ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Supplemental Insurance Agents Near You in Pensacola, FL

Browse supplemental insurance agents serving Pensacola, Florida. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated supplemental insurance agent in Pensacola, Florida is John Shaffer - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 1,051 reviews. Other highly rated options include Will Rentschler - State Farm Insurance Agent, Advance Insurance of Northwest Florida, Florida Insurance Agency. This directory lists 42 supplemental insurance agents serving Pensacola.

Showing 42 supplemental insurance agents in Pensacola, FLListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1John Shaffer - State Farm Insurance Agent117 N Palafox St(850) 433-4343
2Will Rentschler - State Farm Insurance Agent1301 E Cervantes St(850) 433-4678
3Advance Insurance of Northwest Florida105 Beverly Pkwy(850) 469-0880
4Florida Insurance Agency17 W Government St Suite A(850) 972-8070
5Classic Insurance Group1545 E Olive Rd(850) 332-5717
6Globe Life Liberty National Division: The Mitchell & Mitchell Agencies1449 W 9 Mile Rd Suite 11 & 12(251) 660-4437
7Acceptance Insurance8084 N Davis Hwy Ste E-1(850) 204-3795
8Sam Carpenter - State Farm Insurance Agent1510 Airport Blvd Suite 1(850) 208-6626
9The O'Neil Agency LLC (Formerly David Seckinger & Associates)1117 N 9th Ave(850) 469-8082
10Messick Insurance196 E 9 Mile Rd # A(850) 479-3535
JS
117 N Palafox St
John Shaffer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

John Shaffer - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Pensacola, Florida area as a local supplemental insurance agent. This agency offers supplemental insurance policies designed to help clients cover costs that primary health plans may not fully address. The agency guides customers through available options for managing out-of-pocket expenses or income gaps during medical events. John Shaffer - State Farm Insurance Agent assists clients with specific supplemental offerings such as accident insurance and hospital indemnity plans.

WR
1301 E Cervantes St
Will Rentschler - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

Will Rentschler - State Farm Insurance Agent in Pensacola, FL, offers a range of supplemental insurance services, including accidental injury, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans. The agency assists clients with selecting and managing these supplemental plans, providing ongoing support for policy coverage questions and annual enrollment updates. Service includes coordinating benefit claims and adjusting coverage as personal needs change. The agency provides these services to owners and residents of single-family homes, apartments, retail shops, and restaurants in the greater Pensacola area.

AI
105 Beverly Pkwy
Advance Insurance of Northwest Florida
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

Advance Insurance of Northwest Florida serves the city of Pensacola and the surrounding communities of the western Panhandle. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company handles essential gap coverage policies such as hospital indemnity, accident, and critical illness plans. These products are designed to pay cash benefits directly to the policyholder alongside a primary health plan. The agency generally approaches a typical job by first conducting a personalized needs review to identify any financial exposure, then presents suitable plan options from its carrier lineup for review and selection.

FI
17 W Government St Suite A
Florida Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

Serving homeowners, renters, and families in Florida, this agency focuses on supplemental insurance to help cover costs that major health plans do not. It offers policies such as accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity plans to provide financial protection during unexpected medical events. The team works directly with local clients to explain coverage options and complete applications. Alongside Pensacola, the agency also serves residents in the Pace community and surrounding Santa Rosa County neighborhoods.

CI
1545 E Olive Rd
Classic Insurance Group
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

Classic Insurance Group in Pensacola, FL specializes in supplemental insurance, distinguishing between one-time policy purchases and recurring coverage options that fill gaps in primary plans. These complementary plans handle out-of-pocket expenses like deductibles and copays for accident or hospital stays. As a supplemental insurance agent, the company helps clients select specific add-on policies suited to their individual needs. Service runs on a one-time basis for policy setup, with ongoing support provided as needed for claims or coverage adjustments.

GL
1449 W 9 Mile Rd Suite 11 & 12
Globe Life Liberty National Division: The Mitchell & Mitchell Agencies
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

Globe Life Liberty National Division: The Mitchell & Mitchell Agencies specializes in supplemental insurance, offering policies for life, accident, cancer, and disability coverage in the Pensacola area. Its general services help families fill gaps left by primary health plans, providing direct cash benefits for medical deductibles and everyday expenses. As a local agent, it explains policy options and assists with claims personally. For residents preparing for hurricane season on the Gulf Coast, it can address questions about supplemental coverage for storm-related injuries.

AI
8084 N Davis Hwy Ste E-1
Acceptance Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

As hurricane season approaches in Pensacola, residents seek reassurance that their policies cover gaps left by standard health plans. Acceptance Insurance, a local supplemental insurance agent, helps clients address these concerns by offering policies for accident, critical illness, and hospital indemnity needs. The team takes time to explain how each option complements existing coverage, ensuring customers understand their benefits before committing. A typical first step involves a complimentary review of current insurance, followed by a personalized assessment of potential gaps in the individual’s financial protection plan.

SC
1510 Airport Blvd Suite 1
Sam Carpenter - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

Sam Carpenter - State Farm Insurance Agent in Pensacola, FL, focuses on helping clients manage financial risk through various personal insurance options. As a supplemental insurance agent, the office specializes in policies that provide additional coverage for accidents, critical illness, and hospital stays, filling gaps left by primary health plans. These supplemental products can offer cash benefits directly to policyholders for unexpected medical expenses. The agency serves local commercial sectors, including offices needing extra disability protection, warehouses requiring specialized accident coverage, and food service businesses seeking income replacement for injured staff.

ON
1117 N 9th Ave
The O'Neil Agency LLC (Formerly David Seckinger & Associates)
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL

The O'Neil Agency, formerly David Seckinger & Associates, serves residential clients throughout Pensacola, Florida, with supplemental insurance policies. These plans help cover costs that major medical insurance leaves behind. Commercial coverage is also available for local businesses seeking similar financial protection. The agency serves the greater Pensacola area and surrounding communities. After an initial enrollment, representatives remain available for follow-up assistance and can review coverage needs during each regular visit to ensure policies still fit the client’s situation.

MI
196 E 9 Mile Rd # A
Messick Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
RL
6100 W Fairfield Dr Ste A
Robinson Legacy Insurance Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 285-0808
brand.site/robinsonlegacyinsurance
NI
1007 N 12th Ave
Navita Insurance & Benefits
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(706) 594-7371
mycoastalrg.com
PG
12385 Sorrento Rd Suite C-1
Policy Guide, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(888) 414-4547
policyguide.com
TC
1403 E Belmont St
Torgersen Consulting
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 433-9996
tcbenefitsgroup.com
KI
5401 Pensacola Blvd
Key Insurance of Pensacola
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 434-2460
keyinsurancepensacola.com
DA
1890 N Pace Blvd
Direct Auto Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 434-5690
local.directauto.com/florida/pensacola/1890-n-pace-blvd
GC
700 N New Warrington Rd
Gulf Coast Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 497-6810
gcains.com
MI
1259 W 9 Mile Rd
Madril Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 476-2733
madrilinsurance.com
PI
21 S Tarragona St Suite 103
Peterson Insurance & Financial Services
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 741-1015
cpetersonfinancial.com
EI
123 N New Warrington Rd
Extreme Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 455-0101
yourextremeins.com
ZI
229 Beverly Pkwy
Zarahn Insurance Agency Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 438-9169
zarahninsuranceagency.com
GI
6705 Pine Forest Rd Suite 300
GreatFlorida Insurance: Beau Barry
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 475-0702
pensacola.greatflorida.com
MC
6501 North W Street
Medicare Compare Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 503-3226
pensacolamedicaresupplements.com
MH
611 N New Warrington Rd
Mike Hill - State Farm Insurance Agent
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 456-2886
mikehill.biz
TW
4761 N 9th Ave
Thompson-Walden Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 478-0401
morechoicesins.com
HI
87 W Hood Dr
Holloway Insurance, Inc.
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 434-0335
hollowayinsurance.com
MI
3750 N Pace Blvd
Mitchell Insurance Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 434-7753
mitchellinsuranceagency.net
JI
225 N Pace Blvd
Josh Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 990-5674
joshinsurance.com
LI
700 N De Villiers St
Legacy Insurance Brokers
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 741-4200
legacyinsbroker.com
BI
4300 Bayou Blvd Ste 35
BLF INSURANCE AGENCY, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 490-0056
blfinsurance.com
CF
5336 N Blue Angel Pkwy
Coastal Family Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 828-2234
coastalfamilyinsurancefl.com
DG
4400 Bayou Blvd STE 41
Dax Gill Insurance Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 777-3090
daxgillinsurance.com
RM
6501 North W Street
Rachel Maneen Agent, Pensacola, Florida Health, Vision and Dental Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 202-8888
pensacolahealthinsurance.com
HP
11 W Garden St
Higginbotham - Pensacola
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 484-7011
higginbotham.com/locations/Pensacola
FB
1680 Airport Blvd
Florida Blue Center - Pensacola
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 202-4150
floridablue.com/center/pensacola
SI
1550 Creighton Rd Suite 7
SHR Insurance / Sylvia Ramos
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 607-1563
shrinsurance.com
HI
534 S Navy Blvd
Homefront Insurance Agency, LLC
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 912-9956
homefrontinsuranceagency.com
AI
672 Brent Ln
Affiliated Insurance
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 477-5840
floridamajormedical.com
AF
125 W Romana St
AmeriLife of Florida, LLC- Pensacola
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 741-2514
amerilife.com/pensacola
AM
125 W Romana St
Amerilife Medicare Plans, Pensacola
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 266-4005
pensacolamedicareinsurance.com
PP
6501 North W Street
Pat Paulsen Agency
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 474-9159
patpaulsenagency.com
ST
6503 North W Street
Sheila Thomas Agent, Pensacola Florida
Supplemental Insurance Agent · Pensacola, FL
(850) 712-1537
askpensacolainsurance.com

What Does a a Supplemental Insurance Agent in Pensacola Cost?

Supplemental insurance costs in Florida vary by plan type age and health status. For example Medigap Plan G premiums in Pensacola typically range from 120 to 250 dollars per month for a 65 year old. Medicare Advantage plans often have low or zero monthly premiums but may have copays and network limits. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About supplemental insurance agents in Pensacola

Supplemental insurance agents in Pensacola Florida help residents find coverage that fills gaps in Medicare or employer health plans. Florida law requires all agents to be licensed by the state and to follow strict disclosure rules. Local agents can explain how plans like Medigap or Medicare Advantage work with your existing coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a supplemental insurance agent in Pensacola?

A supplemental insurance agent is a licensed professional who helps you buy policies that cover costs not paid by your main health plan. In Florida these agents must pass a state exam and renew their license every two years. They can offer plans like Medigap critical illness or hospital indemnity insurance.

When can I enroll in a Medigap plan in Florida?

You have a six-month Medigap open enrollment period that starts when you are 65 and enrolled in Medicare Part B. During this time you can buy any Medigap policy without medical underwriting. After this period insurers in Florida can use health questions to decide your premium or deny coverage.

Are there Florida laws that affect supplemental insurance?

Yes Florida has a 30-day free look period for Medicare supplement policies. This means you can cancel a new policy within 30 days for a full refund. Florida also requires agents to provide a written outline of coverage before you buy a policy.

Supplemental Insurance Agents in Other Florida Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each supplemental insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.