ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Alamogordo, NM

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Alamogordo, New Mexico. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Alamogordo, New Mexico is Amy Tillotson - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 152 reviews. Other highly rated options include Farmers Insurance - Trisha Roberts, Cesar Nava - State Farm Insurance Agent, USA Insurance. This directory lists 20 supplemental insurance agents serving Alamogordo.

Showing 20 supplemental insurance agents in Alamogordo, NMListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Amy Tillotson - State Farm Insurance Agent1018 Vermont Ave(575) 437-3811
2Farmers Insurance - Trisha Roberts1909 Indian Wells Rd(575) 434-8114
3Cesar Nava - State Farm Insurance Agent1222 N White Sands Blvd(575) 446-4246
4USA Insurance3310 N White Sands Blvd(575) 439-9999
5George Gandy Insurance912 Adams Ave(575) 437-2892
6David Quinlan - State Farm Insurance Agent351 Panorama Blvd(575) 446-4022
7Javier Lerma: Allstate Insurance820 E 10th St(575) 812-8030
8Edd Gauldin - State Farm Insurance Agent2904 N White Sands Blvd(575) 437-9948
9Fred Loya Insurance200 E 1st St Ste D(575) 434-0355
10Farmers Insurance - John Glass200 N White Sands Blvd(575) 437-3807
AT
1018 Vermont Ave
Amy Tillotson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

Amy Tillotson - State Farm Insurance Agent serves Alamogordo, New Mexico, offering supplemental insurance policies designed to fill gaps in standard health coverage. This office helps local residents manage out-of-pocket medical costs with products that cover deductibles and copayments. These plans often assist with expenses not paid by major medical insurance, providing financial support during unexpected illness or injury. The agency commonly handles Medicare supplement and accident insurance plans in the Alamogordo area.

FI
1909 Indian Wells Rd
Farmers Insurance - Trisha Roberts
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

Serving the Alamogordo region, Farmers Insurance - Trisha Roberts offers a range of supplemental insurance policies designed to cover gaps in primary health or property coverage. These plans assist with deductibles, coinsurance, and unexpected out-of-pocket costs for individuals and families. As a local agency, it provides guidance on selecting appropriate supplemental options and assists with filing claims when needed. In addition, the agency offers ongoing support to help clients review and adjust their coverage as their circumstances change. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail stores, and restaurants in the area.

CN
1222 N White Sands Blvd
Cesar Nava - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

Cesar Nava - State Farm Insurance Agent serves local homeowners and families in Alamogordo, New Mexico, with supplemental insurance coverage. These plans help fill gaps in traditional policies, providing financial support for unexpected medical events or property losses. The agency assists clients in reviewing their existing coverage to identify where extra protection may be beneficial. Residents can meet with the agent to discuss policies designed for their specific needs. Cesar Nava also extends his supplemental insurance services to clients in the nearby community of Tularosa.

UI
3310 N White Sands Blvd
USA Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

USA Insurance serves Alamogordo, New Mexico, and the surrounding communities in Otero County, providing supplemental insurance coverage that helps individuals bridge gaps left by primary health plans. The agency handles policies for benefits such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity, offering simpler access to funds for out-of-pocket expenses. It generally starts with a no-obligation review of a client's existing coverage and then presents policy options tailored to each situation.

GG
912 Adams Ave
George Gandy Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

George Gandy Insurance serves homeowners, businesses, and property managers in Alamogordo, New Mexico, by offering supplemental insurance policies that help cover costs not included in primary health or property plans. This agency provides local guidance on selecting gap coverage for medical expenses and asset protection. Policyholders receive direct assistance with claims and plan adjustments. The company also serves residents and commercial clients in the neighboring community of Tularosa, ensuring access to supplemental insurance support across the region.

DQ
351 Panorama Blvd
David Quinlan - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

David Quinlan operates as a supplemental insurance agent in Alamogordo, NM. The primary difference between one-time and recurring service options lies in policy structure: one-time plans cover a single event or condition, while recurring options offer continuous coverage for ongoing needs. This agent helps clients select supplementary policies that fill gaps left by primary health insurance, providing financial protection against unexpected costs. Services are available on both a one-time basis for specific policy purchases and as needed for consultations or claims support.

JL
820 E 10th St
Javier Lerma: Allstate Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

Javier Lerma: Allstate Insurance in Alamogordo, New Mexico specializes in supplemental insurance plans that cover gaps left by primary health policies, offering local support for selecting and managing these additional coverages. The agency helps individuals understand their options for hospital indemnity, accident, or critical illness insurance that can pay out directly when medical needs arise. During the open enrollment season in New Mexico, many clients consult here to ensure their supplemental coverage keeps pace with changes in their primary health plan.

EG
2904 N White Sands Blvd
Edd Gauldin - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

Edd Gauldin - State Farm Insurance Agent in Alamogordo, NM, provides supplemental insurance that covers gaps left by primary health plans. This agent’s specialty add-ons address expenses such as deductibles, copays, and unexpected out-of-pocket costs. Policies are designed for individuals seeking financial protection against medical or accident-related losses. The agency serves a variety of commercial sectors, including local offices, warehouses, and food service businesses.

FL
200 E 1st St Ste D
Fred Loya Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

With the seasonal shifts in Alamogordo bringing new health and financial considerations, a supplemental insurance agent helps bridge coverage gaps left by major medical plans. Fred Loya Insurance offers tailored policies that address common local needs for additional protection. Their focus remains on assisting community members in understanding options for dental, vision, or accident plans. Before issuing a policy, a straightforward initial assessment is conducted to review individual circumstances and determine suitable coverage levels.

FI
200 N White Sands Blvd
Farmers Insurance - John Glass
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM

Farmers Insurance - John Glass provides supplemental insurance coverage for residential clients in Alamogordo, New Mexico, assisting with policies that complement existing health plans. Commercial supplemental insurance options are also available for local businesses in the service area, helping to cover gaps in standard coverage. The agency maintains regular contact with policyholders to address any changes in their needs or circumstances. New detailed follow-up occurs periodically between scheduled visits to ensure all supplemental plans remain aligned with customers’ evolving requirements.

FI
1214 N New York Ave
Farmers Insurance - Michael Haymes
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 437-2350
agents.farmers.com/nm/alamogordo/michael-haymes
UI
3310 N White Sands Blvd
USA Insurance and Charles Garland & Harris Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 437-6910
myusainsurance.net
FC
913 Delaware Ave
First Command
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 434-5550
advisor.firstcommand.com/us/nm/alamogordo
CR
1214 N New York Ave
Christopher Rupp Agency LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 437-2350
agents.farmers.com/nm/alamogordo/christopher-rupp
GI
1111 E 10th St
Gregory Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 434-4773
SI
820 N Scenic Dr ste d
Safer Insurance LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 552-8128
BJ
3310 N White Sands Blvd
Boles Jake
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 439-9999
myusainsurance.net
AP
820 E 10th St
Allstate Personal Financial Representative: Heber Spilsbury
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 415-4764
CP
1200 N White Sands Blvd #113
Cooksey & Papson and Rupp Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 430-2517
cookseypapsonandruppinsurance.com
CL
500 E 10th St # 304
Corina Lisk & Ashley Dalton Agencies
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Alamogordo, NM
(575) 434-2719

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Alamogordo Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in New Mexico vary by plan type, age, and location. Medicare Supplement Plan G for a 65-year-old in Alamogordo typically ranges from $110 to $180 per month. Dental and vision add-on plans may cost $30 to $60 per month. These are general estimates and your actual premium will depend on your specific case. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Alamogordo

Supplemental insurance agents in Alamogordo, New Mexico help residents find policies that cover gaps in Medicare or other primary health plans. New Mexico law requires agents to be licensed by the state and follow specific disclosure rules for Medicare supplement plans. Local agents can explain how plans like Medigap work with Original Medicare in Otero County.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a supplemental insurance agent in Alamogordo do?

A supplemental insurance agent helps you compare and enroll in policies that pay for costs not covered by your main health plan. This includes Medicare Supplement plans, dental, vision, and hospital indemnity insurance. Agents must hold a valid New Mexico insurance license.

When can I enroll in a Medicare supplement plan in New Mexico?

You have a six-month open enrollment period starting when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time, you cannot be denied coverage due to health conditions. Outside this window, you may face medical underwriting.

Are there New Mexico rules for supplemental insurance agents?

Yes. New Mexico requires agents to provide a written outline of coverage and a buyer guide for Medicare supplement plans. Agents must also follow the state rules on replacement of existing policies to avoid gaps in coverage.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other New Mexico Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.