ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Sun Prairie, WI

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin is First Choice Insurance Solutions (FCIS) a Vizance Company, rated 5.0 stars across 633 reviews. Other highly rated options include Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent, Mallory Rodriguez - State Farm Insurance Agent, Homewood Insurance Agency. This directory lists 18 supplemental insurance agents serving Sun Prairie.

Showing 18 supplemental insurance agents in Sun Prairie, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1First Choice Insurance Solutions (FCIS) a Vizance Company1261 W Main St #101(608) 318-1200
2Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent233 E Main St(608) 834-0483
3Mallory Rodriguez - State Farm Insurance Agent2824 Prairie Lakes Dr UNIT 203(608) 837-3783
4Homewood Insurance Agency1262 W Main St(608) 837-3611
5Austin Weaver - COUNTRY Financial Agent1777 W Main St Ste 112(608) 277-5546
6Monica Titley: Allstate Insurance1015 W Main St(608) 271-9900
7Geoff Wilkins - State Farm Insurance Agent1210 Emerald Terrace(608) 837-2502
8Rusch Insurance703 Commercial Ave suite C(608) 724-1924
9Rural Mutual Insurance: Hudson Agency & Associates2273 McCoy Rd(608) 295-7582
10Amy Thompson American Family Insurance695 S Grand Ave UNIT 204(608) 837-6607
FC
1261 W Main St #101
First Choice Insurance Solutions (FCIS) a Vizance Company
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

First Choice Insurance Solutions (FCIS) a Vizance Company serves the Sun Prairie, Wisconsin metro area as a supplemental insurance agent. The firm helps clients bridge gaps in primary health coverage by offering policies for medical out-of-pocket costs and unexpected accident expenses. These plans can provide financial support during illness or injury. The company specializes in hospital indemnity coverage and critical illness insurance policies to address specific protection needs.

AE
233 E Main St
Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Andy Eyers - State Farm Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie, WI offers supplemental insurance coverage designed to fill gaps left by major medical plans. These policies help manage out-of-pocket costs like deductibles, copays, and non-medical expenses such as accident recovery or hospital stays. The agency provides tailored policy evaluations and ongoing support to adjust coverage as client needs change. Andy Eyers serves a diverse range of properties including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants in the local area.

MR
2824 Prairie Lakes Dr UNIT 203
Mallory Rodriguez - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Serving Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, and the surrounding communities, Mallory Rodriguez - State Farm Insurance Agent handles supplemental insurance coverage designed to fill gaps left by primary health plans. This type of insurance can help clients manage costs from accidents, critical illnesses, or hospital stays. The agent typically begins by reviewing a client’s existing benefits to identify coverage shortfalls, then recommends appropriate supplemental options to address those specific needs through a straightforward, consultative process.

HI
1262 W Main St
Homewood Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Homeowners and business owners in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, turn to Homewood Insurance Agency for supplemental insurance coverage that fills gaps left by standard policies. These plans help with expenses like deductibles or lost income during recovery from an illness or accident. The agency provides guidance in selecting appropriate plans from well-known insurance carriers serving the region. Its services also extend to nearby communities within the Madison metropolitan area, including the town of DeForest.

AW
1777 W Main St Ste 112
Austin Weaver - COUNTRY Financial Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Austin Weaver, a COUNTRY Financial agent in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, offers both one-time policy reviews and recurring service check-ins for supplemental insurance. This approach ensures clients understand their coverage options, such as accident or critical illness plans, without overcommitting to unnecessary products. Policies are designed to fill gaps left by primary health insurance, providing financial protection during unexpected events. Service operates on an as-needed basis, with scheduled annual reviews available to adjust coverage as life circumstances change.

MT
1015 W Main St
Monica Titley: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

As a supplemental insurance agent, Monica Titley of Allstate Insurance in Sun Prairie, WI provides specialty gap coverage for accidents and hospital stays. The agency assists clients by explaining how these policies help pay out-of-pocket costs unreimbursed by major medical plans. It works with individuals and families to tailor a plan that addresses their specific needs or budget concerns. This focused guidance can be especially valuable during the open enrollment season for Medicare beneficiaries when coverage gaps often become more pressing.

GW
1210 Emerald Terrace
Geoff Wilkins - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

As cold and flu season taxes household budgets in Sun Prairie, WI, even minor health issues can create unexpected financial strain for local families. Geoff Wilkins - State Farm Insurance Agent provides supplemental insurance policies designed to cover deductibles, copays, and lost income that major medical plans often leave behind. Residents exploring these options can meet with the agent to discuss gap coverage or accident and hospital indemnity plans. The initial step typically involves a complimentary policy review and a personalized needs assessment to determine the most suitable coverage.

RI
703 Commercial Ave suite C
Rusch Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Rusch Insurance helps individuals and businesses address gaps in their standard health coverage by offering supplemental insurance plans in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. These policies provide additional financial support for services like accident recovery, critical illness diagnosis, or unexpected hospital stays. The agency focuses on clarifying policy options so clients can choose tailored add-ons that fit their specific needs. It serves a variety of commercial sectors, including professional offices, large warehouses, and food service establishments.

RM
2273 McCoy Rd
Rural Mutual Insurance: Hudson Agency & Associates
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Rural Mutual Insurance: Hudson Agency & Associates in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, is known for providing supplemental insurance coverage that helps individuals fill gaps left by standard health plans. Its service range includes policies for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity needs. The agency assists local residents in securing additional financial protection during unexpected medical events. Working throughout the Sun Prairie area, the agency can add cancer insurance as a focused specialty add-on to existing supplemental policies.

AT
695 S Grand Ave UNIT 204
Amy Thompson American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI

Amy Thompson American Family Insurance serves residential clients in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin, helping them select supplemental insurance coverage to address gaps in their primary health or life policies. The agency also offers commercial coverage options for small businesses in the local area. As a supplemental insurance agent, the office explains policy details and facilitates claims for serious illness, accident, or hospital indemnity plans. Clients are encouraged to schedule follow-up visits during open enrollment periods to adjust their protection as their needs change.

TR
1777 W Main St Ste 112
Tyler Riekena - COUNTRY Financial Representative
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 834-2060
advisors.countryfinancial.com/usa/wi/sun-prairie/tyler-riekena
TI
804 Liberty Blvd #203
TRICOR Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 837-2484
tricorinsurance.com/sun-prairie-insurance-office
LC
600 W Main St C
Larry Cutler American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 837-3307
amfam.com/agents/wisconsin/sun-prairie/larry-cutler
SO
100 Wilburn Rd Suite 103
Susan Olson Insurance & Financial Solutions
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 825-7882
talentcpa.com
RM
425 W Main St #104
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Mitch Deprey
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 318-5801
ruralmutual.com/agent/mitch-deprey-sun-prairie
TI
110 N Grand Ave Ste 216
Talent Insurance & Financial Solutions
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 825-7882
SA
5 N Bird St
Suchomel & Associates, LLC American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 478-3850
amfam.com/agents/wisconsin/sun-prairie/jamie-suchomel
AI
1261 W Main St
Adept Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Sun Prairie, WI
(608) 345-7109
adeptinsurancegroup.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Sun Prairie Cost?

Supplemental insurance agent services in Sun Prairie are typically free to you because agents earn commissions from insurance companies. Medigap plan premiums in Wisconsin vary by age, gender, and location, with monthly costs ranging from about $50 to $300 for a standard plan. Medicare Advantage plans may have $0 premiums but include copays and deductibles. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Sun Prairie

Supplemental insurance agents in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin help residents find policies that cover costs not paid by original Medicare. Wisconsin law requires Medigap policies to offer guaranteed issue rights in certain situations, such as when you lose employer coverage. Local agents can explain how Wisconsin state regulations affect your plan choices and enrollment periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Sun Prairie?

A supplemental insurance agent is a licensed professional who helps you buy Medigap or Medicare Advantage plans. They guide you through options that pay for deductibles, copays, and other out-of-pocket costs not covered by Original Medicare.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Wisconsin?

You have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time, insurers cannot deny you coverage or charge higher premiums due to health conditions. Wisconsin also has special enrollment rights for other qualifying events.

Are there Wisconsin-specific rules for Medigap plans?

Yes, Wisconsin requires Medigap policies to include a free look period of 30 days. You can cancel a policy within that time for a full refund. Wisconsin also has a standard Medigap plan called Basic that all insurers must offer, plus additional plan options.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.