ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeSupplemental Insurance AgentsIndiana › Indianapolis

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Indianapolis, IN

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Indianapolis, Indiana. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Indianapolis, Indiana is Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group, rated 5.0 stars across 1,179 reviews. Other highly rated options include Easy Street Insurance, Steffey Insurance Agency, Wenclewicz Insurance. This directory lists 22 supplemental insurance agents serving Indianapolis.

Showing 22 supplemental insurance agents in Indianapolis, INListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group7212 Shadeland Ave # 201(317) 350-1598
2Easy Street Insurance8000 S Meridian St(317) 882-9602
3Steffey Insurance Agency3091 E 98th St SUITE 125(317) 334-3743
4Wenclewicz Insurance7202 Shadeland Ave # 207(317) 288-5099
5Breneman Insurance Group5329 S Emerson Ave Suite A(317) 786-2200
6Access Auto Insurance8249 Pendleton Pike(317) 890-4900
7Conner Insurance8445 Keystone Crossing #200
8HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky3535 E 96th St Ste 117 Ste 117(317) 418-8271
9Burns Family Insurance1800 N Meridian St #103a(317) 377-1100
10Central Insurance Associates70 91st St #200(317) 846-4622
SW
7212 Shadeland Ave # 201
Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group serves the Indianapolis, Indiana metro area as a supplemental insurance agent. This agency helps clients address coverage gaps not filled by major medical plans. It offers policies that provide fixed cash benefits directly to the policyholder for events like hospitalization or critical illness. These standalone plans can support with deductibles, copays, or everyday expenses during recovery. The agency also handles accident and cancer-specific insurance, which are targeted supplemental options popular in the region.

ES
8000 S Meridian St
Easy Street Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

For one-time needs, Easy Street Insurance in Indianapolis, IN helps clients compare individual supplemental policies, while also offering scheduled reviews for those already enrolled in a plan. The agency focuses on coverage options that fill gaps left by primary health insurance, such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. These products help manage out-of-pocket costs for local residents. Service is available on an as-needed basis, with clients contacting the office when they have questions or require policy changes.

SI
3091 E 98th St SUITE 125
Steffey Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

As Indianapolis residents face rising out-of-pocket costs from standard health plans, Steffey Insurance Agency provides supplemental insurance options to help bridge those financial gaps. These policies can offer direct cash benefits for unexpected medical events, which assists families in managing expenses like deductibles or lost wages during recovery. The agency focuses on explaining these tailored coverages clearly and scheduling a simple, no-obligation review of a client’s existing needs to identify the gaps that could be addressed. A personal assessment is conducted as the first practical step.

WI
7202 Shadeland Ave # 207
Wenclewicz Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Wenclewicz Insurance in Indianapolis specializes in supplemental insurance options, such as hospital indemnity and critical illness plans, helping clients fill gaps left by primary health coverage. The agency works with area residents to access policies that provide cash benefits for out-of-pocket costs not addressed by major medical insurance. Its agents assist in reviewing current coverage to identify potential exposures. Many clients rely on these benefits during the annual open enrollment season, when evaluating Medicare supplement and employer plan changes becomes a priority.

BI
5329 S Emerson Ave Suite A
Breneman Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Breneman Insurance Group in Indianapolis, Indiana serves local residents with supplemental insurance policies that help cover expenses not paid by primary health plans. The agency also provides commercial clients with comparable gap coverage tailored to business needs. Their service area encompasses Indianapolis and the surrounding communities within the region. Supplemental policies from this agent typically allow customers to schedule follow-up consultations between regular plan renewals, ensuring coverage remains aligned with changing circumstances.

AA
8249 Pendleton Pike
Access Auto Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Access Auto Insurance serves homeowners, families, and professionals seeking meaningful coverage gaps for their core policies. As a supplemental insurance agent in Indianapolis, the company operates with a focus on helping clients compare options in accident, health, and property endorsement plans. Its services assist individuals in understanding how gap coverage can apply after deductibles or claim limits are exhausted on primary insurance. Access Auto Insurance also extends its guidance and plan comparison services to the neighboring community of Carmel within the broader Indianapolis metropolitan area.

CI
8445 Keystone Crossing #200
Conner Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
HI
3535 E 96th St Ste 117 Ste 117
HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

HealthMarkets Insurance - Staci Lepsky serves the Indianapolis, Indiana metro area as a Supplemental Insurance Agent. The agency helps clients explore options for coverage that fills gaps left by major medical plans. These additional policies can provide financial support for expenses such as deductibles, copays, and coinsurance. The agent guides individuals in understanding how supplemental benefits might assist during unexpected health events. The office focuses on services like hospital indemnity plans and accident insurance, which offer direct cash benefits for covered medical situations.

BF
1800 N Meridian St #103a
Burns Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Burns Family Insurance provides supplemental insurance policies designed to cover gaps not addressed by primary health plans in Indianapolis, Indiana. Their services focus on offering financial protection for unexpected medical costs, including hospital stays and critical illness expenses. Maintenance plan options ensure continued coverage adjustments as client needs change over time. The agency represents multiple carriers to present suitable policy choices for individuals and families. It services single-family homes, apartments, retail establishments, and restaurants across the local area.

CI
70 91st St #200
Central Insurance Associates
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN

Central Insurance Associates serves Indianapolis and its surrounding communities, offering supplemental insurance agent services to residents in the area. These policies cover costs not included by primary health plans, such as deductibles and copayments for medical events. A typical job involves reviewing a client's existing coverage and identifying gaps in protection. The company generally meets with individuals to explain policy options clearly, ensuring each client selects a plan suited to their specific financial and health needs.

PH
9765 Randall Dr
Premier Health Advisors
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 819-0140
mypremierhealthadvisors.com
1I
4030 S Emerson Ave Suite B
A-1 Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 787-4995
a1insureit.com
NI
8435 Keystone Crossing #160
Nefouse Indiana Group Health Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(800) 846-8615
nefousehealthinsurance.com
HI
1232 W 86th St
HealthMarkets Insurance - Michael Wehner
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(614) 270-9921
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/mwehner
JI
5700 N College Ave
Jeremiah Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 506-2717
jeremiahinsuranceinc.com
IS
4202 E New York St
Indy Select Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 875-1522
indyselectinsurance.com
HI
450 E 96th St #500
Hoosier Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 536-2999
hoosierinsurancegroup.com
MI
10475 Crosspoint Blvd Suite 250
Multiline Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 476-6141
multi-lineins.com
SI
5519 E 82nd St Suite E
Skaggs Insurance Agencies Inc
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 841-6000
skaggsinsurance.com
IB
5645 N Post Rd # C
Insurance By George
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(317) 544-5207
insurancebygeorge.com
AS
3500 Depauw Blvd Suite 1054
Andrew Sandlin - HealthMarkets Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(574) 536-3947
healthmarkets.com/local-health-insurance-agent/asandlin
MS
1311 W 96th St #240
Mermit SR22 Insurance Agency of Indiana
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Indianapolis, IN
(260) 731-1483

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Indianapolis Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Indiana vary by policy type and your age. A Medicare Supplement Plan G can cost between $100 and $250 per month for a 65 year old. Cancer insurance premiums often range from $30 to $100 per month. Costs depend on your health status and the insurer. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Indianapolis

Supplemental insurance agents in Indianapolis help residents fill gaps left by major medical plans. Indiana law requires agents to hold a valid Indiana insurance license and follow state regulations on policy disclosures. Local agents often assist with Medicare Supplement plans and hospital indemnity policies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Indianapolis?

A supplemental insurance agent sells policies that cover costs not paid by your primary health insurance. In Indiana these agents must be licensed by the Indiana Department of Insurance. They help you choose plans like accident or critical illness coverage.

Do I need a special license to sell supplemental insurance in Indiana?

Yes. Indiana requires a life and health insurance producer license. Agents must complete pre-licensing education and pass a state exam. They must also take continuing education courses every two years.

Can a supplemental insurance agent help with Medicare in Indianapolis?

Yes. Many agents are certified to sell Medicare Supplement plans and Medicare Advantage plans. In Indiana you have a six-month open enrollment period when you turn 65 to buy a Medigap policy without medical underwriting.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Indiana Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.