Skip to main content

Compare Supplemental Insurance Agents in Shirley, NY

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Shirley, New York. Contact information and addresses listed below.

8 agents listed
Updated May 2026
Shirley, NY
Important: Listings are compiled from publicly available sources and have not been independently verified by BeforeInsuranceUSA.com. We do not endorse any agent or guarantee outcomes. Verify licensing and disciplinary status with the Department of Insurance of New York before hiring.
Showing 8 supplemental insurance agents in Shirley, NY Listings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked by BeforeInsuranceUSA. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement of any agent.
Island Wide Insurance Agency (formerly Stop Agency, Inc.)
878 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967
(631) 395-1000 islandwideins.com
Lighthouse Insurance Shirley
960-B Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967
(631) 399-0300 lighthouseinsurance.com
Marlin Insurance Agency Inc
1138 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley, NY 11967
(631) 281-6200 marlinagency.com
Long Island Medicare Planning
18 Dawn Dr, Shirley, NY 11967
(631) 345-2300 longislandmedicareplanning.net
Essential Insurance New York
2 Coraci Blvd, Shirley, NY 11967
(332) 378-1898
Esquire Agency
396 William Floyd Pkwy 2nd Floor, Shirley, NY 11967
(631) 873-3825 esquireagency.net
Affinity Health Plan
60 Northern Blvd, Shirley, NY 11967
(631) 772-1868
Shirley Mastic Insurance Agency
18 Ryerson Ave, Shirley, NY 11967
(631) 399-1000

Supplemental insurance agents in Shirley, New York help residents choose Medigap or Medicare Advantage plans to cover costs not paid by Original Medicare. New York law guarantees a six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting when you turn 65 and enroll in Part B, during which you cannot be denied coverage due to pre-existing conditions. Agents in Shirley can explain how these state protections apply to your specific situation.

What Does a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Shirley Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Shirley, New York vary by plan type, age, and insurer. Medigap Plan G premiums for a 65-year-old typically range from $120 to $250 per month, while Medicare Advantage plans may have lower or zero monthly premiums but higher out-of-pocket costs. New York uses community rating, meaning premiums do not increase with age, but they can vary by region. This is general information, not insurance advice.

* Cost estimates are general ranges based on publicly available data and compiled using automated research tools. Actual fees vary by agent and case complexity. This is not insurance advice — consult directly with an agent for fee specifics.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Shirley?
A supplemental insurance agent in Shirley is a licensed professional who helps you compare and enroll in Medigap or Medicare Advantage plans. They work with multiple carriers to find a plan that fits your needs and budget.
When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in New York?
In New York, your best time to enroll is during the six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this period, insurers cannot deny you coverage or charge higher premiums due to health conditions.