ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Mishawaka, IN

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Mishawaka, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Mishawaka, Indiana is McCarthy Insurance Group, rated 4.9 stars across 171 reviews. Other highly rated options include Backstrom Insurance Group, HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher, Pilot Insurance Agency. This directory lists 14 supplemental insurance agents serving Mishawaka.

Showing 14 supplemental insurance agents in Mishawaka, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1McCarthy Insurance Group802 Lincolnway W(574) 259-5622
2Backstrom Insurance Group3006 Lincolnway E(574) 360-8182
3HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher1736 E Day Rd Suite 400 Suite 400(574) 307-8882
4Pilot Insurance Agency822 W 8th St(574) 855-4837
5HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry1736 E Day Rd #400(574) 229-8147
6DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency1117 Lincolnway E(574) 256-6707
7Dennis Insurance Agency2401 Lincolnway W(574) 254-1010
8HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding1736 E Day Rd Ste 200 #400(574) 240-4013
9Summers Insurance Agency12415 McKinley Hwy(574) 252-0502
10Mike Woods Insurance Agency INC American Family Insurance105 E Grove St(574) 259-4400
MI
802 Lincolnway W
McCarthy Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

McCarthy Insurance Group serves the Mishawaka, Indiana, metro area as a supplemental insurance agent. They help clients bridge gaps in primary health coverage by offering policies that pay cash benefits directly to the policyholder. These plans can assist with out-of-pocket costs such as deductibles and copays during medical events. Common supplemental products available through this agency include accident insurance and critical illness coverage, both designed to provide financial support when unexpected health issues arise.

BI
3006 Lincolnway E
Backstrom Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Backstrom Insurance Group offers supplemental insurance agent services in the Mishawaka, IN area, providing policies designed to fill gaps in primary health coverage. The agency assists clients with plan selection, enrollment, and ongoing claims support to ensure benefits are utilized effectively. Policyholders receive guidance through annual reviews and updates as their needs change. These supplemental insurance plans are available for single-family homes, apartments, retail, and restaurant property owners.

HI
1736 E Day Rd Suite 400 Suite 400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Tony Letcher serves homeowners and individuals in Mishawaka, Indiana, by providing supplemental insurance agent services. These policies help cover expenses not included in primary health plans, such as accident, hospital indemnity, or critical illness costs. The agency assists local customers in understanding and choosing suitable supplemental coverage for their personal needs and financial situations. Its service area also extends to the greater South Bend metropolitan region.

PI
822 W 8th St
Pilot Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Pilot Insurance Agency serves Mishawaka and the surrounding communities in north-central Indiana with a focus on supplemental insurance. It handles policies that help cover costs beyond traditional health plans, such as accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity coverage for local residents. To address a typical job, it first reviews each client’s current coverage and specific financial risks, then identifies gaps before selecting appropriate policy options. This approach ensures the final recommendation matches the individual’s needs and budget.

HI
1736 E Day Rd #400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Derek Mabry in Mishawaka, IN, provides supplemental insurance, which typically covers gaps that primary health plans leave, such as copays, deductibles, or accident costs. Unlike one-time event policies, recurring coverage like Medicare supplements or cancer plans renew as long as the client needs protection. The agent advises individuals on selecting appropriate benefits based on their specific health and financial situations. Service is available on an as-needed basis for new enrollments, plan reviews, or questions about existing policies.

DI
1117 Lincolnway E
DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

DAC Insurance Inc., Michiana's Insurance Agency in Mishawaka provides supplemental insurance that fills the coverage gaps left by major medical plans, offering focused policies such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity protection. It assists area residents with routine policy reviews and claim guidance to simplify their benefits. During the cold season, the agency helps clients prepare for potential influenza complications that can lead to unexpected out-of-pocket costs.

DI
2401 Lincolnway W
Dennis Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

As the leaves turn in the St. Joseph Valley, many Mishawaka residents think about covering medical gaps a regular plan might miss. Dennis Insurance Agency in Mishawaka helps people here find the right supplemental insurance to handle those out-of-pocket costs. A local agent can explain how these plans complement existing coverage for better financial protection during a sudden illness or accident. To make sure a specific policy fits a person's situation, the initial step always involves a simple, in-person review of current benefits and potential needs.

HI
1736 E Day Rd Ste 200 #400
HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Zack Spaulding provides supplemental insurance solutions for residential clients in Mishawaka, focusing on policies that help cover gaps in primary health plans. The agency also extends commercial coverage options to local businesses seeking to protect their employees and operations throughout the greater St. Joseph County area. Serving both individual households and company accounts, the agency ensures clients have access to tailored benefit plans. Zack Spaulding maintains ongoing contact with policyholders to review coverage adjustments and facilitate seamless follow-up service between regular visits.

SI
12415 McKinley Hwy
Summers Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN

Summers Insurance Agency operates as a local supplemental insurance agent located in Mishawaka, Indiana. The firm specializes in offering supplementary policies that help fill coverage gaps left by standard health and medical plans. Clients can explore additional options for accident, critical illness, or hospital indemnity protection to better manage out-of-pocket expenses. Regarding commercial sectors, the agency can serve businesses of various types, including local offices seeking extra employee benefits, warehouses needing workforce protection, and food service establishments requiring tailored supplemental coverage for their staff.

MW
105 E Grove St
Mike Woods Insurance Agency INC American Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
SI
13800 Jackson Rd
Synergy Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 258-5555
synergyinsurancegroup.com
TI
1602 N Main St
Trevino Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 256-5712
trevinoinsurance.com
WI
425 Park Pl Cir Suite 400
WalkerHughes Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 234-7788
walkerhughes.com
MM
509 W McKinley Ave Ste 1
Medicare Michiana
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Mishawaka, IN
(574) 370-8555

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Mishawaka Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Indiana vary by plan type age and insurer. Medigap Plan G premiums for a 65-year-old in Mishawaka typically range from 120 to 250 dollars per month. Plan N may cost 90 to 180 dollars per month. Costs can change each year and depend on your location and health status. This is general information not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Mishawaka

Supplemental insurance agents in Mishawaka Indiana help residents find Medigap and Medicare Supplement plans. Indiana law allows a six-month open enrollment period for Medigap when you first enroll in Medicare Part B. Local agents can explain plan options and guide you through the application process.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Mishawaka?

A supplemental insurance agent in Mishawaka helps you buy Medigap or Medicare Supplement policies. These agents are licensed in Indiana and can compare plans from different insurance companies for you.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Indiana?

In Indiana you have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time you cannot be denied coverage due to health conditions.

Do supplemental insurance agents charge fees in Mishawaka?

Most supplemental insurance agents in Mishawaka are paid commissions by the insurance company, not by you. There is usually no direct fee for their help with plan selection and enrollment.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.