ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsNew York › New Hartford

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in New Hartford, NY

Browse medicare insurance agents serving New Hartford, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in New Hartford, New York is The Frigault Agency, Inc., rated 5.0 stars across 177 reviews. Other highly rated options include Turnbull Insurance Service, Mark Kotary - State Farm Insurance Agent, McRorie-Peo Agency. This directory lists 17 medicare insurance agents serving New Hartford.

Showing 17 medicare insurance agents in New Hartford, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1The Frigault Agency, Inc.136 Clinton Rd Rt. 12B(315) 797-8080
2Turnbull Insurance Service600 French Rd(315) 735-9201
3Mark Kotary - State Farm Insurance Agent4530 Commercial Dr(315) 736-5212
4McRorie-Peo Agency48 Genesee St Floor 2(315) 316-0084
5Farmers Insurance - Tricia Darling Agency1 Ellinwood Ct(315) 736-8747
6Neil Campbell - State Farm Insurance Agent102 Genesee St(315) 797-1100
7De Angelo & Associates2 Campion Rd(315) 768-7900
8Dionisio Roman Jr.: Allstate Insurance147 Genesee St(315) 732-7290
9Bonomo Insurance Agency Inc4541 Middle Settlement Rd(315) 736-1121
10Paul Chapman Insurance Agency , Inc.1758 Burrstone Rd(315) 793-1048
FA
136 Clinton Rd Rt. 12B
The Frigault Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY

The Frigault Agency, Inc. serves the Utica-Rome metro area, including New Hartford, New York, as a local Medicare insurance agency. Its primary focus is helping individuals navigate the complexities of Medicare coverage, including Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage plans, and prescription drug plans. The agency assists clients by comparing plan options from multiple carriers to match their healthcare needs and budgets. Among its core services, the company guides clients through the annual Medicare enrollment period and handles eligibility questions for Medicare Supplement insurance plans.

TI
600 French Rd
Turnbull Insurance Service
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY

Turnbull Insurance Service, located in New Hartford, NY, provides Medicare insurance agent services, including assistance with plan selection and enrollment for eligible individuals. The firm helps clients understand their coverage options and manage annual plan updates. It offers ongoing support to ensure clients can navigate changes to their Medicare benefits. The agency services local residents living in single-family homes, apartments, and retirement communities, as well as those accessing care while residing in assisted living facilities.

MK
4530 Commercial Dr
Mark Kotary - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY

Homeowners and individuals exploring their healthcare coverage options in the New Hartford area work with Mark Kotary, a medicare insurance agent. This local office helps clients navigate the complexities of benefit plans, including original Medicare and supplemental policies. The agent assists with annual enrollment periods and plan comparisons to ensure appropriate coverage. Mark Kotary also serves customers throughout Onondaga County and the greater Syracuse metro region.

MP
48 Genesee St Floor 2
McRorie-Peo Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY

Serving the New Hartford, NY area and its surrounding communities, McRorie-Peo Agency handles Medicare insurance options for local seniors. The agency assists clients in understanding Part A, Part B, and supplement plans available in the region. Every enrollment need is addressed with a clear focus on explaining coverage details and plan differences. An agent typically begins by reviewing an individual’s current healthcare usage and budget to recommend suitable plans, then manages the full application process to ensure proper enrollment in a Medicare plan.

FI
1 Ellinwood Ct
Farmers Insurance - Tricia Darling Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY

Serving the New Hartford, NY area, a Medicare insurance agent helps clients distinguish between a single appointment to address an immediate question and an ongoing relationship for annual enrollment periods and plan updates. Coverage guidance typically includes comparing Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D drug plans to match individual health needs and budgets. At Farmers Insurance - Tricia Darling Agency, service is provided on a scheduled or as-needed basis, accommodating both one-time consultations and recurring annual reviews.

NC
102 Genesee St
Neil Campbell - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY

Neil Campbell, a medicare insurance agent in New Hartford, NY, specializes in helping clients understand and enroll in Medicare Advantage, supplement, and Part D prescription drug plans. He also provides year-round guidance on plan changes and coverage options, answering questions about how benefits apply at local pharmacies and hospitals. During the annual Open Enrollment Period from October through December, he assists clients with reviewing their current plans and switching to more suitable coverage for the coming year.

DA
2 Campion Rd
De Angelo & Associates
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY

For many in New Hartford, the annual Medicare Open Enrollment period can bring complex decisions about coverage changes. De Angelo & Associates works with eligible residents navigating these annual plan options. The company explains current Part D prescription drug plans and Medicare Advantage structures that serve the surrounding area directly. An initial consultation helps clients understand their Part A and Part B benefits thoroughly before any official plan review begins. This process starts with a straightforward checklist review of each client’s existing medical needs and provider preferences.

DR
147 Genesee St
Dionisio Roman Jr.: Allstate Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY

Dionisio Roman Jr.: Allstate Insurance provides residential medicare insurance agent services in New Hartford, New York. Commercial coverage options through the Allstate network are also available for local business clients. The office serves New Hartford and the surrounding Oneida County area. As a dedicated agent, Dionisio Roman Jr. helps clients review plan options and navigate annual enrollment periods. Clients can expect follow-up assistance or plan adjustments between regular appointments without additional hassle.

BI
4541 Middle Settlement Rd
Bonomo Insurance Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
PC
1758 Burrstone Rd
Paul Chapman Insurance Agency , Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
HI
92 Genesee St
Highstreet Insurance formerly Gates-Cole Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
(315) 732-5183
myhighstreet.com/agency-directory/new-work/new-hartford/92-genesee-street
GC
3985 Oneida St #202
Glenn Carr - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
(315) 737-7359
glenncarragent.com
UN
180 Genesee St
Utica National Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
(800) 598-8422
uticanational.com
BI
29 Winmar Crescent
Bright Insurance NY
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
(315) 216-2091
ON
95 Genesee St
OneGroup
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
(315) 457-1830
onegroup.com
RI
Valley View Rd
The Russell Insurance Agency Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
(800) 763-1406
russellinsuranceagency.com
WI
2 Campion Rd #7
World Insurance Associates LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · New Hartford, NY
(315) 725-5850
locations.worldinsurance.com/world-insurance-associates-llc-83f69e01fe4e

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in New Hartford Cost?

In New York, Medicare insurance agents generally do not charge clients directly for their services. They earn commissions from the insurance carriers. Some independent agents may charge a flat fee for plan comparisons, which can range from 50 to 200 dollars. Costs vary by case and agent. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in New Hartford

Medicare insurance agents in New Hartford, New York help residents compare Part D, Advantage, and Medigap plans. New York law requires agents to be licensed by the state and follow strict guidelines during enrollment periods. Local agents understand the specific network options available in Oneida County.

Frequently Asked Questions

When can I enroll in Medicare in New Hartford?

Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before your 65th birthday and lasts seven months. New York also has a Special Enrollment Period for those who lose other coverage. You can change plans during the Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7.

What types of Medicare plans are available in New Hartford?

New Hartford residents can choose Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage plans, and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans. Medigap supplemental plans are also available to help cover out-of-pocket costs. An agent can explain which options work with local providers.

Do I have to pay for a Medicare insurance agent in New York?

Most Medicare insurance agents are paid by insurance companies, not by you. Their services are typically free to consumers. However, some agents may charge a fee for certain consulting services, so always ask before signing any agreement.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.