ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeRenters Insurance AgentsOhio › Westerville

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in Westerville, OH

Browse renters insurance agents serving Westerville, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in Westerville, Ohio is Billy Tecklenburg - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 500 reviews. Other highly rated options include Keith Zabrocki: Allstate Insurance, Masters Insurance Group, April Schaad - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 20 renters insurance agents serving Westerville.

Showing 20 renters insurance agents in Westerville, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Billy Tecklenburg - State Farm Insurance Agent102 County Line Rd W Unit B(614) 890-1166
2Keith Zabrocki: Allstate Insurance925 N State St Ste I(614) 682-6030
3Masters Insurance Group178 W Schrock Rd Suite A(614) 471-7676
4April Schaad - State Farm Insurance Agent309 S State St(614) 891-5033
5Megan Brooks at Comparion Insurance Agency600 N Cleveland Ave #190(614) 245-6154
6Anthony Pelfrey - State Farm Insurance Agent309 S State St(614) 656-1932
7Justin Giger - State Farm Insurance Agent20 W Main St(614) 882-9414
8The Harmony Agency: Allstate Insurance510 S State St(614) 442-7777
9Steadfast Insurance LLC167 S State St #175
10Highfield Insurance Agency LLC155 Commerce Park Dr(614) 882-3141
BT
102 County Line Rd W Unit B
Billy Tecklenburg - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

Billy Tecklenburg - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Westerville, OH area, offering renters insurance designed to protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage. The agency helps tenants find policies that cover losses from theft, fire, or water damage, with options for temporary living expenses if a rental becomes uninhabitable. Billy Tecklenburg also assists with policy bundling and valuations for high-value items like electronics or jewelry.

KZ
925 N State St Ste I
Keith Zabrocki: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

Keith Zabrocki: Allstate Insurance in Westerville, Ohio provides a range of renters insurance services designed to protect personal belongings and offer liability coverage. Its service options include helping clients assess their coverage needs, explaining policy terms clearly, and offering dedicated claims support through Allstate’s system. Maintenance of a policy typically involves periodic review meetings to adjust coverage as circumstances change. The agency services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants, ensuring each property type receives appropriate protection for its specific risks.

MI
178 W Schrock Rd Suite A
Masters Insurance Group
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

Masters Insurance Group serves renters and tenants throughout Westerville, Ohio, helping them secure policies that protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage. The company works directly with clients to explain coverage options for apartments, condos, and single-family rentals. By guiding customers through policy terms and deductible choices, they ensure each renter finds appropriate financial protection for their living space. Masters Insurance Group also extends its renters insurance services to residents in nearby Gahanna and other surrounding areas within the Columbus metropolitan region.

AS
309 S State St
April Schaad - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

April Schaad - State Farm Insurance Agent serves clients in Westerville, Ohio and the surrounding communities. The agency handles renters insurance, addressing the protection of personal belongings and liability coverage within rental properties. It structures policies to cover typical risks such as theft, fire damage, and water damage from certain plumbing issues. In handling a typical job, the agency first assesses the client’s specific living situation and personal property value, then tailors a coverage plan to match those unique needs.

MB
600 N Cleveland Ave #190
Megan Brooks at Comparion Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

Megan Brooks at Comparion Insurance Agency in Westerville, Ohio, specializes in helping renters secure customized coverage for personal belongings and liability protection. This agency works to evaluate each client’s unique living situation and find fitting policy options from its offerings. Regular risk assessments and flexible plan adjustments are available to adapt to changing needs. As autumn approaches and dead leaves increase slip hazards on walkways, the agency assists clients in reviewing their liability limits to ensure adequate protection from fall-related accidents.

AP
309 S State St
Anthony Pelfrey - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

Anthony Pelfrey, operating as a State Farm Insurance Agent in Westerville, OH, helps clients differentiate between one-time temporary policies and recurring annual agreements for renters protection. Coverage typically addresses personal property replacement, liability for guest injuries, and additional living expenses if a home becomes uninhabitable. Service options are available on an as-needed basis for policy adjustments or claims assistance, while annual renewals are handled on a scheduled timeline.

JG
20 W Main St
Justin Giger - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

Justin Giger - State Farm Insurance Agent provides renters insurance guidance for Westerville residents. This agent assists clients in protecting personal belongings against common perils and offers tailored liability coverage. Policyholders can explore additional endorsements for valuable items such as jewelry or electronics. The agency’s services extend beyond individual renters to commercial sectors, understanding the distinct insurance needs of offices, warehouses, and food service operations.

HA
510 S State St
The Harmony Agency: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

As the changing seasons in Westerville bring increased rainfall or winter freeze risks, residents seek dependable protection for their rental property and belongings. The Harmony Agency: Allstate Insurance provides guidance for local tenants choosing appropriate coverage, including liability and personal property insurance. Their agents explain common policy options, helping renters understand deductibles and claim procedures. An initial review of the renter’s current lease terms and an inventory of valuables often serves as the first practical assessment step.

SI
167 S State St #175
Steadfast Insurance LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
HI
155 Commerce Park Dr
Highfield Insurance Agency LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH

Highfield Insurance Agency LLC serves residential clients by writing renters insurance policies in Westerville, Ohio and the surrounding area. Commercial coverage for landlords and small business owners renting property is also offered. The agency helps tenants protect personal belongings, provide liability protection, and secure temporary living expenses if a unit becomes uninhabitable. Service continues when policyholders require evidence of coverage for a new lease, coverage changes mid-term, or a simple renewal review between regular scheduled contacts.

DI
212 S State St
Dolbow Insurance LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 899-1611
dolbowinsurance.com
KI
190 S State St
Kalmbaugh Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 890-7222
kalmbaughinsurance.com
CI
600 N Cleveland Ave #190
Comparion Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 245-6150
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/ohio/westerville-0813
DM
405 W Main St
Debbie Montgomery - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 890-2886
debbiemontgomeryinsurance.com
OI
5855 Chandler Ct
Otto Insurance Group
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 964-2303
otto-ins.com
FI
107 E College Ave # 202
Fetchero Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 891-9311
fetcheroinsurance.com
JL
600 N Cleveland Ave #190
James Linscott-Hill, Insurance Agent | Comparion Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 458-2008
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/ohio/westerville-0813/jimmy-linscott-hill
BY
425 W Schrock Rd #101
Bill Young - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 898-9977
billyoungs.com
AI
925 N State St Suite 200
Associated Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(380) 208-0231
associated-ins.com
OK
1001 Eastwind Dr #108
Outcalt Kerns Insurance, LLC
Renters Insurance Agent · Westerville, OH
(614) 890-0383
okinsa.net

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in Westerville Cost?

Renters insurance in Ohio typically costs between 15 and 30 dollars per month for a standard policy. In Westerville the price may vary based on your rental type location and coverage amount. Higher liability limits or replacement cost coverage will increase the premium. This is general information not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in Westerville

Renters insurance agents in Westerville Ohio help tenants protect their personal property and liability. Ohio law does not require renters insurance but many landlords in Westerville now ask for proof of coverage. An agent can explain how Ohio policy limits and deductibles apply to your rental situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does renters insurance cover in Westerville Ohio?

Renters insurance typically covers your personal belongings like furniture and electronics against fire theft or vandalism. It also includes liability protection if someone is injured in your rental. Ohio policies often offer actual cash value or replacement cost coverage options.

Is renters insurance required by law in Ohio?

Ohio state law does not require renters insurance. However many landlords in Westerville include a requirement in the lease agreement. An agent can help you find a policy that meets your landlords rules.

How do I choose a renters insurance agent in Westerville?

Look for an agent licensed in Ohio who works with multiple insurance companies. Ask about coverage limits for your specific belongings and any Ohio specific exclusions like flood or earthquake damage. Compare quotes from several agents before deciding.

Renters Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.