ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Neenah, WI

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Neenah, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Neenah, Wisconsin is Dave Mader - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 564 reviews. Other highly rated options include Hartman & Associates LLC American Family Insurance, Josh Carter - State Farm Insurance Agent, Ben Mayer - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 15 supplemental insurance agents serving Neenah.

Showing 15 supplemental insurance agents in Neenah, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Dave Mader - State Farm Insurance Agent1065 S Lake St(920) 722-6021
2Hartman & Associates LLC American Family Insurance996 S Green Bay Rd(920) 725-3951
3Josh Carter - State Farm Insurance Agent1108 Breezewood Ln(920) 722-4277
4Ben Mayer - State Farm Insurance Agent1395 W American Dr E(920) 722-4457
5SECURA Insurance Co.1500 Mutual Way(800) 558-3405
6Sean the Health Insurance Guy1760 American Dr(920) 215-1150
7Eric Soda Agency LLC American Family Insurance1220 S Commercial St(920) 725-2110
8Sturtevant & Associates, LLC500 N Commercial St Suite A(920) 969-1956
9Alliance Insurance Centers1977 American Dr #200(920) 886-3510
10Elite Insurance Agency1580 Lyon Dr(414) 206-3018
DM
1065 S Lake St
Dave Mader - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Dave Mader - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Neenah, Wisconsin area as a local supplemental insurance agent. The company focuses on helping residents manage out-of-pocket costs that primary health plans do not fully cover, such as deductibles and copayments. Supplemental policies can provide financial protection during unexpected medical events. Clients often seek assistance with enrolling in coverage for accidents or critical illnesses, ensuring they have additional support when facing significant health expenses. The agency handles both accident insurance and hospital indemnity plans in this region.

HA
996 S Green Bay Rd
Hartman & Associates LLC American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Hartman & Associates LLC American Family Insurance serves homeowners, businesses, and property managers in Neenah, Wisconsin, by offering supplemental insurance coverage. These policies help fill gaps left by standard plans, such as accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity protection. The agency provides personalized guidance to local clients throughout the policy selection and claims process. Its service area also extends into the greater Appleton metropolitan region, including nearby communities like Menasha.

JC
1108 Breezewood Ln
Josh Carter - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Serving Neenah, Wisconsin, and the surrounding Fox Valley communities, Josh Carter - State Farm Insurance Agent handles supplemental insurance coverage designed to fill gaps left by primary health plans. This agency works with clients to secure policies for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity needs. To understand each client’s existing coverage, the agent reviews current benefits and medical cost exposures during a personal consultation. By comparing available plan options side by side, the agent selects cost-effective supplemental protection tailored to the individual’s specific health risks and budget.

BM
1395 W American Dr E
Ben Mayer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Ben Mayer - State Farm Insurance Agent in Neenah, WI, provides supplemental insurance coverage that goes beyond primary plans to help fill gaps in out‑of‑pocket expenses. The office offers both one‑time policies for specific needs and recurring coverage for ongoing financial protection. Agent services provide local guidance on available plans during policy selection and claims assistance. These professional services are available on an as‑needed basis, whether for an initial consultation or when a claim arises.

SI
1500 Mutual Way
SECURA Insurance Co.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

SECURA Insurance Co. in Neenah, WI provides a complete range of supplemental insurance products to help fill gaps in primary health coverage. It offers service plans that are designed to assist clients with managing out-of-pocket expenses and coordinating benefits during claims processing. Its straightforward maintenance approach focuses on policy renewals and routine updates to ensure continuous coverage. The company services a variety of properties, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

SH
1760 American Dr
Sean the Health Insurance Guy
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Sean the Health Insurance Guy in Neenah, Wisconsin, specializes in supplemental insurance policies that fill coverage gaps left by major medical plans. The agency helps clients evaluate their existing health coverage and recommend appropriate additional policies to manage out-of-pocket expenses. It assists individuals and families in the surrounding area with navigating the complexities of secondary insurance options. During the annual Medicare open enrollment period, the agency focuses on guiding older adults through their supplemental plan choices to avoid costly late enrollment penalties.

ES
1220 S Commercial St
Eric Soda Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

As winter snow and ice blanket the Fox Valley, homeowners often face unexpected property damage that their primary health plan may not fully cover. Eric Soda Agency LLC American Family Insurance in Neenah assists residents by offering supplemental insurance options tailored to fill these common coverage gaps. Clients can discuss specific risks related to seasonal weather or medical expenses during a free initial assessment that examines individual needs and policy limitations.

SA
500 N Commercial St Suite A
Sturtevant & Associates, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Sturtevant & Associates, LLC works to help individuals manage gaps in their primary health coverage through supplemental insurance. The agency focuses specifically on offering add-on policies that provide extra financial protection for unexpected medical events. These plans can help cover out-of-pocket expenses, such as deductibles and copayments, that typical major medical insurance does not include. In the Neenah, Wisconsin area, the agency serves a variety of commercial sectors, including offices, warehouses, and food service businesses.

AI
1977 American Dr #200
Alliance Insurance Centers
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Alliance Insurance Centers serves residents throughout the Neenah area, helping individuals navigate the complexities of supplemental insurance coverage. The agency extends its services to local businesses, ensuring that commercial clients can access comparable protections for their workforce. By focusing on tailored benefit options, the company addresses gaps in primary health plans for clients in Neenah and the surrounding Wisconsin communities. A dedicated follow-up process ensures that policyholders can revisit their coverage for adjustments or questions between regularly scheduled service visits.

EI
1580 Lyon Dr
Elite Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI

Elite Insurance Agency is a supplemental insurance agent in Neenah, Wisconsin, known for helping individuals fill gaps in their primary health coverage. The agency serves local residents by offering plans that address out-of-pocket expenses not covered by major medical policies. These supplemental products include options for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans tailored to individual needs. Agents work closely with clients to explain coverage differences and find suitable financial protection. A specialty add-on service includes dental or vision insurance for those seeking further preventive care benefits.

LI
Marketplace Building, 124 W Wisconsin Ave #230
Lighthouse Insurance Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(920) 722-7210
golighthouseins.com
FI
1370 S Commercial St
Farmers Insurance - Diane Masey
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(920) 729-9001
agents.farmers.com/wi/neenah/diane-masey
RI
55 Jewelers Park Dr Suite 105
R&R Insurance Services, Inc. - Neenah
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(920) 955-1040
myknowledgebroker.com
JI
24 Jewelers Park Dr
Jm Insurance Services LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(800) 339-9124
jmiservices.com
SS
931 Caroline St
Scott Stueck - Aflac Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Neenah, WI
(920) 540-0554

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Neenah Cost?

Supplemental insurance agent services in Wisconsin are typically free to consumers because agents earn commissions from insurance carriers. Medigap plan premiums in Wisconsin can range from about $100 to $300 per month depending on age, gender, and tobacco use. Costs vary by case and plan type. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Neenah

Supplemental insurance agents in Neenah, Wisconsin help residents choose Medigap or Medicare Advantage plans to cover costs not paid by Original Medicare. Wisconsin state law provides special enrollment periods and consumer protections under Chapter 632 of the Wisconsin Statutes. Local agents can explain how these rules apply to your situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Neenah?

A supplemental insurance agent in Neenah helps you compare and enroll in Medicare Supplement plans or Medicare Advantage plans. They are licensed by the State of Wisconsin and must follow Wisconsin insurance regulations.

When can I enroll in a supplemental plan in Wisconsin?

You have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting when you are both 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. Wisconsin also offers a birthday rule that allows you to switch Medigap plans within 60 days of your birthday without medical underwriting.

Does Wisconsin require guaranteed issue for Medigap?

Yes, Wisconsin law provides guaranteed issue rights for Medigap in certain situations, such as losing employer coverage or moving out of a plan service area. This means you cannot be denied a policy due to health conditions during those times.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.