ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in Carthage, MO

Browse health insurance agents serving Carthage, Missouri. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in Carthage, Missouri is NewLife Senior Insurance, rated 5.0 stars across 119 reviews. Other highly rated options include Insurance Providers, Tony Williams - State Farm Insurance Agent, Adam Bridges - Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance. This directory lists 20 health insurance agents serving Carthage.

Showing 20 health insurance agents in Carthage, MOListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1NewLife Senior Insurance15801 Fir Rd(417) 607-6479
2Insurance Providers103 W Airport Dr(417) 358-1751
3Tony Williams - State Farm Insurance Agent2232 S Grand Ave(417) 358-9700
4Adam Bridges - Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance106 E 4th St Ste B(417) 358-7922
5Shelter Insurance - Matt Sappington420 W Fir Rd(417) 358-8164
6Kathleen Carter Agency, LLC American Family Insurance2423 Fairlawn Dr(417) 358-9715
7Jeffry Hodkin American Family Insurance800 S Garrison Ave(417) 359-3399
8Insurance Store of Carthage1524 S Garrison Ave(417) 237-0500
9FCNB Insurance2206 S Maple St E(417) 358-1543
10Jasper County Mutual Insurance505 S Main St(417) 358-2557
NS
15801 Fir Rd
NewLife Senior Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

Located in Carthage, Missouri, NewLife Senior Insurance serves the Jasper County region as a dedicated health insurance agent. The company assists seniors and other clients in navigating Medicare options, including Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans. It provides guidance on selecting prescription drug coverage and explains how different policies coordinate with existing healthcare. By comparing available plans, NewLife Senior Insurance helps individuals find coverage that matches their medical needs and budget. Its services also include enrollment assistance for Medicare Part D and annual plan reviews during open enrollment periods.

IP
103 W Airport Dr
Insurance Providers
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

Insurance Providers offers its clients a range of health insurance agent services, including policy comparisons and plan enrollment. They also assist with ongoing maintenance plans, such as annual coverage reviews and claims assistance to adjust policies as healthcare needs evolve. Located in Carthage, MO, the agency works to help individuals navigate changing regulations. It typically serves a variety of property types and business clients, including single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants needing coverage for their operations and employees.

TW
2232 S Grand Ave
Tony Williams - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

Tony Williams - State Farm Insurance Agent serves local homeowners, renters, and drivers seeking health coverage in the Carthage area. The business helps individuals compare health insurance plans that fit personal needs, including coverage for doctor visits and hospital care. It guides customers through the enrollment process and explains policy benefits clearly. Health insurance assistance is tailored to each client’s medical requirements and budget. The agency additionally serves the neighboring community of Joplin with accessible insurance options.

AB
106 E 4th St Ste B
Adam Bridges - Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

Adam Bridges - Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance serves Carthage and the surrounding communities in southwest Missouri. It handles health insurance plans for individuals and families, focusing on coverage that meets various healthcare needs. The agency works to explain available policy options, helping clients understand benefits and costs. For a typical job, it gathers personal information to compare plans suited to each client’s situation, then provides clear guidance to make an informed choice.

SI
420 W Fir Rd
Shelter Insurance - Matt Sappington
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

For those managing their health coverage needs on a short-term basis versus ongoing protection, Shelter Insurance - Matt Sappington in Carthage, MO provides local health insurance agent services. Coverage options are presented to help individuals or families select appropriate plans for medical, dental, or supplemental needs. The agent assists with understanding policy details to match personal health situations and budgets. Service arrangements are available on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis depending on the client's specific requirements for insurance guidance.

KC
2423 Fairlawn Dr
Kathleen Carter Agency, LLC American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

As a health insurance agent based in Carthage, MO, Kathleen Carter Agency, LLC American Family Insurance specializes in helping individuals and families select appropriate medical and supplemental health plans. It assists clients in understanding coverage options and navigating annual enrollment periods to find suitable protection for healthcare needs. The agency addresses the specific financial and health security concerns that arise for residents when managing chronic conditions or planning for unexpected medical events.

JH
800 S Garrison Ave
Jeffry Hodkin American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

As open enrollment approaches each year, residents of Carthage, Missouri often seek to understand recent changes in health insurance regulations and plan options. Jeffry Hodkin American Family Insurance helps individuals and families review these evolving choices to find coverage that meets their medical and financial needs. The agency focuses on explaining complex policy details clearly, ensuring clients can make informed decisions. Every initial consultation begins with a thorough inspection of the client's current healthcare usage and budget priorities before proceeding to the coverage-assessment step.

IS
1524 S Garrison Ave
Insurance Store of Carthage
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

Insurance Store of Carthage assists individuals and families with securing health coverage that meets their medical needs and financial situations. As a dedicated health insurance agent in Carthage, MO, the firm also helps clients navigate plan options, enrollments, and policy changes throughout the year. It works to match customers with suitable private plans or marketplace subsidies. The agency is available to serve professionals in local offices, warehouse operations, and food service establishments.

FI
2206 S Maple St E
FCNB Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

FCNB Insurance serves residents in Carthage, MO, offering health insurance plans tailored to individual household needs. Commercial coverage is also available for local businesses seeking employee benefit options in the Carthage area. As an agent, the company helps clients navigate plan selections, enrollment periods, and coverage changes. They handle questions between regular visits, including policy renewals or coordination with medical providers, to ensure consistent support for each policyholder.

JC
505 S Main St
Jasper County Mutual Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO

Jasper County Mutual Insurance serves as a health insurance agent in Carthage, Missouri, helping local residents navigate individual and family health plans. The company connects clients with major carriers to find coverage that fits medical needs and budgets, including options for preventive care, prescriptions, and specialist visits. They also assist with understanding plan networks and out-of-pocket costs during open enrollment. Medicare supplement and Advantage plan guidance is offered as a specialty service for qualifying clients.

MI
318 South Side Blvd
Montague Insurance & Financial LLC
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 221-3244
SR
10385 Blackberry Rd
Specialty Risk Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 359-5470
specialtyriskinsuranceagency.com
BI
303 W 3rd St
Beimdiek Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 358-4007
beimdiek.com
AF
800 S Garrison Ave
American Family Insurance - Jeff Hodkin Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 359-3399
BC
1203 S Grand Ave
BIM Consulting
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 237-0953
imwithbim.com
IB
221 W 4th St #4
Impact Benefits LLC
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 310-9290
impactbenefitsllc.com
WW
221 W 4th St #3
William Wagner Insurance Agency & Mutual of Omaha
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 358-4083
agents.mutualofomaha.com/william-wagner
SI
349 S Main St
Southwest Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 358-4041
southwestagencyins.com
HM
2443 Fairlawn Ave
HFI Medicare
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 673-0637
hfimedicare.com
GI
303 W 3rd St
Gallagher Insurance, Risk Management & Consulting
Health Insurance Agent · Carthage, MO
(417) 358-4007
assuredpartners.com/Carthage

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in Carthage Cost?

Health insurance agents in Missouri typically do not charge consumers directly. Their compensation comes from commissions paid by insurance carriers which are built into the premium. Premiums for ACA plans in Missouri vary widely based on age income and plan tier. For example a mid-level Silver plan for a 40-year-old in Carthage might range from 400 to 600 dollars per month before subsidies. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in Carthage

Health insurance agents in Carthage Missouri help individuals families and small businesses find coverage that fits their needs and budget. Missouri law requires agents to be licensed by the Missouri Department of Insurance and to follow strict disclosure rules. Local agents understand the specific provider networks available in Jasper County and can guide you through Open Enrollment or Special Enrollment periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a health insurance agent in Carthage do?

A health insurance agent in Carthage helps you compare plans from different carriers like Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas City and Cigna. They explain plan benefits deductibles and out-of-pocket costs. Agents do not charge a fee because they are paid by the insurance company.

When can I enroll in a health plan in Missouri?

Open Enrollment for ACA plans typically runs from November 1 to January 15 each year. You may qualify for a Special Enrollment Period if you have a qualifying life event such as losing other coverage moving to Carthage or getting married. Medicare enrollment has its own initial and annual periods.

Are health insurance agents in Missouri required to be licensed?

Yes all health insurance agents in Missouri must hold a valid license from the Missouri Department of Insurance. You can verify an agents license on the Missouri Department of Insurance website. Agents must also complete continuing education to stay current on state and federal regulations.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Missouri Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.