ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Erie, PA

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Erie, Pennsylvania. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Erie, Pennsylvania is Cronk Insurance Inc., rated 5.0 stars across 433 reviews. Other highly rated options include Mike Samueloff - State Farm Insurance Agent, Todd M. Powers - State Farm Insurance Agent, Brandon Fresch - State Farm Insurance Agent. This directory lists 37 supplemental insurance agents serving Erie.

Showing 37 supplemental insurance agents in Erie, PAListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Cronk Insurance Inc.3838 W 12th St(814) 456-7501
2Mike Samueloff - State Farm Insurance Agent5320 Buffalo Rd Unit B(814) 806-3466
3Todd M. Powers - State Farm Insurance Agent4532 Peach St(814) 868-4839
4Brandon Fresch - State Farm Insurance Agent864 Silliman Ave(814) 899-1112
5Erie Insurance: Corporate Headquarters100 Erie Insurance Pl(814) 870-2000
6Sitter Insurance, LLC4267 W Ridge Rd(814) 835-3889
7Historic Square Agency LLC3731 W 26th St(814) 835-3743
8Bort Insurance Services1460 W 38th St(814) 868-3400
9Northshore Insurance Agency, LLC2340 W Grandview Blvd #3(814) 838-8310
10Bankers Life3939 W Ridge Rd Ste B8 # B7(814) 833-8300
CI
3838 W 12th St
Cronk Insurance Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Cronk Insurance Inc. provides supplemental insurance agent services in Erie, PA, offering plans that help cover gaps left by major medical policies. These supplemental plans may include options for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity coverage. The company assists clients in understanding their benefits and ensuring their needs remain met. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail locations, and restaurants in the Erie area.

MS
5320 Buffalo Rd Unit B
Mike Samueloff - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Serving the Erie, Pennsylvania area and surrounding communities, this agency provides supplemental insurance policies designed to fill coverage gaps left by major medical plans. The agent assists clients in securing various supplemental products that can help manage out-of-pocket expenses and provide financial support during specific health events. For a typical case, the agency begins with a personalized consultation to understand the client’s existing coverage and needs, then carefully matches those needs with appropriate policy benefits and options.

TM
4532 Peach St
Todd M. Powers - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Homeowners and small business owners in the Erie area rely on Todd M. Powers - State Farm Insurance Agent for supplemental insurance coverage. These policies provide financial protection for gaps left by standard medical and property plans, offering peace of mind during unexpected events like illness or accident. The office works directly with clients to customize affordable plans that fit individual budgets and coverage needs. It also extends its supplemental insurance services to the neighboring communities in Millcreek and Edinboro.

BF
864 Silliman Ave
Brandon Fresch - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

As a supplemental insurance agent in Erie, PA, Brandon Fresch – State Farm Insurance Agent offers coverage that can provide one-time benefits for specific events or recurring monthly payments for ongoing needs. These plans typically help fill gaps left by major medical policies, addressing expenses such as deductibles or lost income. Services run on a completely as-needed basis, with no scheduled appointment required unless the client requests a routine policy review.

EI
100 Erie Insurance Pl
Erie Insurance: Corporate Headquarters
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Erie Insurance, serving the Erie, Pennsylvania metro area, provides supplemental insurance agent services to local residents. These policies fill coverage gaps left by major medical plans, offering financial protection for unexpected health events. The company facilitates access to cash benefits for hospital stays or critical illness diagnoses, helping clients manage out-of-pocket costs. Supplemental insurance agents in this region also assist with accident insurance plans, which pay fixed sums for specific injuries. These services help individuals secure additional peace of mind beyond traditional health coverage.

SI
4267 W Ridge Rd
Sitter Insurance, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Sitter Insurance, LLC specializes in supplemental insurance policies that fill coverage gaps left by standard health plans, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. The agency serves individuals and families in Erie, Pennsylvania, helping them navigate these supplementary options to reduce out-of-pocket expenses associated with medical treatments and unexpected health events. Sitter Insurance also regularly assists clients with planning for seasonal needs, such as reviewing coverage before winter months increase risks of slips and flu-related hospital visits.

HS
3731 W 26th St
Historic Square Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

As the seasons shift in Erie, PA, residents often review their current coverage for gaps that Medicare or a primary health plan may leave. Historic Square Agency LLC works as a supplemental insurance agent, helping clients understand policies designed to cover those out-of-pocket costs. They assist individuals in comparing limited-benefit plans that address specific local healthcare needs. An initial assessment is always conducted to review the person’s existing coverage and identify areas where extra protection might be appropriate.

BI
1460 W 38th St
Bort Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Bort Insurance Services in Erie, Pennsylvania, assists clients with their primary insurance needs and specializes in supplemental coverage policies. These additional plans help fill gaps in standard health insurance, offering financial protection for unexpected medical or accident-related expenses. Their services support individuals managing out-of-pocket costs from copays, deductibles, or hospital stays. Bort Insurance Services works with a variety of commercial sectors to provide these supplemental options, including small offices, warehouses, and food service businesses.

NI
2340 W Grandview Blvd #3
Northshore Insurance Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Northshore Insurance Agency, LLC is known for helping Erie, PA residents secure supplemental coverage that fills gaps left by primary medical plans. Its service range includes policies designed to cover out-of-pocket costs, such as deductibles and copayments, for various health events. The agency also offers insurance that provides cash benefits for critical illnesses and accident-related expenses. For added protection, it presents a specialty option like hospital indemnity plans, which pay a fixed amount directly to the policyholder per day of inpatient care.

BL
3939 W Ridge Rd Ste B8 # B7
Bankers Life
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA

Bankers Life serves residential clients in Erie, Pennsylvania, with supplemental insurance policies designed to bridge gaps in primary health coverage. The agency also provides commercial coverage options for local businesses seeking additional financial protection for their employees. Their service area encompasses the greater Erie region and surrounding communities. Clients can expect follow-up consultations after policies are issued, ensuring coverage remains aligned with changing needs between regular annual reviews or life event updates.

GL
1128 State St
Great Lakes Insurance Services Group LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 456-0498
greatlakesins.com
HP
332 Holland St
Hilling-Pfeffer Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 870-3109
hilling-pfefferinsurance.com
LS
3537 W 12th St
Loesel-Schaaf Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 833-5433
lsinsure.com
LE
1001 State St
Level Of Effort - Insurance Broker of Erie
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 580-5998
loeinsurance.us
HM
2562 W 12th St
Hart McConahy & Martz Insurance Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 455-0987
hmm-ins.com
BS
3200 W 32nd St
Byham's Insurance Services, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 520-6609
byhamins.com
RC
712 Maryland Ave
R. C. Chase Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 452-2723
chaseinsurance.com
LI
3715 Zimmerman Rd
Lighthouse Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 453-4721
weinsureerie.com
LI
4620 Buffalo Rd
Laskowski Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 897-8467
laskins.com
AI
1001 State St Suite 1317
Akin Insurance Consulting
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 449-5189
yourerieconsultant.com
SM
2616 W 8th St
Siegel Medicare & Health Insurance Advisors
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 790-4015
siegelmedicarehealth.com
RH
2900 Copperleaf Dr STE. 100
R. H. Rutkowski Insurance Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 870-3131
rhrins.com
BI
4603 Wattsburg Rd
Burick Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 825-3660
jessicaburickinsurance.com
VI
1652 W 8th St
Vicary Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 459-3407
vicary.com
AP
1311 W 26th St
Asset Protection LTD
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 860-3101
assetprotectionltd.com
CM
8270 Peach St Suite 200
Cheryl Mitchell Insurance Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 651-0711
cherylmitchellinsurance.com
DK
1730 W 26th St
Drushel & Kolakowski Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 455-8434
dk4ins.com
GL
2404 E Lake Rd
Great Lakes Insurance Services Group LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 459-4380
greatlakesins.com
BI
3915 Caughey Rd #3
Bock Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 835-3397
bockinsurance.com
BB
1032 W 38th St
Bayfront Benefit Solutions Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 240-6227
bayfrontbenefitsolutions.com
DI
3209 Greengarden Blvd
Domino Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 868-4851
domino-insurance.com
HD
5753 Peach St
Highmark Direct Health Insurance Store
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 528-9600
highmarkdirect.com
HI
1105 W 12th St
The Health Insurance Store
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 920-5275
getyourbestplan.com
BI
3731 W 26th St
Borowy Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 835-3743
historicsquare.com
UH
654 Millcreek Plaza Erie #9004k
UPMC Health Plan Connect Center
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 897-3408
upmchealthplan.com
GI
4535 Buffalo Rd
Greenwood Insurance of Erie
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 899-2133
greenwoodinsurancepa.com
HH
4509 W 26th St
Heidi Hilton Insurance Agency, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Erie, PA
(814) 464-4762
heidihiltonins.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Erie Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Erie Pennsylvania vary by plan type age and health status. Medigap Plan G premiums typically range from 100 to 250 dollars per month for a 65-year-old. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums but include copays and deductibles. Costs can change each year and depend on the carrier. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Erie

Supplemental insurance agents in Erie Pennsylvania help residents find policies that cover costs not paid by original Medicare or employer plans. Pennsylvania law requires agents to be licensed by the state and follow strict rules about plan comparisons and disclosures. Local agents understand the specific needs of Erie County residents including access to UPMC Hamot and Saint Vincent Hospital networks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Erie?

A supplemental insurance agent in Erie is a licensed professional who helps you buy Medigap Medicare Advantage or other private health plans. They compare policies from different carriers to find coverage that fits your budget and medical needs.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Pennsylvania?

You have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are both 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time you can buy any Medigap policy without medical underwriting. Outside this window you may face health questions or higher premiums.

Are there special rules for supplemental insurance in Pennsylvania?

Yes Pennsylvania has a guaranteed issue law that gives you additional rights to buy a Medigap policy in certain situations like losing employer coverage. The state also requires agents to provide a standardized outline of coverage so you can compare plans easily.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Pennsylvania Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.