ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Landlord Insurance Agents Near You in Lancaster, PA

Browse landlord insurance agents serving Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated landlord insurance agent in Lancaster, Pennsylvania is HomeSale Insurance Services, rated 5.0 stars across 456 reviews. Other highly rated options include Bagnall Shaw Insurance, Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance, Alicia Alexander - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 26 landlord insurance agents serving Lancaster.

Showing 26 landlord insurance agents in Lancaster, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1HomeSale Insurance Services215 S Centerville Rd Ste B(800) 425-5130
2Bagnall Shaw Insurance401 W Orange St(717) 431-8383
3Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance1729 Lititz Pike(717) 290-7290
4Alicia Alexander - State Farm Insurance Agent1265 Lititz Pike(717) 393-4777
5Susquehanna Insurance650 Delp Rd(717) 290-7780
6Red Rose Insurance100 S Queen St Ste 226(717) 690-0971
7Gebhard Insurance LLC90 Willow Valley Square(717) 930-2085
8Eagle One Insurance Agency2173 Embassy Dr—
9Element | Insurance Agency - Lancaster617B N Prince St #200(717) 397-4729
10Acceptance Insurance454 N Prince St(717) 356-3320
HI
215 S Centerville Rd Ste B
HomeSale Insurance Services
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

HomeSale Insurance Services provides landlord insurance for rental property owners throughout Lancaster County. The agency helps clients secure coverage that protects residential and commercial rental properties against common risks like fire damage, liability claims, and lost rental income. Policies are tailored to meet the specific needs of local landlords who own single-family homes, duplexes, or multi-unit apartment buildings. HomeSale Insurance Services also arranges liability protection for short-term vacation rentals and helps investors obtain coverage for newly purchased investment properties.

BS
401 W Orange St
Bagnall Shaw Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Bagnall Shaw Insurance offers a range of landlord insurance plans tailored for property owners in Lancaster, PA. It provides coverage options that protect against property damage, liability claims, and rental income loss. The company assists clients in selecting appropriate policies and can help adjust coverage as property portfolios grow. Its services include regular policy reviews to ensure adequate protection for various real estate investments. Bagnall Shaw Insurance services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

FI
1729 Lititz Pike
Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance serves property managers and landlords seeking coverage for rental properties in the Lancaster area. It offers policies designed to protect residential and commercial rental units from common risks such as property damage and liability claims. The agency works closely with landlords to explain coverage options and tailor policies to individual buildings or portfolios. As a local provider, it understands the specific insurance needs of property owners. The company also extends its services to clients in nearby Lititz.

AA
1265 Lititz Pike
Alicia Alexander - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Alicia Alexander - State Farm Insurance Agent in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding communities handles landlord insurance policies for residential and commercial property owners. The agency provides coverage options to protect rental properties from damage and liability risks. Its general approach for a typical job involves consulting with the landlord to assess specific property exposures, then tailoring a policy with appropriate deductibles and limits to match the client's investment needs.

SI
650 Delp Rd
Susquehanna Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Susquehanna Insurance in Lancaster, PA offers landlord insurance on either a one-time policy purchase or a recurring annual renewal basis. Coverage typically protects rental property structures from fire, wind, and vandalism, while also providing liability protection against tenant injuries. Separate polices may cover loss of rental income if a property becomes uninhabitable. Service is provided strictly on a scheduled annual renewal cycle for existing policies, with new coverage written only upon initial one-time application.

RR
100 S Queen St Ste 226
Red Rose Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Red Rose Insurance specializes in tailored landlord insurance policies for property owners in Lancaster, PA. It provides general agent services that match rental property coverage with local market needs, including protection for multi-unit dwellings and single-family rentals. The agency guides clients through policy selections suited to Lancaster’s historic housing stock. Its assistance proves particularly valuable during winter months, when frozen pipes and ice dam damage become common concerns for insured rental properties throughout the region.

GI
90 Willow Valley Square
Gebhard Insurance LLC
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Gebhard Insurance LLC provides landlord insurance services to property owners throughout the Lancaster, PA area. Their core work involves protecting rental properties from common liabilities, and they specialize in offering additional coverage for loss of rental income and vandalism. They structure policies to address the distinct needs of commercial tenants, ensuring comprehensive protection for offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

EO
2173 Embassy Dr
Eagle One Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
EI
617B N Prince St #200
Element | Insurance Agency - Lancaster
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

As the Lancaster area sees heavy turnover between summer leases, property owners require reliable coverage that addresses wear and tear from short-term tenants. Element | Insurance Agency - Lancaster provides tailored landlord insurance policies designed to shield investments from common rental property liabilities. Their agents understand local ordinance requirements and offer guidance on dwelling protection versus liability-only plans. Every new client relationship begins with a thorough property inspection to evaluate current risks and establish appropriate coverage limits before any policy finalization.

AI
454 N Prince St
Acceptance Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA

Acceptance Insurance in York, PA specializes in landlord insurance policies for both single-family rentals and multi-unit properties. It also provides general property coverage options to safeguard against common rental risks. Landlords benefit from protection against fire, vandalism, liability claims, and loss of rental income. The company helps property owners address the specific seasonal concern of winter damage, such as burst pipes or roof leaks from snow and ice accumulation.

HI
705 Olde Hickory Rd
Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 560-9733
hinkleinsurance.com
EI
1857 William Penn Way
EHD Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 394-5681
ehdinsurance.com
RM
2481 New Holland Pike
Rick Milanak - State Farm Insurance Agent
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 656-4371
rickmilanak.com
CA
805 Estelle Dr # 102
Cornerstone Agency Services
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 898-5982
casrisk.com
GI
1630 Manheim Pike
Goosehead Insurance - Jake Brendle
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 844-6206
goosehead.com/agents/pa/lancaster/jake-brendle
NH
120 N Pointe Blvd Suite 302
New Heritage Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 684-6409
newheritageinsurance.com
BG
2101 Oregon Pike # 300
BCF Group Inc
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 560-7730
bcfgroup.net
CI
101 Good Dr floor 2
Community Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-7531
communitysure.com
GI
2669 Lititz Pike Suite E/F
Goosehead Insurance - Mel Carwile
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 295-4537
goosehead.com/agents/pa/lancaster/mel-carwile
NW
314 Shultz Rd
North West Insurance Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 219-2601
RI
320 Granite Run Dr
Ruhl Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 665-2283
iruhl.com
MU
39 N Duke St
Murray
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 397-9600
assuredpartners.com/lancaster
CH
119 N Duke St
Countryside Home Insurance Solutions
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 963-2685
home-insurance-lancaster.com
LM
1 Howard Ave
Levin Maxwell Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 299-9411
maxwelllevininsurance.com
HI
320 Granite Run Dr Suite 201
Horst Insurance
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 560-1919
horstinsurance.com
SA
2231 Dutch Gold Dr
Spoonhour Agency
Landlord Insurance Agent · Lancaster, PA
(717) 553-0444
spoonhourinsurance.com

What Does a a Landlord Insurance Agent in Lancaster Cost?

Landlord insurance in Pennsylvania typically costs 15 to 25 percent more than standard homeowners insurance. For a single family rental in Lancaster you might pay between 800 and 1500 dollars per year. Costs depend on property value location and coverage limits. This is general information not insurance advice.

About landlord insurance agents in Lancaster

Landlord insurance agents in Lancaster Pennsylvania help property owners secure coverage for rental homes and apartments. Pennsylvania law does not require landlord insurance but mortgage lenders often mandate it. Local agents understand Lancaster County rental market conditions and can tailor policies to your property.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does landlord insurance cover in Pennsylvania?

Landlord insurance typically covers property damage liability and loss of rental income. In Pennsylvania policies often exclude flood or earthquake damage so you may need separate coverage.

Is landlord insurance required by Pennsylvania law?

Pennsylvania state law does not require landlord insurance. However your mortgage lender may require a policy with specific coverage limits. Many landlords also carry liability coverage to protect against tenant injury lawsuits.

How do I choose a landlord insurance agent in Lancaster?

Look for an agent licensed in Pennsylvania who has experience with rental properties. Ask about coverage for short term rentals if you use Airbnb or Vrbo. An agent can explain PA specific policy exclusions like ordinance or law coverage.

Landlord Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each landlord insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.