insurance agent. The firm helps individuals and families obtain coverage that bridges gaps left by primary health plans, including policies that address out-of-pocket medical costs and unexpected income loss. Supplemental insurance plans are designed to provide financial protection for specific events not fully covered by major medical insurance. The agency handles accident insurance and hospital indemnity policies in this region.

WI
2880 Apalachee Pkwy
Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services provides supplemental insurance coverage to residents and businesses in Tallahassee, FL. Its plans help bridge gaps left by primary health, life, or disability policies by offering additional benefits for unexpected medical costs or income loss. The agency assists clients in selecting suitable policies and provides ongoing service to manage claims or adjust coverage as needs change. It serves a variety of properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail stores, and restaurants.

MH
3184 Hawks Landing Dr
The Medicare Help Desk
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

The Medicare Help Desk serves local homeowners and retirees in the Tallahassee area who need guidance with supplemental insurance plans. This agency helps clients understand and enroll in policies designed to cover gaps in original Medicare benefits, addressing routine out-of-pocket expenses. As a supplemental insurance agent, they assist individuals in comparing plan options suited to their healthcare needs and budgets. The agency also extends its services to residents in and around the neighboring community of Woodville.

AI
1138 E Tennessee St
Alliance Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Serving Tallahassee and the surrounding communities of Leon, Gadsden, and Wakulla counties, Alliance Insurance works as a supplemental insurance agent. It assists clients with policies that help cover gaps in primary health plans, such as accident or hospital indemnity coverage. The agency focuses on protecting against out-of-pocket costs that may arise from unexpected medical events or treatments. For a typical job, it guides a client through plan options by explaining policy benefits and filling out any necessary enrollment paperwork.

WI
2286 Wednesday St STE 1
Woodham Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

During Florida’s unpredictable storm season, many Tallahassee residents reassess their existing coverage gaps. Woodham Insurance provides supplemental insurance agent services tailored to help individuals address expenses that major medical plans often leave uncovered, such as deductibles, copays, or extended care costs. Their agency focuses on explaining how supplemental policies can integrate with current health or life coverage without duplication. Each consultation begins with an initial needs assessment, where a representative reviews a client’s existing plans to identify specific gaps before recommending any policy for consideration.

DC
2814 Remington Green Cir
Doug Croley Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Many supplemental insurance plans are designed for one-time enrollment with recurring monthly premiums, while others offer short-term coverage options for specific needs. Doug Croley Insurance Services in Tallahassee, FL, assists clients in evaluating these different models when selecting policies for dental, vision, or accident protection. These plans typically supplement primary health coverage by providing fixed cash benefits for defined services or events. Local residents can schedule an appointment on a one-time or as-needed basis to review their current coverage or explore new supplemental options.

FI
1836 Hermitage Blvd
Fuqua Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Fuqua Insurance Agency specializes in supplemental insurance policies that help cover expenses beyond primary health coverage, serving the Tallahassee area. It assists clients with selecting plans that address gaps in medical, dental, or disability protection through individual consultations. The agency guides customers through enrollment processes and ongoing policy management to ensure suitable coverage. During open enrollment seasons or following a recent hospital stay, it helps individuals review options and fill coverage needs that primary insurance does not fully address.

TI
1114 N Adams St
Tyre Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

Tyre Insurance Agency is a supplemental insurance agent serving the Tallahassee, FL area, focusing on policies that fill coverage gaps left by standard health or life plans. Its specialty includes adding extra protection for critical illness, accident recovery, or hospital indemnity needs. These add-ons help individuals manage out-of-pocket expenses during unexpected medical events. The agency supports commercial clients, such as local offices, warehouses, and food service operations, by offering tailored supplemental coverage for their employees.

GI
2522 Capital Cir NE STE 4
GreatFlorida Insurance: Tara Smith
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

GreatFlorida Insurance: Tara Smith serves residential clients in Tallahassee with supplemental insurance policies, filling gaps in primary health coverage. Commercial coverage is also available for local businesses seeking additional protection. Assistance is offered throughout the Tallahassee area, helping clients select appropriate plans for their needs. The agency provides guidance on policy details and claims processes. Between regular health insurance visits, agents follow up to adjust coverage or address changes in circumstances.

MI
1701 Hermitage Blvd Suite 201
McKee Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL

McKee Insurance Agency in Tallahassee, FL, is known for providing supplemental insurance policies that fill financial gaps left by primary health coverage. It serves local individuals and families with various voluntary plans designed to cover out-of-pocket costs for accidents, critical illnesses, and hospital stays. These flexible benefits help policyholders manage deductibles and copays while protecting savings. The agency also specializes in arranging separate dental and vision insurance for comprehensive care.

GI
3201 Shamrock St S Ste 104
GreatFlorida Insurance: Chad Mcclellan
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 825-7055
northtallahassee.greatflorida.com
CI
2457 Care Dr Suite A-200
Capital Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(800) 780-3100
capitalins.com
AI
1701 Hermitage Blvd Suite 201
Acentria Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 668-6162
acentria.com
BL
1500 Mahan Dr Ste 150
Bankers Life
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 894-2022
branches.bankerslife.com/fl/tallahassee/1500-mahan-dr
DI
215 Delta Ct
Dodson Insurance LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 508-5140
trustdodson.com
BH
1634 - C, 1634 Metropolitan Blvd # C
Baker-Harris Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 386-1420
baker-harris.com
EB
3131 Lonnbladh Rd
Earl Bacon Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 878-2121
earlbacon.com
FI
209 Pinewood Dr
Franklin Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 681-0433
franklin-ins.com
JM
1500 Mahan Dr Ste 150
Julia Mendoza, Bankers Life Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(850) 894-2022
agents.bankerslife.com/fl/tallahassee/1500-mahan-dr/julia-mendoza
SE
113 S Monroe St 1st floor
Shawn E Brown Insurance - Health & Medicare Advisors
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Tallahassee, FL
(386) 866-1090
shawnbrowninsurance.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Tallahassee Cost?

Supplemental insurance agent services are typically free to you because agents earn commissions from insurance companies. Medigap plan premiums in Florida range from about $100 to $300 per month depending on age gender and plan type. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums but may have copays. This is general information not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Tallahassee

Supplemental insurance agents in Tallahassee help residents navigate Medicare Supplement plans and other gap coverage. Florida law requires agents to be licensed by the state and follow specific marketing rules. Local agents understand the needs of retirees and families in Leon County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Tallahassee?

A supplemental insurance agent helps you buy policies that cover gaps in Medicare or employer health plans. They can explain Medigap plans A through N and Medicare Advantage options. In Florida agents must hold a valid 2-15 or 2-40 license.

How do I choose a supplemental insurance agent in Tallahassee?

Look for an agent who represents multiple carriers so they can compare plans. Check their license status on the Florida Department of Financial Services website. Ask about their experience with Medicare enrollment periods.

What is the best time to enroll in a supplemental plan in Florida?

The Medicare Supplement Open Enrollment Period lasts six months starting when you turn 65 and enroll in Part B. During this time you cannot be denied coverage due to health conditions. Outside this window insurers may use medical underwriting.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Florida Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.