ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeUmbrella Insurance AgentsOhio › Lancaster

Find Umbrella Insurance Agents Near You in Lancaster, OH

Browse umbrella insurance agents serving Lancaster, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated umbrella insurance agent in Lancaster, Ohio is Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC, rated 4.9 stars across 88 reviews. Other highly rated options include Bill Palmer Insurance Inc, Wentz Insurance Agency Inc, Frear Insurance Services Inc. This directory lists 20 umbrella insurance agents serving Lancaster.

Showing 20 umbrella insurance agents in Lancaster, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC804 W Fair Ave(740) 653-4339
2Bill Palmer Insurance Inc725 E Main St(740) 687-5733
3Wentz Insurance Agency Inc1601 E Main St(740) 653-5535
4Frear Insurance Services Inc343 E Main St(740) 653-1236
5McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services110 N Columbus St Ste 107(740) 653-5230
6Mitchell Insurance Agency1518 E Main St(740) 687-6258
7Putnam White Lewis Insurance824 N Columbus St(740) 653-0602
8Shelter Insurance - Robert Pritchard169 W Fair Ave A(614) 527-5848
9Tom Mertz Insurance345 E Main St(740) 687-1010
10Brightway Insurance, The Kaminsky Agency1424 Ety Pointe Dr NW(740) 654-7782
MI
804 W Fair Ave
Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Miller Insurance & Financial Group, LLC serves clients throughout the Lancaster, Ohio area as an umbrella insurance agent specializing in excess liability coverage. This agency helps local homeowners and auto policyholders secure additional protection beyond standard policy limits, guarding against major claims or lawsuits. Routine services include evaluating existing coverage gaps and obtaining umbrella quotes tailored to individual asset levels. Their work also involves coordinating with primary insurers to ensure seamless policy stacking for high-value personal or rental property risks.

BP
725 E Main St
Bill Palmer Insurance Inc
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Bill Palmer Insurance Inc provides umbrella insurance coverage designed to extend liability protection beyond standard policy limits for clients in Lancaster, OH. Their service includes coordinating with existing homeowners and auto policies to offer broader financial security. They also assist with policy reviews and adjustments when coverage needs change over time. The company services various properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants.

WI
1601 E Main St
Wentz Insurance Agency Inc
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Homeowners, businesses, and property managers in Lancaster, OH turn to Wentz Insurance Agency Inc for umbrella insurance policies that provide extra liability protection beyond standard coverage limits. This local agency helps clients safeguard their assets from major claims and lawsuits by offering a broad layer of security. They serve the Lancaster area as well as nearby communities throughout Fairfield County, ensuring that residents and commercial operators in the region have access to essential excess liability solutions.

FI
343 E Main St
Frear Insurance Services Inc
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Frear Insurance Services Inc serves Lancaster, Ohio, and the surrounding Fairfield County communities, handling umbrella liability insurance coverage needs for local residents and businesses. This type of policy extends additional protection beyond standard homeowners or auto policies to address larger claims. The agency approaches each client by first reviewing their current underlying coverage limits, then carefully explaining how added protection can help safeguard savings and future earnings. For a typical job, it assesses an individual’s total asset exposure before recommending an appropriate policy amount and assisting with the application process.

MI
110 N Columbus St Ste 107
McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services provides umbrella insurance for residential clients in Lancaster, offering additional liability protection beyond standard homeowners or auto policies. The agency also serves local commercial businesses, structuring broader coverage for landlords and small enterprises throughout the surrounding area. Their approach begins with a thorough review of each client\'s existing policies to identify gaps in personal or business liability. After an initial consultation, the company follows up to ensure coverage remains adequate, assisting with policy adjustments between regular visits.

MI
1518 E Main St
Mitchell Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Mitchell Insurance Agency in Lancaster, OH addresses the difference between one-time policies focused on a single claim or short interval and recurring service plans that continuously update coverage as personal assets change. Their umbrella insurance provides extra liability protection beyond standard homeowners or auto policies, safeguarding clients from major financial losses. Service runs on a one-time, scheduled, or as-needed basis depending on whether a client requires a standalone policy review, periodic adjustments for life changes, or immediate consultation after an incident.

PW
824 N Columbus St
Putnam White Lewis Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Putnam White Lewis Insurance serves Lancaster and all of Fairfield County as a provider of umbrella insurance solutions. The agency assists clients in securing personal liability coverage that extends beyond standard homeowners or auto policies. This policy offers an additional layer of financial protection against major claims or lawsuits. Professional guidance is offered to assess an individual’s unique risk profile. The company handles both personal umbrella liability policies and the review of underlying coverage requirements.

SI
169 W Fair Ave A
Shelter Insurance - Robert Pritchard
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

When winter ice storms threaten Lancaster roads, excess liability coverage becomes a practical consideration for homeowners and drivers. Shelter Insurance - Robert Pritchard assists clients in this area by evaluating personal exposure risks and explaining how an umbrella policy can extend beyond standard auto and home limits. The agent works to clarify coverage gaps that might leave savings or future earnings vulnerable to a major claim. A comprehensive risk review is recommended, often beginning with a no-obligation consultation and a detailed inspection of current policies to identify potential shortfalls.

TM
345 E Main St
Tom Mertz Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Tom Mertz Insurance in Lancaster, OH specializes in providing umbrella insurance policies that offer additional liability coverage beyond standard homeowners and auto policies. It helps clients protect their personal assets and future income from major claims or lawsuits. The agency works closely with individuals to assess their overall risk exposure and identify appropriate coverage limits. It is particularly useful in helping homeowners prepare for seasonal risks such as increased visitors during summer months or holiday gatherings when accident liability rises.

BI
1424 Ety Pointe Dr NW
Brightway Insurance, The Kaminsky Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
OI
110 E Main St
Otto Insurance Group
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-4004
otto-ins.com/locations/lancaster-oh
CI
414 E Main St # 100
Clark Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-8623
clarkins.com
SI
169 W Fair Ave B
Shelter Insurance - Jessica Wilkins
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 785-5025
shelterinsurance.com/CA/agent/JWILKINS
GI
711 W Fair Ave
Gibson Insurance Agency
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-7111
garygibsoninsurance.com
GI
503 Tarkiln Rd SE
Great Insurance Lancaster
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 309-1108
EI
402 S Broad St
Easy Insurance Co
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 309-3203
WI
400 N Memorial Dr
Wichert Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 654-0532
wichert.com
DJ
402 E Main St
Derflinger Jones Insurance
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 687-5808
derflingerjonesins.com
MI
802 W Fair Ave
Miller Insurance & Financial: Heston Rita
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-4339
millerinsuranceandfinancialgroup.com/about-our-agency/meet-our-team
HI
2700 Kull Rd
Hammer Insurance LLC
Umbrella Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 785-9489
hammer-insurance.com

What Does an a Umbrella Insurance Agent in Lancaster Cost?

In Ohio, the cost of an umbrella insurance policy typically ranges from 150 to 400 dollars per year for one million dollars in coverage. Higher limits, such as two million or five million dollars, cost more but still remain affordable compared to the protection they provide. Your actual premium depends on your risk factors, including the number of vehicles, properties, and your claims history. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About umbrella insurance agents in Lancaster

Umbrella insurance agents in Lancaster, Ohio help you secure additional liability coverage that goes beyond the limits of your auto or homeowners policy. This extra layer of protection is important for Ohio residents who face lawsuits or claims that exceed standard policy limits. Ohio law does not require umbrella insurance, but it can safeguard your savings and future earnings from large judgments.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does an umbrella insurance agent in Lancaster do?

An umbrella insurance agent helps you evaluate your personal liability risks and find a policy that provides extra coverage above your existing home and auto insurance. They explain how umbrella insurance works with your current policies and help you choose appropriate coverage limits based on your assets.

How much umbrella insurance do I need in Ohio?

Most Ohio agents recommend at least one million dollars in umbrella coverage, but the right amount depends on your personal assets, income, and potential liability risks. Factors include your home value, savings, and whether you own rental property or have a swimming pool. An agent can help calculate a suitable limit for your situation.

Does Ohio law affect umbrella insurance requirements?

Ohio does not mandate umbrella insurance, but it can protect you from lawsuits that exceed your primary policy limits. Ohio follows a comparative negligence rule, meaning you could be held partially liable for an accident. Umbrella coverage helps pay for legal defense and settlements if you are sued.

Umbrella Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each umbrella insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.