ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Amherst, NY

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Amherst, New York. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Amherst, New York is Elmwood Agency, rated 5.0 stars across 395 reviews. Other highly rated options include Michele Proietti - State Farm Insurance Agent, Butterson Agency, Inc, Donald L. Houck Agency, Inc.. This directory lists 11 medicare insurance agents serving Amherst.

Showing 11 medicare insurance agents in Amherst, NYListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Elmwood Agency90 Bryant Woods S #100(716) 206-3706
2Michele Proietti - State Farm Insurance Agent3140 Sheridan Dr Ste 102(716) 838-3500
3Butterson Agency, Inc586 N French Rd # 4(716) 636-8815
4Donald L. Houck Agency, Inc.1940 Eggert Rd(716) 835-2525
5Arrow Insurance LLC3622-3636 Sheridan Dr(716) 351-4481
6Lifecare Insurance NY4330 Maple Rd(716) 217-5142
7Gimeli Hanna Insurance Agency215 Kings Hwy(716) 998-8479
8Meritain Health Inc300 Corporate Pkwy # 100S(716) 319-5500
9NAC Insurance Agency2277 Niagara Falls Blvd(716) 235-5910
10Clarity Group of NY - Amherst3140 Sheridan Dr(716) 860-3143
EA
90 Bryant Woods S #100
Elmwood Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Elmwood Agency serves the Amherst, NY area and the surrounding Erie County region as a Medicare insurance agent. The agency helps individuals navigate their Medicare options during enrollment periods and throughout the year. They assist clients in understanding the difference between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans. Elmwood Agency also provides support for selecting Medicare Part D prescription drug coverage and Medigap supplemental policies.

MP
3140 Sheridan Dr Ste 102
Michele Proietti - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Michele Proietti - State Farm Insurance Agent in Amherst, NY, provides a range of Medicare insurance options, helping clients navigate plan selections. The agency offers ongoing support for annual enrollment and policy adjustments. Services include guidance on plan changes and customer service for claims. This local agent works with individuals seeking coverage for their healthcare needs, assisting with both original Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans. The agency services single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants needing Medicare solutions for themselves or their employees.

BA
586 N French Rd # 4
Butterson Agency, Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Butterson Agency, Inc assists local homeowners and small business owners in Amherst, NY with navigating their Medicare insurance options. The company carefully explains the differences between Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and Part D prescription drug plans. Clients receive personalized guidance to help them select coverage suited to their individual healthcare needs and budget. The agency also serves residents in nearby Buffalo and throughout the surrounding Erie County metro area.

DL
1940 Eggert Rd
Donald L. Houck Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Serving Amherst, New York, and the surrounding communities in Erie County, Donald L. Houck Agency, Inc. handles Medicare insurance needs, including Medicare Supplement and Advantage plans. As a local agency, it assists clients with understanding enrollment periods and comparing plan options. The agency evaluates each individual’s healthcare and budget situation to recommend suitable coverage, then guides them through the application process to secure their policy.

AI
3622-3636 Sheridan Dr
Arrow Insurance LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Serving Amherst, NY, Arrow Insurance LLC distinguishes between one-time guidance for initial plan selection and recurring annual support during open enrollment. Their coverage guidance typically focuses on Medicare Advantage plans, prescription drug plans, and Medicare Supplement policies. By bridging the gap between federal benefits and local medical providers, this agency helps seniors navigate plan changes that affect their out-of-pocket costs. Service runs on an as-needed basis, typically triggered by client requests or the start of the Annual Enrollment Period each October.

LI
4330 Maple Rd
Lifecare Insurance NY
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Lifecare Insurance NY specializes in guiding clients through Medicare Advantage plans, prescription drug coverage, and Medicare Supplement policies for residents of Amherst, NY. It offers full-service assistance with plan comparisons, enrollment paperwork, and personalized explanations of the different parts of Medicare. The agency helps individuals nearing age sixty-five navigate their initial enrollment period and avoid late penalties. It also provides annual support during the fall Open Enrollment period, when clients may adjust their plans to changing health needs or prescription drug costs.

GH
215 Kings Hwy
Gimeli Hanna Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Gimeli Hanna Insurance Agency works with individuals and families in Amherst, NY, to navigate Medicare plan options and enrollment periods. The agency specializes in Medicare Advantage, Part D prescription drug coverage, and Medigap supplement plans. Their agents can help clients compare plans to fit their budgets and healthcare needs. They provide services to offices, warehouses, and food service operations in the surrounding region.

MH
300 Corporate Pkwy # 100S
Meritain Health Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

As open enrollment season approaches in Erie County, many seniors seek guidance through the complex Medicare landscape. Meritain Health Inc, based in Amherst, helps local residents compare Part D prescription drug plans and Medicare Advantage options. The agency assists clients in understanding how various supplemental policies coordinate with Original Medicare coverage. Through a straightforward process, the company reviews individuals' current healthcare needs and plan costs. Interested area seniors can schedule an in-person consultation at the Amherst office to begin their coverage evaluation with a complimentary initial assessment.

NI
2277 Niagara Falls Blvd
NAC Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

NAC Insurance Agency serves residents in Amherst, New York, with Medicare insurance options. Commercial coverage is also available for local businesses operating within the area. The agency helps clients navigate plan choices, including supplement and advantage policies. Personalized consultations focus on finding suitable coverage. The service area encompasses Amherst and the surrounding region in Western New York. After an initial enrollment, the agency offers follow-up assistance during the annual open enrollment period and provides ongoing support between regular visits to ensure any changes in needs are addressed.

CG
3140 Sheridan Dr
Clarity Group of NY - Amherst
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY

Clarity Group of NY - Amherst is known for guiding clients through the Medicare insurance selection process, offering plans that align with the diverse health needs and budgets of local retirees. The agency serves residents in and around Amherst, New York, helping them compare coverage options with straightforward explanations during enrollment periods. A specialty service the team provides includes annual policy reviews to adjust a client’s current plan after any personal medical changes.

MA
2001 Niagara Falls Blvd
Medicare Advantage Plans Explained.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Amherst, NY
(800) 332-7557
medicareadvantagecms.com/contact.php

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Amherst Cost?

In New York, Medicare Part A is usually premium-free if you have paid Medicare taxes for at least 10 years. Part B has a standard monthly premium of $174.70 in 2024, though higher income may increase this amount. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or $0 monthly premiums but include copays and deductibles. Medigap plans in New York can range from $100 to $400 per month depending on age and plan type. Costs vary by plan and carrier. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Amherst

Medicare insurance agents in Amherst, New York help residents navigate Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and Part D prescription drug plans. New York state law provides a guaranteed issue right for Medigap plans during the initial enrollment period and in certain other situations. Agents can explain how local providers and hospitals fit into different plan networks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the role of a Medicare insurance agent in Amherst?

A Medicare insurance agent in Amherst helps you compare and enroll in Medicare plans from multiple carriers. They do not work for the government but are licensed in New York to sell private Medicare plans. They can explain plan benefits, costs, and network rules.

When can I enroll in Medicare in New York?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after your birthday month. New York also has a yearly Open Enrollment from October 15 to December 7 for Part D and Medicare Advantage. You may also qualify for a Special Enrollment Period if you move or lose other coverage.

Are Medicare agents in Amherst free to use?

Yes, Medicare insurance agents in Amherst are typically paid by the insurance companies whose plans they sell. You do not pay a fee for their services. They can help you compare plans without charging you directly.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other New York Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.