ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeAuto Insurance AgentsOhio › Painesville

Find Auto Insurance Agents Near You in Painesville, OH

Browse auto insurance agents serving Painesville, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated auto insurance agent in Painesville, Ohio is Kevin Kilfoyle - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 338 reviews. Other highly rated options include Cyrus Massoudi - State Farm Insurance Agent, Regency Insurance Agency, Allstate Insurance. This directory lists 18 auto insurance agents serving Painesville.

Showing 18 auto insurance agents in Painesville, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Kevin Kilfoyle - State Farm Insurance Agent1655 Mentor Ave(440) 357-5231
2Cyrus Massoudi - State Farm Insurance Agent8 N State St Ste 206(440) 357-1133
3Regency Insurance Agency1930 Mentor Ave(440) 266-8888
4Allstate Insurance1658 Mentor Ave(440) 953-0217
5Makee Insurance Agency, Inc.2190 N Ridge Rd(440) 354-4030
6Boergert Wright Insrnc Agency1 Victoria Square #130(440) 358-9001
7SeibertKeck Insurance Partners87 S St Clair St(440) 951-5875
8Huntington Insurance56 Liberty St(234) 204-4062
9Pollutro Rossley Insurance161 N State St(440) 352-2872
10Diversified Insurance Concepts10 W Erie St #202(440) 358-1221
KK
1655 Mentor Ave
Kevin Kilfoyle - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Kevin Kilfoyle - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the greater Painesville area in Lake County, Ohio, specializing in personal insurance solutions for local drivers. This agency helps customers select appropriate auto insurance policies tailored to their daily commute and vehicle protection needs. The agency also assists clients with understanding their coverage options and deductibles for both standard and comprehensive auto policies. Additionally, the team handles the processing of new policy applications and coordinates roadside assistance services for policyholders in and around Painesville.

CM
8 N State St Ste 206
Cyrus Massoudi - State Farm Insurance Agent
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Cyrus Massoudi - State Farm Insurance Agent in Painesville, Ohio, provides auto insurance policies tailored to individual coverage needs. They offer roadside assistance plans and comprehensive policy reviews to help clients understand their protection. Service appointments are available for updating coverage after life events such as a new vehicle purchase. The agency services single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

RI
1930 Mentor Ave
Regency Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Homeowners, business owners, and property managers in the Painesville area rely on Regency Insurance Agency for their auto insurance coverage. The agency works with clients to review liability limits, collision, and comprehensive policies to match individual driving needs and budgets. Agents explain coverage details clearly, helping customers understand deductibles and policy options before making a decision. Regular policy reviews are offered to ensure protection keeps pace with life changes. Regency Insurance Agency also serves drivers in the surrounding communities of Mentor and Willoughby.

AI
1658 Mentor Ave
Allstate Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Allstate Insurance serves the Painesville, Ohio, area and surrounding Lake County communities, handling a full range of auto insurance policies for local drivers. It addresses coverage needs such as liability, collision, and comprehensive protection to help clients meet state requirements and safeguard their vehicles. The agency tailors each policy to individual driving habits and vehicle types, providing clear explanations of available options. A typical job involves reviewing a customer’s current coverage, comparing it with their specific situation, and recommending adjustments that balance protection with affordability.

MI
2190 N Ridge Rd
Makee Insurance Agency, Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Makee Insurance Agency, Inc., located in Painesville, OH, distinguishes between offering individual, one-time auto policies and managing ongoing coverage with periodic renewals. Their services help area drivers select liability, collision, and comprehensive plans to meet personal needs. Regular policy adjustments can match changing vehicle values or mileage. The agency provides service on both an as-needed basis for single policy purchases and on a scheduled basis for clients who require periodic policy reviews.

BW
1 Victoria Square #130
Boergert Wright Insrnc Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Boergert Wright Insrnc Agency in Painesville, OH, specializes in offering personalized auto insurance policies that align with individual driving habits and vehicle needs. The agency provides thorough guidance through various coverage options, helping drivers understand their liability, collision, and comprehensive protections. Its general service work includes reviewing existing policies to identify potential coverage gaps or savings opportunities. As winter weather can create hazardous road conditions, the agency assists clients in confirming their policies provide adequate ice and snow damage protection before the season arrives.

SI
87 S St Clair St
SeibertKeck Insurance Partners
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

As winter approaches in Painesville, Ohio, icy roads and sudden lake-effect snow make reliable auto insurance coverage a necessity. SeibertKeck Insurance Partners provides policies that protect drivers against collision, liability, and weather-related claims common to the region. Their agents help local residents compare coverage options and adjust deductibles to match individual budgets and commuting needs. Understanding the area’s traffic patterns along State Route 2 is part of their standard risk assessment. The initial step involves either a phone consultation or an inspection of the vehicle’s current registration and VIN.

HI
56 Liberty St
Huntington Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Huntington Insurance helps drivers in Painesville secure liability and collision coverage. The agency also specializes in adding roadside assistance and rental car reimbursement to policies. It works to ensure customers meet Ohio’s minimum insurance requirements while exploring higher protection levels. The team assists both personal and commercial clients. It can serve local offices needing fleet coverage, warehouses requiring vehicle protection for deliveries, and food service businesses with vehicles used for catering or supply transport.

PR
161 N State St
Pollutro Rossley Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Drivers in Painesville, OH, often face the added cost of winter weather claims alongside the state's mandatory liability requirements. Pollutro Rossley Insurance responds by helping local vehicle owners review their current protection against common regional risks, such as collision and comprehensive coverage for road salt damage or deer accidents. An agent works directly with each driver to explain how deductibles affect monthly premiums and out-of-pocket expenses. The process begins with a simple review of the client’s current driving record and vehicle details during an initial consultation.

DI
10 W Erie St #202
Diversified Insurance Concepts
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Diversified Insurance Concepts in Painesville, OH provides auto insurance coverage for local residents and their personal vehicles. The agency also offers commercial auto policies to area businesses needing protection for fleet or company-owned automobiles. Serving Painesville and the surrounding Lake County communities, they help clients select appropriate liability, collision, and comprehensive options. Following initial policy setup, the agency encourages repeat service by contacting customers before each renewal to review changing coverage needs.

BI
11585 Olde Stone Ct
Buckman Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 201-4960
PI
7879 Auburn Rd Suite 1B
Professional Insurance Management
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 975-8800
proinsm.com
AI
10280 Pinecrest Rd
Apex Insurance Solutions Inc.
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 796-5530
apexinsurance.solutions
SS
372 Railroad St
Soto's Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 357-7686
FI
113 Main St Ste 207
Farmers Insurance - Kelley Stewart
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 354-4664
agents.farmers.com/oh/painesville/kelley-stewart
BI
180 S State St
Blakely Insurance
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 352-0725
CI
161 N State St
Callender Insurance Agency
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 354-9566
callenderins.com
AI
1656 Mentor Ave
Allstate Insurance of Lake County
Auto Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 953-0217

What Does an a Auto Insurance Agent in Painesville Cost?

The average cost of car insurance in Ohio is about 1,300 dollars per year for full coverage, but rates in Painesville can vary based on your driving record, age, and vehicle type. Minimum liability coverage may cost around 500 to 700 dollars annually for a good driver. Actual premiums depend on your specific situation. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About auto insurance agents in Painesville

Auto insurance agents in Painesville Ohio help drivers find the right coverage for their needs. Ohio law requires all drivers to carry liability insurance with minimum limits of 25,000 dollars per person for bodily injury and 25,000 dollars for property damage. A local agent can explain these requirements and help you compare policies from different companies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does an auto insurance agent in Painesville do?

An auto insurance agent helps you find and purchase a car insurance policy that meets Ohio legal requirements. They can explain different coverage types like collision and comprehensive and help you compare quotes from multiple insurers.

Is it required to have an agent to buy auto insurance in Ohio?

No, you can buy auto insurance directly from an insurance company online or by phone. However, an independent agent in Painesville can shop multiple carriers for you and provide personalized advice on coverage limits and discounts.

What information do I need to get a quote from a Painesville auto insurance agent?

You will need your drivers license number, vehicle information like make and model, and details about your driving history. The agent will also ask about your annual mileage and where you park the car overnight.

Auto Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each auto insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.