ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsPennsylvania › Mechanicsburg

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Mechanicsburg, PA

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania is Nu Life Healthcare, rated 4.9 stars across 187 reviews. Other highly rated options include Seth Gardner - State Farm Insurance Agent, Walter Hargraves Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent, Shana Mickle at Comparion Insurance Agency. This directory lists 28 medicare insurance agents serving Mechanicsburg.

Showing 28 medicare insurance agents in Mechanicsburg, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Nu Life Healthcare1100 Bent Creek Blvd #102(717) 600-0160
2Seth Gardner - State Farm Insurance Agent2 E Winding Hill Rd(717) 766-7180
3Walter Hargraves Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent42 E Main St(717) 766-6385
4Shana Mickle at Comparion Insurance Agency5000 Ritter Rd #103(570) 980-6094
5Fetrow Insurance Associates, LLC5299 E Trindle Rd(717) 766-3200
6Grove Financial & Associates, Inc.350 S Sporting Hill Rd(717) 763-8514
7Ashley Burgett at Comparion Insurance Agency5000 Ritter Rd #103(717) 590-6697
8Comparion Insurance Agency5000 Ritter Rd #103(717) 795-8703
9Adam Evans at Comparion Insurance Agency5000 Ritter Rd #103(717) 590-6699
10Insurance Freedom Associates - Mechanicsburg230 S Sporting Hill Rd Suite 101(717) 766-3622
NL
1100 Bent Creek Blvd #102
Nu Life Healthcare
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Nu Life Healthcare serves the Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania area as a Medicare insurance agency. The company helps local residents navigate Medicare enrollment and annual plan changes. It assists clients with comparing supplemental coverage options and prescription drug plans. The staff provides guidance on Medicare Advantage plans, including both HMO and PPO network choices. Nu Life Healthcare also processes enrollments for Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage.

SG
2 E Winding Hill Rd
Seth Gardner - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Seth Gardner - State Farm Insurance Agent in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, offers a range of Medicare insurance services, including assistance with plan selection and enrollment. The office provides ongoing support to help clients understand their coverage options and manage policy changes throughout the year. Service plans focus on simplifying the complexities of Medicare for local beneficiaries. The agent works with individuals and families, serving those living in single-family homes and apartments, as well as retail workers and restaurant employees in the Mechanicsburg area.

WH
42 E Main St
Walter Hargraves Jr - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Walter Hargraves Jr serves homeowners, retirees, and working families seeking guidance on Medicare insurance plans in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania. The agency assists clients with understanding their Medicare options, enrollment periods, and affordable coverage choices. It provides personalized consultations to help local residents compare plans and find suitable health insurance solutions. This service area includes Mechanicsburg and extends into the adjacent communities of Camp Hill and the greater Harrisburg metropolitan region.

SM
5000 Ritter Rd #103
Shana Mickle at Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Shana Mickle at Comparion Insurance Agency in Mechanicsburg, PA helps clients understand the difference between enrolling once during Initial Enrollment and setting up recurring annual reviews as options change. Coverage selections center on matching available Medicare plans to individual medical and financial needs. This medicare insurance agent offers service on both a scheduled annual basis for plan changes and as-needed for immediate questions or life updates.

FI
5299 E Trindle Rd
Fetrow Insurance Associates, LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Serving the Mechanicsburg area and surrounding central Pennsylvania communities, Fetrow Insurance Associates, LLC handles Medicare insurance plans for local residents. The company works with individuals to understand their specific healthcare coverage options during enrollment periods. A typical job involves reviewing a client's current plan, discussing available Medicare Advantage and supplement alternatives, and then providing a clear explanation of how each option addresses their needs and budget.

GF
350 S Sporting Hill Rd
Grove Financial & Associates, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Grove Financial & Associates, Inc. provides guidance on Medicare supplement plans and prescription drug coverage for clients in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania. It assists individuals in enrolling during initial eligibility periods and annual open enrollment. The agency helps clarify the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage options. As the annual Medicare open enrollment period approaches, the company provides personalized support to help clients evaluate current plans and make necessary adjustments for the coming year.

AB
5000 Ritter Rd #103
Ashley Burgett at Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Ashley Burgett at Comparion Insurance Agency in Mechanicsburg, PA, assists local residents with understanding and selecting Medicare coverage options. As a dedicated Medicare insurance agent, this practice specializes in guiding clients through the complexities of plan enrollment and annual changes, tailoring recommendations to individual health and financial needs. Commercial sectors it can serve include professional offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

CI
5000 Ritter Rd #103
Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

As the annual Medicare enrollment period approaches, residents of Mechanicsburg and the surrounding Cumberland Valley often face complex decisions about their coverage options. Comparion Insurance Agency in Mechanicsburg helps navigate these choices by reviewing each client’s current plan, health needs, and budget to identify suitable Medicare insurance solutions. The process begins with a no-obligation initial consultation to compare available plans and confirm eligibility for any special enrollment periods.

AE
5000 Ritter Rd #103
Adam Evans at Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Adam Evans at Comparion Insurance Agency serves residents in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, helping them navigate Medicare insurance options for their healthcare needs. The agency also assists with related commercial coverage choices that may suit local small business owners and their employees. Serving the greater Mechanicsburg area, the agency provides guidance on plan comparisons and enrollment periods. Clients often return for annual policy reviews, ensuring their coverage continues to meet changing health requirements during regular check-in visits.

IF
230 S Sporting Hill Rd Suite 101
Insurance Freedom Associates - Mechanicsburg
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA

Insurance Freedom Associates - Mechanicsburg is known for guiding Medicare beneficiaries through the complex selection of plans and coverage options across the Mechanicsburg, PA area. Their agents work to clarify Part A, Part B, and Part D benefits while helping clients identify suitable supplement plans for their healthcare needs. They assist with understanding enrollment periods and comparing available local policies. For more tailored support, the company can additionally provide consultations focused on Medicare Advantage plan options for eligible individuals.

RT
200 W Main St
R T Dunn Insurance Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 766-0770
rtdunninsuranceagency.com
JO
5115 E Trindle Rd
James O. Bower Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 763-5668
bowerins.com
DI
6483 Carlisle Pike
DJM Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 796-6601
djminsurance.com
SI
1001 S Market St STE C
Shiner Insurance Agency PC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 766-1200
shinerinsurance.com
IA
4 Kacey Ct
Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 204-8602
hilkekrzeminski598.wixsite.com/insurance-agency
JC
1215 Manor Drive Ste 300
Jacob Canning, Bankers Life Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 791-2100
agents.bankerslife.com/pa/mechanicsburg/1215-manor-dr/jacob-canning
KH
1215 Manor Drive Ste 300
Kyle Heckert, Bankers Life Agent and Bankers Life Securities Financial Representative
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 791-2100
agents.bankerslife.com/pa/mechanicsburg/1215-manor-dr/kyle-heckert
HD
6416 Carlisle Pike
Highmark Direct Health Insurance Store
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 302-7900
highmarkdirect.com
AA
4550 Lena Dr
AIA Alera Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 591-8280
aia.aleragroup.com
EI
4901 Louise Dr
Erie Insurance: Harrisburg Office
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 795-8200
erieinsurance.com/contact-erie/locations/harrisburg
BL
1215 Manor Drive Ste 300
Bankers Life
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 791-2100
branches.bankerslife.com/pa/mechanicsburg/1215-manor-dr
VH
1215 Manor Drive Ste 300
Vontina Hall, Bankers Life Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 791-2100
agents.bankerslife.com/pa/mechanicsburg/1215-manor-dr/vontina-hall
MI
4999 Louise Dr # 201
Murray Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 620-2400
murrayins.com/contact/offices
MR
5000 Ritter Rd #103
Matthew Roberts at Comparion Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 590-6702
comparioninsurance.com/insurance-agent/pennsylvania/mechanicsburg-0357/matthew-roberts
GI
4999 Louise Dr # 201
Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 620-2400
assuredpartners.com/Mechanicsburg
PS
1215 Manor Drive Ste 300
Patrick Schussler, Bankers Life Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 791-2100
agents.bankerslife.com/pa/mechanicsburg/1215-manor-dr/patrick-schussler
CH
1215 Manor Drive Ste 300
Cherelle Harvey, Bankers Life Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 791-2100
agents.bankerslife.com/pa/mechanicsburg/1215-manor-dr/cherelle-harvey
AB
1215 Manor Drive Ste 300
Adam Bricker, Bankers Life Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 791-2100
agents.bankerslife.com/pa/mechanicsburg/1215-manor-dr/adam-bricker

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Mechanicsburg Cost?

Medicare insurance agent services in Pennsylvania are typically free to consumers because agents earn commissions from insurance carriers. These commissions are built into the plan premiums and do not increase your out-of-pocket costs. For Medicare Supplement plans premiums can range from around $100 to $300 per month depending on your age health and the plan type. This is general information not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Mechanicsburg

Medicare insurance agents in Mechanicsburg Pennsylvania help residents navigate Original Medicare Medicare Advantage and Part D drug plans. Pennsylvania law requires agents to be licensed and to disclose their compensation. Local agents understand the specific network options available in Cumberland County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a Medicare insurance agent in Mechanicsburg do?

A Medicare insurance agent helps you compare plans from different carriers and enroll in coverage that fits your needs. They can explain the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage. Agents in Pennsylvania must follow state regulations regarding marketing and sales.

When can I enroll in Medicare in Mechanicsburg Pennsylvania?

You have an Initial Enrollment Period that starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after. There is also an Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 each year. Pennsylvania residents may also qualify for Special Enrollment Periods after certain life events.

Are Medicare insurance agents in Pennsylvania free to use?

Most Medicare insurance agents do not charge you directly for their services. They are paid commissions by the insurance companies whose plans you choose. You should confirm the agent's compensation structure before working with them.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.