ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in St John, IN

Browse health insurance agents serving St John, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in St John, Indiana is Lighthouse Insurance Agency, rated 4.8 stars across 257 reviews. Other highly rated options include Adam Hage - State Farm Insurance Agent, Ryan Spangler - State Farm Insurance Agent, Renny Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 12 health insurance agents serving St John.

Showing 12 health insurance agents in St John, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Lighthouse Insurance Agency8213 Wicker Ave(219) 365-0066
2Adam Hage - State Farm Insurance Agent9465 Joliet St(219) 627-5145
3Ryan Spangler - State Farm Insurance Agent10210 Wicker Ave Ste 2(219) 627-3996
4Renny Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent9211 Wicker Ave(219) 365-8840
5Ante Juric & Associates LLC American Family Insurance9321 Wicker Ave Ste 203(219) 627-5900
6Eugene F. Sarkey Insurance Agency, Inc.9467 Joliet St Suite 1(219) 365-3550
7Farmers Insurance - Justin Sarkey9467 Joliet St(219) 365-1958
8Tim Van Zuidam - COUNTRY Financial Representative8626 Wicker Ave # A(219) 365-1781
9State Farm Insurance9208 Wicker Ave #19(219) 365-8840
10Lagestee Insurance Agency8229 Wicker Ave(219) 365-7706
LI
8213 Wicker Ave
Lighthouse Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Lighthouse Insurance Agency serves St John and the surrounding Lake County area as a health insurance agent. The company helps individuals and families navigate plan options, including those from the local marketplace. They explain coverage for routine care and preventive services. Guided by the needs of Northwest Indiana residents, their work focuses on matching clients with suitable policies. This agency specifically handles Open Enrollment applications and short-term health insurance plans in the region.

AH
9465 Joliet St
Adam Hage - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Adam Hage - State Farm Insurance Agent in St John, IN provides a range of health insurance options, including individual plans and family coverage. Its service approach focuses on discussing clients’ specific health needs and financial goals to tailor the right policy. The company also offers regular policy reviews to adjust coverage as life circumstances change. In addition to health insurance, the agency extends its services to servicing single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

RS
10210 Wicker Ave Ste 2
Ryan Spangler - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Ryan Spangler - State Farm Insurance Agent in St John, Indiana serves homeowners and renters in the region by offering comprehensive health insurance plans. The agency assists individuals and families with selecting suitable medical coverage tailored to diverse needs and budgets. It also provides supplemental insurance policies to help manage out-of-pocket expenses. Additionally, the office supports small business owners in finding affordable group health solutions for their employees. Beyond St John itself, Ryan Spangler’s services extend to the nearby community of Crown Point and the broader Lake County metro area.

RS
9211 Wicker Ave
Renny Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Renny Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent serves St John, Indiana, and the surrounding Lake County communities. It handles the full breadth of health insurance needs, including individual plans, family coverage, and short-term medical options. The agency works with clients to assess their specific healthcare requirements and budget constraints. It generally approaches a typical job by first reviewing a client’s current coverage and medical history. After this initial review, the agent presents tailored plan comparisons from available carriers and assists with the application process.

AJ
9321 Wicker Ave Ste 203
Ante Juric & Associates LLC American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Ante Juric & Associates LLC American Family Insurance offers both one-time consultations for immediate policy needs and ongoing service options to adjust coverage as life circumstances change. Clients in St John, IN, can access individual or family health insurance plans tailored to local medical networks and preventative care requirements. The agency provides explanations of policy terms, benefits, and enrollment procedures. Service runs on a scheduled basis throughout the year, with availability during open enrollment and special enrollment periods.

EF
9467 Joliet St Suite 1
Eugene F. Sarkey Insurance Agency, Inc.
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Eugene F. Sarkey Insurance Agency, Inc. specializes in helping individuals and families navigate health insurance agent services, including plan comparisons and enrollment assistance. It serves the St John, IN, area by guiding clients through the complexities of medical coverage options, from individual policies to family plans. The agency helps residents address specific seasonal concerns, such as evaluating new plan options and coverage changes during the annual open enrollment period.

FI
9467 Joliet St
Farmers Insurance - Justin Sarkey
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

As winter weather approaches in St John, IN, families often review their coverage needs, and Farmers Insurance - Justin Sarkey provides health insurance agent services to address those concerns. Whether clients face shifting employer benefits or want to compare individual plans, this agency evaluates available options to help local residents find suitable policies that match their medical needs and budgets. The process typically begins with a thorough consultation that reviews current coverage and explores possible adjustments, followed by a scheduled in-person or virtual assessment of each applicant’s requirements.

TV
8626 Wicker Ave # A
Tim Van Zuidam - COUNTRY Financial Representative
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Tim Van Zuidam - COUNTRY Financial Representative works as a health insurance agent serving the St John, Indiana area. This includes helping clients compare and select health plans that match their medical needs and budgets. The office can address individual coverage needs and group policy options. Commercial sectors served include local office spaces, warehouses, and food service operations seeking employee health benefits.

SF
9208 Wicker Ave #19
State Farm Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Serving residents in St John, IN, this agency provides individual health insurance plans through State Farm Insurance. Commercial health coverage for local businesses is also offered to the surrounding area. The agent helps clients compare plan options and navigate enrollment periods. Personalized service ensures policyholders understand their benefits and network details. Periodic plan reviews check for possible savings or coverage changes. The agency follows up on annual renewals and claims assistance between regular appointments.

LI
8229 Wicker Ave
Lagestee Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN

Lagestee Insurance Agency, based in St John, IN, is known for guiding individuals and families through the complexities of health insurance coverage. The agency assists clients in selecting individual plans, family policies, and group health options that meet varying medical needs and budgets. Services include explaining plan benefits, network restrictions, and out-of-pocket costs to help consumers make informed decisions. As a specialty service, Lagestee Insurance Agency can also provide supplemental coverage such as dental or vision plans to complement major medical policies.

BI
9321 Wicker Ave
Boulevard Insurance Agency
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN
(219) 365-6180
TC
9167 Wicker Ave Suite 11
Tribal-Care Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · St John, IN
(701) 446-8282

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in St John Cost?

The cost of health insurance in Indiana varies widely based on age, income, plan type, and coverage level. For an ACA silver plan, a 40-year-old in Lake County might pay between $400 and $700 per month before subsidies. Medicare Supplement plans typically range from $100 to $300 per month. Costs change each year and depend on your specific situation. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in St John

Health insurance agents in St John, Indiana help individuals and families find coverage that fits their needs and budget. Indiana follows the federal Affordable Care Act guidelines, and agents can assist with Open Enrollment periods as well as Special Enrollment qualifying events. Local agents understand the specific healthcare providers and networks available in Lake County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Open Enrollment period for health insurance in Indiana?

The Open Enrollment period for ACA plans in Indiana typically runs from November 1 to January 15 each year. Outside this window, you can only enroll if you have a qualifying life event like losing other coverage or moving. An agent can help you determine your eligibility.

Do health insurance agents in St John charge a fee for their services?

Most health insurance agents in Indiana are paid by the insurance companies, not by you directly. This means their services are usually free to consumers. Always confirm with the agent before starting the process.

What types of health insurance plans can an agent help me find in St John?

Agents in St John can help you with ACA marketplace plans, Medicare Advantage and Supplement plans, short-term medical plans, and private individual or family plans. They can compare options from multiple carriers to find a plan that fits your needs.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.