ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Butler, PA

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Butler, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Butler, Pennsylvania is Baker Consulting Services, Inc., rated 5.0 stars across 235 reviews. Other highly rated options include John E Hollock Insurance Agency, Tim Reges Jr Insurance and Financial Services, Inc., AAdvantage Insurance Services. This directory lists 19 medicare insurance agents serving Butler.

Showing 19 medicare insurance agents in Butler, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Baker Consulting Services, Inc.124 S Washington St(724) 302-3164
2John E Hollock Insurance Agency506 N Main St(724) 283-3897
3Tim Reges Jr Insurance and Financial Services, Inc.340 N McKean St(724) 283-2260
4AAdvantage Insurance Services1723 N Main St Ext(724) 287-3743
5AAA Butler Insurance and Member Services138 Clearview Cir(724) 287-2713
6Gwen Sciullo - State Farm Insurance Agent293 Evans City Rd(724) 285-3259
7Farmers Insurance - John Aubrey10 Pittsburgh Rd(724) 256-9955
8Health Benefit Options340 N Main St(724) 705-0068
9Kotch Insurance Agency201 S Duffy Rd(724) 285-1164
10Health Management Brokers614 Moraine Pointe Plaza(724) 822-0388
BC
124 S Washington St
Baker Consulting Services, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Baker Consulting Services, Inc. serves the Butler, Pennsylvania area as a Medicare insurance agent. This agency assists clients with navigating their Medicare options and finding suitable coverage plans. It helps individuals understand the differences between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage. The business also guides clients through the enrollment process, ensuring policyholders meet key deadlines. Its specific services include evaluating and enrolling clients in Medicare Supplement plans and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans.

JE
506 N Main St
John E Hollock Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Seniors and retirees in the Butler, PA area turn to John E Hollock Insurance Agency for experienced assistance with Medicare insurance plans. The agency helps clients navigate original Medicare, supplement options, and prescription drug coverage. They answer questions about enrollment periods and plan comparisons. With a focus on clear explanations, they aim to match each individual’s health needs and budget. They also serve residents in surrounding communities such as Cranberry Township and across nearby Butler County for local access to Medicare advice and enrollment support.

TR
340 N McKean St
Tim Reges Jr Insurance and Financial Services, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Tim Reges Jr Insurance and Financial Services, Inc. provides Medicare insurance guidance and enrollment assistance to individuals in the Butler, Pennsylvania area. Its service approach includes plan comparisons, annual enrollment support, and ongoing policy reviews to help clients adapt to changing healthcare needs. The company serves individual homeowners and families residing in single-family homes, as well as those living in apartments and other residential properties. It also works with clients managing commercial properties such as retail storefronts and restaurants.

AI
1723 N Main St Ext
AAdvantage Insurance Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

AAdvantage Insurance Services in Butler, PA distinguishes between an initial consultation, which is a one-time event, and the ongoing support available through annual enrollment periods for coverage adjustments. Their Medicare insurance agent work helps clients navigate plans by filing claims or discussing Part D prescription needs. These assistance services can run either as a single appointment, on a set schedule for yearly reviews, or on an as-needed basis whenever a coverage change arises.

AB
138 Clearview Cir
AAA Butler Insurance and Member Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Serving Butler and the surrounding communities in western Pennsylvania, AAA Butler Insurance and Member Services handles the needs of individuals navigating Medicare. The company helps clients understand their options, from Original Medicare to Medicare Advantage and prescription drug plans. To manage these choices, the agent takes time to review each person’s specific health and financial situation. It then compares available plans to find a suitable match, ensuring clear explanations along the way.

GS
293 Evans City Rd
Gwen Sciullo - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

As Medicare open enrollment season approaches each year, many Butler residents seek reliable guidance on their plan options. Gwen Sciullo, operating as a State Farm Insurance Agent, serves the local community by offering Medicare insurance solutions tailored to individual healthcare needs. The agency helps clients navigate plan choices, from prescription coverage to supplemental policies, ensuring they understand each benefit. Clients are encouraged to schedule an initial personal assessment to review their specific coverage requirements.

FI
10 Pittsburgh Rd
Farmers Insurance - John Aubrey
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Offering personalized assistance with Medicare supplement plans and Advantage options, Farmers Insurance - John Aubrey in Butler, PA helps individuals navigate the complex landscape of healthcare coverage. The agency provides guidance in comparing plans to match specific medical needs and budgets, ensuring clients understand their choices for prescription drug and hospital coverage. As rolling enrollment periods approach, it assists locals in reviewing their current policies for potential updates that better address evolving health requirements during seasonal changes.

HB
340 N Main St
Health Benefit Options
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Health Benefit Options in Butler, PA assists individuals with understanding and selecting Medicare coverage. The company specializes in navigating the nuances of Medicare Advantage plans and Part D prescription drug policies. It works to align insurance options with each client’s specific healthcare needs and budget constraints. The firm helps those managing offices, running warehouse operations, and working in food service to find appropriate supplemental coverage tailored to their schedules and income considerations.

KI
201 S Duffy Rd
Kotch Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Kotch Insurance Agency provides residential Medicare insurance services to individuals in the Butler, Pennsylvania area, also addressing commercial coverage needs for clients across the wider region. The agency assists with enrollment in Medicare plans and clarifies option details for local beneficiaries. Following an initial consultation, the office offers ongoing support, sending reminders to review coverage when annual enrollment periods approach and scheduling follow-up appointments as needed between regular visits.

HM
614 Moraine Pointe Plaza
Health Management Brokers
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA

Health Management Brokers, a Medicare insurance agent in Butler, PA, is known for assisting local seniors with their annual enrollment decisions. The company provides guidance on Medicare Advantage plans, Part D prescription drug coverage, and Medicare Supplement policies to ensure clients find appropriate options. Its services include free annual plan comparisons that help beneficiaries adjust coverage during the Open Enrollment Period. Health Management Brokers specializes in offering no-cost educational workshops to explain Medicare changes and new plan benefits.

MI
230 Mercer St
Minich Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 285-3743
minichinsurance.com
SI
1109 N Main St Ext
Siegel Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 209-1575
siegelinsurance.net
MI
400 N Main St
Mitchell Insurance, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 283-7900
since1849.com
7M
10 Pittsburgh Rd
724 Medicare
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 276-5019
724medicare.com
SI
302 N Main St
Standard Insurance Butler Ltd.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(610) 427-5162
agnesfrosch2989786.wixsite.com/standard-insurance
UU
247 S Main St
USSA - United Safety Services of America
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(857) 578-1596
facebook.com/USSAMedicare
HI
104 Alameda Plaza
Hawkins Insurance Services
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 283-4942
FI
665 Evans City Rd
Farmers Insurance - Western PA Ins Professionals LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 789-9508
agents.farmers.com/pa/butler/western-pa-ins-professionals-llc
PI
120 Point Plaza
Protec Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Butler, PA
(724) 209-8144

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Butler Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Pennsylvania do not charge you directly for their services. They receive commissions from the insurance carriers whose plans you choose. These commissions are built into the plan premiums and do not increase your costs. Typical monthly premiums for Medicare Advantage plans in Butler range from zero to over one hundred dollars depending on the plan and your coverage needs. This is general information not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Butler

Medicare insurance agents in Butler Pennsylvania help residents navigate Medicare Part A Part B Part C and Part D options. Pennsylvania law requires agents to be licensed by the state and follow strict marketing guidelines. Local agents understand Butler County healthcare providers and can explain how Pennsylvania Medicare Savings Programs may affect your choices.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a medicare insurance agent in Butler do?

A medicare insurance agent helps you compare Medicare plans like Advantage plans and prescription drug plans. They explain coverage details and assist with enrollment during your Initial Enrollment Period or Annual Election Period. Agents in Butler are familiar with local hospitals and doctors in the area.

When can I enroll in Medicare in Pennsylvania?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after your birthday month. Pennsylvania also has a Special Enrollment Period for those who delay coverage due to employer insurance. Missing these windows may result in late enrollment penalties.

Are medicare insurance agent services free in Butler?

Most medicare insurance agents are paid by insurance companies not by you. Their services are typically free to you as the consumer. Always confirm that the agent is licensed in Pennsylvania and ask about any fees before working with them.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.