ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeHealth Insurance AgentsIndiana › New Palestine

Find Health Insurance Agents Near You in New Palestine, IN

Browse health insurance agents serving New Palestine, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated health insurance agent in New Palestine, Indiana is Brent Reece - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 77 reviews. Other highly rated options include Hatoway Insurance Partners, HRM Insurance Services, USA Benefits Group - Life Protection Plans : Jessica Stamps. This directory lists 13 health insurance agents serving New Palestine.

Showing 13 health insurance agents in New Palestine, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Brent Reece - State Farm Insurance Agent5040 W U.S. 52 Ste A(317) 861-2400
2Hatoway Insurance Partners35 W Main St(317) 861-4411
3HRM Insurance Services18 E Main St(317) 861-7524
4USA Benefits Group - Life Protection Plans : Jessica Stamps6020 W Deer Run Dr(317) 509-2132
5Steven Hall Agency - Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance4056 S Arbor Ln Suite 300(317) 861-9575
6John Lytell American Family Insurance48 W Main St(317) 861-0057
7Farmers Insurance - Jason Waugh35 E Main St(317) 861-6666
8Frank Financial Insurance group6375 W U.S. 52(317) 417-5907
9Star Shield Insurance210 US-5(317) 349-7537
10Dunaway Insurance40 E Main St(317) 861-6776
BR
5040 W U.S. 52 Ste A
Brent Reece - State Farm Insurance Agent
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

Brent Reece – State Farm Insurance Agent serves the New Palestine, Indiana area as a local health insurance agent. The company assists residents with navigating individual and family health plans to meet their medical needs. Understanding the complexities of coverage options, the agency helps clients review policy benefits and compare plan costs. They also handle the enrollment process and ongoing adjustments to existing policies. Specific services include personal health insurance consultations and Medicare supplement plan guidance.

HI
35 W Main St
Hatoway Insurance Partners
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

Serving the New Palestine, Indiana area, Hatoway Insurance Partners provides a range of health insurance options, including individual plans and family coverage. Its service model includes assisting clients with annual enrollment periods and reviewing plan options to help meet changing healthcare needs. Regular policy check-ins help ensure coverage remains suitable as medical costs and personal circumstances evolve. The company services single-family homes, apartments, retail stores, and local restaurants.

HI
18 E Main St
HRM Insurance Services
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

HRM Insurance Services provides health insurance plan shopping, enrollment assistance, and ongoing policy management for individuals and families. Its representatives help clients understand plan options, claims processes, and coverage changes throughout the year. Service includes annual plan comparisons to adjust for evolving medical needs or budget shifts. After enrollment, the company offers support for questions about benefits or network providers. It serves residential homes, apartment dwellers, retail businesses with employee health benefits, and local restaurant owners seeking group coverage.

UB
6020 W Deer Run Dr
USA Benefits Group - Life Protection Plans : Jessica Stamps
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

USA Benefits Group - Life Protection Plans, operated by Jessica Stamps, serves local homeowners and families seeking individual or group health insurance coverage. The agency assists clients in selecting medical plans that meet their daily healthcare needs and budgets. It also provides guidance through enrollment periods and plan changes. Customers from New Palestine, IN, can visit the office for personalized consultations. The agency additionally covers clients throughout the greater Indianapolis metro area, including nearby communities like Greenfield.

SH
4056 S Arbor Ln Suite 300
Steven Hall Agency - Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

Steven Hall Agency - Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance in New Palestine offers clients a choice between one-time plan purchases and ongoing coverage management that adapts to changing medical needs. As a health insurance agent, the practice helps individuals and families navigate policy options for preventive care, prescriptions, and major medical events. The agency holds in-person consultations to explain deductibles and network requirements clearly. Services run on a scheduled basis, with periodic check-ins to review plan performance and update coverage as necessary for the upcoming year.

JL
48 W Main St
John Lytell American Family Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

John Lytell American Family Insurance serves clients in New Palestine, Indiana, and the surrounding communities of Hancock County. As a health insurance agent, the company handles individual health plans, family coverage options, and small group insurance policies. The agency assists clients with navigating open enrollment periods and understanding different plan structures. When working with a customer, it begins by assessing specific healthcare needs and budget constraints, compares available carrier options, and then presents a clear recommendation that fits the client’s situation.

FI
35 E Main St
Farmers Insurance - Jason Waugh
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

As the autumn season prompts many New Palestine residents to review their coverage, Farmers Insurance - Jason Waugh assists individuals and families in navigating health insurance options. The agency helps clients compare plans and understand deductibles, networks, and out-of-pocket costs. Focusing on local needs in Indiana, the agent coordinates enrollment periods and addresses changes in personal circumstances. Each initial consultation typically involves a thorough review of current coverage to identify potential gaps or savings, preceding a scheduled assessment of the client’s specific healthcare requirements.

FF
6375 W U.S. 52
Frank Financial Insurance group
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

Frank Financial Insurance group provides comprehensive guidance on health insurance options for individuals and families in New Palestine, IN. Their specialty expands coverage to include critical illness and accident protection plans. By assessing each client’s unique healthcare needs, they help navigate the complexities of policy selection and enrollment. They serve a variety of commercial sectors, including professional offices, large warehouses, and food service operations requiring group benefits for their employees.

SS
210 US-5
Star Shield Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

Star Shield Insurance offers individual and family health plans, Medicare supplements, and small group coverage options. As a local health insurance agent in New Palestine, Indiana, it helps clients understand complex policy details and narrow their choices. The agency explains open enrollment timelines, plan tiers, and network requirements to support informed decisions. It also assists with reviewing options if a client loses employer coverage and needs to find a suitable new plan before a deadline.

DI
40 E Main St
Dunaway Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN

Dunaway Insurance in New Palestine, Indiana assists local residents with their health insurance needs, covering individual plans and family policies under guidance of this market. The agency also offers commercial coverage solutions for area small businesses and professional groups seeking employee benefits. Serving clients throughout Hancock County and surrounding central Indiana communities, the agent works to maintain current coverage for each client. Following every open enrollment period, their office provides a brief follow-up to review any plan changes and schedule the next regular check-in.

SI
53 W Main St
Smith Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN
(317) 861-6861
smithagencyins.com
NB
35 W Main St
Network Benefits Of Mid-America Inc
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN
(317) 861-3600
networkbenefits.com
SI
4544 W Rising Sun Dr
Southeastern Insurance
Health Insurance Agent · New Palestine, IN
(765) 647-3551
southeasternins.net

What Does a a Health Insurance Agent in New Palestine Cost?

The cost of health insurance plans in Indiana varies widely based on age income plan type and metal level. For 2024 ACA plans in Hancock County monthly premiums for a 40 year old can range from about 350 to 700 dollars for a Silver plan before subsidies. Short term plans may cost 100 to 300 dollars per month but offer fewer benefits. This is general information not insurance advice.

About health insurance agents in New Palestine

Health insurance agents in New Palestine Indiana help individuals families and small businesses find coverage that fits their needs and budget. Agents licensed in Indiana must follow state regulations including the Indiana Code Title 27 which governs insurance producer conduct and consumer protections. Working with a local agent gives you access to plans available through the federal marketplace as well as private options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of health insurance plans can an agent in New Palestine help me with?

Agents can assist with ACA marketplace plans Medicare Advantage and Supplement plans short term health insurance and individual or family plans. They are licensed to sell plans from multiple carriers so you can compare options.

Do I have to pay a fee to use a health insurance agent in Indiana?

No. Health insurance agents in Indiana are typically paid by the insurance company not by you. Their commission is built into the plan premium so you pay the same price whether you use an agent or apply directly.

When can I enroll in a health plan through an agent in New Palestine?

Open enrollment for ACA plans usually runs from November 1 to January 15 each year. You may qualify for a special enrollment period if you have a qualifying life event like losing other coverage moving or having a baby. Medicare enrollment periods vary by situation.

Health Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each health insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.