ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in Sheboygan, WI

Browse renters insurance agents serving Sheboygan, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in Sheboygan, Wisconsin is Acuity Insurance, rated 4.2 stars across 1,622 reviews. Other highly rated options include Sue Breitbach Fenn Agency LLC American Family Insurance, Allstate Insurance Agent Jerry Bodart, Aim Group Inc.. This directory lists 19 renters insurance agents serving Sheboygan.

Showing 19 renters insurance agents in Sheboygan, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Acuity Insurance2800 S Taylor Dr(800) 242-7666
2Sue Breitbach Fenn Agency LLC American Family Insurance3626 Erie Ave(920) 457-1950
3Allstate Insurance Agent Jerry Bodart909 N 8th St UNIT 105(920) 547-5724
4Aim Group Inc.526 N 8th St(920) 457-9112
5J M Sampson Agency LLC American Family Insurance2204 Wilson Ave Ste 2(920) 452-3661
6Gene Kopp Agency Inc American Family Insurance2109 Erie Ave #101(920) 458-7141
7Amy Gabrielse Agency, Inc American Family Insurance2108 Kohler Memorial Dr Ste 200(920) 458-2101
8Nicla Insurance506 N 8th St(920) 452-8461
9Blia Vang - State Farm Insurance Agent3005 S 12th St(920) 452-2482
10Pete Fullerton - State Farm Insurance Agent1305 N 8th St(920) 458-4211
AI
2800 S Taylor Dr
Acuity Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Acuity Insurance serves the Sheboygan, Wisconsin area as a renters insurance agent. It helps local residents protect their personal belongings and liability within rental properties. The company assists renters in securing coverage for their possessions against common risks like theft, fire, and water damage. It also offers policies that include temporary living expense protection when a rented home becomes uninhabitable. Acuity handles the process of customizing renters policies for apartments, condominiums, and single-family rental homes in this area.

SB
3626 Erie Ave
Sue Breitbach Fenn Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Serving the Sheboygan area, Sue Breitbach Fenn Agency LLC American Family Insurance provides renters insurance policies designed to protect tenants' personal belongings from covered perils such as theft, fire, and water damage. The agency offers liability coverage options and assistance reviewing policy details to match coverage with individual needs. Policies can be tailored for various dwelling types, including single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

AI
909 N 8th St UNIT 105
Allstate Insurance Agent Jerry Bodart
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Homeowners, renters, and landlords in Sheboygan rely on Allstate Insurance Agent Jerry Bodart for renters insurance coverage. The agency guides customers through policies that protect personal belongings and provide liability protection. It helps residents understand policy details, deductibles, and coverage limits. Services extend to local property managers seeking tenant insurance solutions as well. The agency also covers households in the nearby community of Kohler and throughout Sheboygan County.

AG
526 N 8th St
Aim Group Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Aim Group Inc. serves Sheboygan and the surrounding communities in Wisconsin, handling renters insurance policies for local tenants and property owners. The agency addresses common coverage needs including personal property protection and liability safeguards for those leasing apartments or homes. For a typical job, it reviews a client’s individual living situation to recommend a suitable policy, then works through the paperwork and explains the terms directly until the renter understands the plan in place.

JM
2204 Wilson Ave Ste 2
J M Sampson Agency LLC American Family Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

J M Sampson Agency LLC American Family Insurance in Sheboygan, WI provides renters insurance as an ongoing, renewable policy rather than a one-time purchase, offering continuous protection for personal belongings against covered loss. Coverage options can include liability protection for accidents occurring within a rented home or apartment. This local agency assists clients in understanding policy limits and deductibles to suit their specific needs. Service plans are available on a scheduled basis, allowing for regular policy reviews and updates.

GK
2109 Erie Ave #101
Gene Kopp Agency Inc American Family Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Gene Kopp Agency Inc American Family Insurance provides tailored renters insurance policies that protect personal belongings and liability in Sheboygan, WI. It guides clients through coverage options for apartments, houses, and condos, including protection against theft, fire, and water damage. The company also assists with selecting deductibles and additional endorsements. During the winter season, it helps renters address risks such as frozen pipe breaks and ice dam-related property damage.

AG
2108 Kohler Memorial Dr Ste 200
Amy Gabrielse Agency, Inc American Family Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

As the lakeside winds bring heavy rain to Sheboygan each spring, residents often realize their current coverage lacks flood protection. Amy Gabrielse Agency, Inc American Family Insurance helps local tenants secure a renters insurance policy that safeguards personal belongings against such seasonal water damage alongside fire and theft. This agency understands the specific risks of Wisconsin living and works with clients to outline liability options that meet ordinary household needs. Anyone inquiring about protection can begin with a simple risk assessment call to document current possessions and rental property safety features.

NI
506 N 8th St
Nicla Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Nicla Insurance provides renters insurance services for residences in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, helping tenants protect personal belongings against common losses. The agency also offers commercial coverage for small businesses and rental property owners throughout the broader area. An agent can explain coverage options and adjust policies as circumstances change over time. Returning clients often schedule follow-up consultations before lease renewals or at regular intervals to review their changing possessions and liability needs.

BV
3005 S 12th St
Blia Vang - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Blia Vang - State Farm Insurance Agent assists Sheboygan residents in securing renters coverage that protects personal belongings and provides liability protection. This agency also helps clients add specialized endorsements for valuable items like jewelry or electronics beyond standard policy limits. The team serves both individual renters and commercial tenants needing customized policies for offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

PF
1305 N 8th St
Pete Fullerton - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI

Pete Fullerton - State Farm Insurance Agent in Sheboygan, WI, is known for helping local residents protect their personal belongings and liability through renters insurance policies. The agency offers coverage for apartments, condos, and rental homes throughout the Sheboygan area. Policies can include protection for possessions against fire, theft, and certain water damage incidents. A specialty service the agency can add on is coverage for valuable items such as jewelry or electronics with a scheduled personal property endorsement.

HA
1601 N 8th St
Heinen & Associates
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 458-9724
heineninsurance.com
BI
801 N 8th St
Brandl Insurance Agency Sheboygan
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 457-3743
brandlinsurance.com
IM
1403 Broadway Ave
Insurance and Mortgage Services, Inc
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
insmort.com
CT
1732 S 8th St
Chris Toutloff - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 458-7732
statefarm.com/agent/us/wi/sheboygan/chris-toutloff-pcn691ys000
BI
1424 Union Ave
Boll Insurance Agency, inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 457-7386
bollinsuranceagency.net
AI
1539 N 33rd Pl a
AAA Insurance - Adventure Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 783-6890
locator.acg.aaa.com/wi/sheboygan/aaa-insurance-adventure-insurance-agency
MI
833 Pennsylvania Ave
McClone Insurance - Sheboygan
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 458-6174
mcclone.com/sheboygan
CI
1414 N Taylor Dr #105
Circle Insurance Service, Inc
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 458-0321
circleinsurance.com
TI
1414 N Taylor Dr #105
Trempe Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · Sheboygan, WI
(920) 452-9483
trempeinsuranceagency.com

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in Sheboygan Cost?

Typical renters insurance in Wisconsin costs between $15 and $30 per month for a standard policy with $30,000 in personal property coverage. Higher coverage limits or add-ons like flood or earthquake protection will increase the premium. Costs vary by case and by insurance company. This is general information not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in Sheboygan

Renters insurance agents in Sheboygan Wisconsin help tenants protect their belongings and cover liability risks. Wisconsin law does not require renters insurance but many landlords in Sheboygan now ask for proof of coverage in lease agreements. Local agents can explain how Wisconsin tenant laws affect your policy options and coverage limits.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a renters insurance agent in Sheboygan do?

A renters insurance agent in Sheboygan helps you find a policy that covers your personal property and liability. They explain different coverage levels and deductibles. They also assist with filing claims if you have a loss.

Is renters insurance required by law in Wisconsin?

No Wisconsin state law does not require renters insurance. However many landlords in Sheboygan include a requirement in the lease. An agent can help you meet that requirement with an affordable policy.

What factors affect renters insurance cost in Sheboygan?

Cost depends on your coverage amount deductible and location in Sheboygan. The value of your belongings and your claims history also affect the premium. An agent can compare quotes from different carriers to find a good rate.

Renters Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.