ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeRenters Insurance AgentsWisconsin › New Berlin

Find Renters Insurance Agents Near You in New Berlin, WI

Browse renters insurance agents serving New Berlin, Wisconsin. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated renters insurance agent in New Berlin, Wisconsin is Christy Celeste - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 205 reviews. Other highly rated options include John Hillyer - State Farm Insurance Agent, MM Insurance Assoc Inc, Joseph Lehmann IV: Allstate Insurance. This directory lists 16 renters insurance agents serving New Berlin.

Showing 16 renters insurance agents in New Berlin, WIListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Christy Celeste - State Farm Insurance Agent2675 S Calhoun Rd(262) 784-3080
2John Hillyer - State Farm Insurance Agent15855 W National Ave Ste 105(262) 782-3900
3MM Insurance Assoc Inc15885 W National Ave Ste 300(262) 754-4736
4Joseph Lehmann IV: Allstate Insurance2665 S Moorland Rd Suite #206(262) 226-2555
5American Advantage - Petersen14785 W National Ave(262) 432-0789
6Herbst & Associates Inc American Family Insurance15171 W National Ave #201(262) 691-3070
7Paul Conradson - State Farm Insurance Agent16717 W Greenfield Ave(262) 784-2828
8NexGen Risk Solutions, Inc.16735 W Greenfield Ave(217) 627-6992
9Farmers Insurance - Thomas Bell15885 W National Ave Ste 300(262) 395-7768
10Insurance Associates of America17500 W Liberty Ln(262) 754-5252
CC
2675 S Calhoun Rd
Christy Celeste - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

Christy Celeste - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Milwaukee County area of Wisconsin from its New Berlin location, specializing in renters insurance policies for local residents. The agency helps tenants protect their personal belongings from risks like theft, fire, and water damage. Clients can also work with the agent to secure liability coverage that guards against accidents occurring inside a rented home or apartment. Additionally, the office assists with obtaining loss-of-use benefits to cover temporary living expenses when a rental becomes uninhabitable due to a covered claim.

JH
15855 W National Ave Ste 105
John Hillyer - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

John Hillyer - State Farm Insurance Agent in New Berlin, WI, offers a range of services that help customers protect their personal belongings and liability through customized renters insurance policies. The agency provides ongoing policy management, including annual reviews to adjust coverage limits as needed. It also supports clients with claims filing assistance and coverage for additional living expenses during displacements. The company services single-family homes, apartments, retail spaces, and restaurants.

MI
15885 W National Ave Ste 300
MM Insurance Assoc Inc
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

MM Insurance Assoc Inc serves homeowners, landlords, and property managers in the New Berlin area, offering renters insurance policies to protect tenants’ personal belongings and liability. Their agents help clients assess coverage needs for apartments, condos, and single-family rentals. They work with individuals and local property owners to secure policies that fit various budgets and lease requirements. The agency also serves residents in the surrounding communities of Waukesha and southeastern Waukesha County, providing coverage guidance for renters across the greater Milwaukee metro region.

JL
2665 S Moorland Rd Suite #206
Joseph Lehmann IV: Allstate Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

Joseph Lehmann IV: Allstate Insurance serves New Berlin, Wisconsin, and the surrounding communities. The agency handles renters insurance policies, protecting personal belongings and offering liability coverage. For a typical job, it reviews a client’s specific needs and current possessions to recommend an appropriate coverage level. It then explains policy options, including deductibles and potential discounts, and assists in completing the necessary paperwork. The agency applies a straightforward, consultative approach to help clients understand their policy details and secure protection for their rental property.

AA
14785 W National Ave
American Advantage - Petersen
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

American Advantage - Petersen in New Berlin, WI typically offers both one-time policy setup and ongoing coverage management for renters. The agency helps tenants protect personal belongings and liability through standard renters insurance policies designed for local residents. Because a renters policy requires annual renewal decisions, service runs on a scheduled basis rather than as a one-time event or an on-demand call. Clients work with the agent when renewing or adjusting their current plan to match changing needs.

HA
15171 W National Ave #201
Herbst & Associates Inc American Family Insurance
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

Herbst & Associates Inc American Family Insurance specializes in connecting New Berlin residents with renters insurance policies tailored to protect personal belongings and provide liability coverage. The agency generally assists local clients in reviewing coverage limits and deductibles to match individual needs. It also helps renters address specific concerns, such as ensuring adequate protection for valuables during spring storm season or after a minor fire in a neighboring unit.

PC
16717 W Greenfield Ave
Paul Conradson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

As local storms shift through Waukesha County, many renters in New Berlin seek coverage for sudden water or wind damage to their belongings. Paul Conradson - State Farm Insurance Agent provides a policy review to explain how personal property, liability, and temporary living expenses are structured for apartment and condo residents. After discussing typical local risks from hail or frozen pipes, the agent schedules a brief phone consultation to confirm needed coverage limits and begin the initial-assesment step.

NR
16735 W Greenfield Ave
NexGen Risk Solutions, Inc.
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

NexGen Risk Solutions, Inc. provides renters insurance policies to clients in the New Berlin, WI area, helping protect personal belongings and liability exposure within rental properties. It offers tailored coverage options that can include protection for high-value items such as jewelry, electronics, or collectibles through scheduled personal property endorsements. Additionally, its policies may extend to cover temporary relocation costs in the event of a unit becoming uninhabitable. The company serves a range of commercial sectors, including offices, warehouses, and food service establishments.

FI
15885 W National Ave Ste 300
Farmers Insurance - Thomas Bell
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

Farmers Insurance - Thomas Bell provides residential renters insurance coverage in New Berlin, Wisconsin, tailoring policies to protect personal belongings and liability. Commercial renters insurance is also available for local businesses leasing space. Service extends throughout the New Berlin area and surrounding communities. Each policy is reviewed with the client to address specific needs and coverage gaps. The agent follows up after claims or policy changes and remains available for adjustments to coverage between regular visits, ensuring continued protection as circumstances evolve.

IA
17500 W Liberty Ln
Insurance Associates of America
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI

Insurance Associates of America in New Berlin, WI provides renters insurance agency services focused on protecting personal belongings and liability for local tenants. It offers policy options covering theft, fire, and water damage for apartment dwellers and homeowners who lease. The agency guides clients through claim filing procedures and helps adjust coverage limits based on inventory value. It can add on flood insurance to safeguard against sewer backup or rising water.

CS
15350 W National Ave Suite 119
Csedo-Stoeck Insurance Agency Inc
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI
(262) 785-9411
csedoinsurance.com
BG
16237 W Ryerson Rd Lower
Bernie Gonzalez Insurance Agency
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI
(262) 443-7831
berniegonzalezinsurance.com
WP
2665 S Moorland Rd #204
Wisconsin Preferred Ins Group
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI
(414) 698-6770
AS
17500 W Liberty Ln
Anderson's Insurance Associates
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI
(262) 789-8500
insurewithandersons.com
MI
17500 W Liberty Ln
Mader Insurance Services
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI
(262) 785-0563
maderins.com/contact-us
RM
16237 W Ryerson Rd
Rural Mutual Insurance Agent: Alex Fuentes
Renters Insurance Agent · New Berlin, WI
(414) 455-5542
ruralmutual.com/agent/alex-fuentes

What Does a a Renters Insurance Agent in New Berlin Cost?

In Wisconsin renters insurance typically costs 15 to 30 dollars per month for 30 000 dollars in personal property coverage and 100 000 dollars in liability coverage. Your actual rate may be higher or lower based on factors like your credit score location and chosen deductible. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About renters insurance agents in New Berlin

A renters insurance agent in New Berlin Wisconsin can help you find a policy that covers your personal property and liability. Wisconsin law does not require renters insurance but many landlords in New Berlin ask for proof of coverage. An agent can explain how local weather risks like hail or winter pipe bursts affect your policy needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a renters insurance agent in New Berlin do?

A renters insurance agent helps you compare policies from different companies to find coverage for your belongings and liability. They explain policy limits deductibles and exclusions specific to Wisconsin. They also assist with filing claims if you have a loss.

Do I need renters insurance in New Berlin Wisconsin?

Wisconsin state law does not require renters insurance. However most landlords in New Berlin require tenants to carry a policy as a lease condition. Having coverage protects your personal property from events like fire theft or water damage.

How much does renters insurance cost in New Berlin Wisconsin?

Typical renters insurance in Wisconsin costs between 15 and 30 dollars per month for standard coverage. The exact price depends on your coverage limits deductible and the value of your belongings. An agent can give you a specific quote based on your situation.

Renters Insurance Agents in Other Wisconsin Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each renters insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.