ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsOhio › Painesville

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Painesville, OH

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Painesville, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Painesville, Ohio is Kevin Kilfoyle - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 338 reviews. Other highly rated options include Cyrus Massoudi - State Farm Insurance Agent, Regency Insurance Agency, Makee Insurance Agency, Inc.. This directory lists 16 medicare insurance agents serving Painesville.

Showing 16 medicare insurance agents in Painesville, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Kevin Kilfoyle - State Farm Insurance Agent1655 Mentor Ave(440) 357-5231
2Cyrus Massoudi - State Farm Insurance Agent8 N State St Ste 206(440) 357-1133
3Regency Insurance Agency1930 Mentor Ave(440) 266-8888
4Makee Insurance Agency, Inc.2190 N Ridge Rd(440) 354-4030
5Boergert Wright Insrnc Agency1 Victoria Square #130(440) 358-9001
6SeibertKeck Insurance Partners87 S St Clair St(440) 951-5875
7Huntington Insurance56 Liberty St(234) 204-4062
8Pollutro Rossley Insurance161 N State St(440) 352-2872
9Diversified Insurance Concepts10 W Erie St #202(440) 358-1221
10Buckman Insurance11585 Olde Stone Ct(440) 201-4960
KK
1655 Mentor Ave
Kevin Kilfoyle - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Kevin Kilfoyle - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Painesville, Ohio area and surrounding Lake County, specializing in Medicare insurance coverage for local seniors. The agency helps clients navigate the complexities of selecting appropriate medical coverage. They provide guidance on both Medicare Advantage plans and standalone Medicare Supplement policies, addressing individual health needs and budgets. The office also assists with Medicare Part D prescription drug plan options during annual enrollment periods, ensuring clients understand their choices.

CM
8 N State St Ste 206
Cyrus Massoudi - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Cyrus Massoudi - State Farm Insurance Agent in Painesville, OH, offers guidance on Medicare insurance plans, helping clients navigate enrollment and coverage options. The agency provides ongoing support for policy questions and plan adjustments throughout the year to match changing health needs. Assistance with understanding plan features and paperwork is available to ensure clear communication. Typical services cater to individual homeowners and those with single-family homes, as well as residents of apartments, retail businesses, and local restaurants in the area.

RI
1930 Mentor Ave
Regency Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Regency Insurance Agency assists homeowners and individuals in Painesville, Ohio, with their Medicare insurance needs, helping them navigate plan options such as Part D and Medicare Advantage. As a local agency, it focuses on explaining coverage details so clients can make informed decisions. The agency also serves residents in the surrounding communities of Lake County, including nearby Mentor and the greater Willoughby area.

MI
2190 N Ridge Rd
Makee Insurance Agency, Inc.
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Serving Painesville, Ohio, and the surrounding Lake County communities, Makee Insurance Agency, Inc. is a Medicare insurance agent specializing in plan enrollment for eligible residents. The agency handles Medicare Supplements, Advantage plans, and Part D prescription drug coverage to help clients navigate their healthcare options. It typically guides each client by reviewing their medical needs and budget, then comparing available plans to identify a suitable fit for their individual circumstances.

BW
1 Victoria Square #130
Boergert Wright Insrnc Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

A Medicare insurance agent can help with either a one-time plan selection or provide recurring annual reviews. Coverage options vary, including Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Part D drug plans. The agent explains the differences between Original Medicare and private plan alternatives in the local area. Services for clients in Painesville, OH, operate on an as-needed or scheduled appointment basis, depending on individual enrollment periods and health needs.

SI
87 S St Clair St
SeibertKeck Insurance Partners
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

SeibertKeck Insurance Partners serves residents in Painesville, Ohio, with Medicare insurance solutions, helping them navigate plan options for healthcare needs. The agency also provides commercial coverage for local businesses requiring group or supplemental employee benefits. Their service area extends throughout the surrounding Lake County region and nearby communities. After an initial enrollment consultation, the team remains available for ongoing assistance with plan changes, claims questions, or annual review appointments between regular Medicare visit cycles.

HI
56 Liberty St
Huntington Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

As the Annual Enrollment Period approaches each fall, many older adults in Painesville review their coverage needs. Huntington Insurance offers personalized guidance through Medicare's options, including plan comparisons and prescription drug coverage evaluations, without pressure tactics. Seniors benefit from an agent's familiarity with local healthcare providers and plans. The initial step in securing appropriate coverage for the upcoming year is a no-cost face-to-face assessment to review individual requirements.

PR
161 N State St
Pollutro Rossley Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Pollutro Rossley Insurance offers guidance on Medicare Advantage plans, Medicare Supplement policies, and Part D prescription drug coverage. It assists clients in Painesville and surrounding Lake County with comparing options to match their specific healthcare needs and budgets. The agency helps individuals navigate the complexities of initial enrollment periods and annual open enrollment. It also provides support during special enrollment periods triggered by life changes, such as relocating from out of state or losing employer-based coverage.

DI
10 W Erie St #202
Diversified Insurance Concepts
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Diversified Insurance Concepts helps individuals in Painesville and the surrounding area understand their options for health coverage during retirement. The agency places a strong emphasis on Medicare plans, including the supplemental coverage details often needed beyond Original Medicare. Agents work to answer client questions about enrollment periods and plan choices specific to Ohio. Their services extend to the local business community, assisting office staff, warehouse personnel, and food service workers in evaluating their benefits selections.

BI
11585 Olde Stone Ct
Buckman Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH

Buckman Insurance serves residents of Painesville, Ohio, as a medicare insurance agent. It also offers commercial coverage options to local businesses and individuals throughout the greater Lake County area. The agency guides clients through plan selections, including Medicare Advantage and supplement policies, with clear explanations of benefits. After an initial enrollment or annual review, the agent maintains contact to address questions or changes between regular December open enrollment periods, ensuring coverage remains aligned with healthcare needs as they evolve.

PI
7879 Auburn Rd Suite 1B
Professional Insurance Management
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 975-8800
proinsm.com
SS
372 Railroad St
Soto's Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 357-7686
FI
113 Main St Ste 207
Farmers Insurance - Kelley Stewart
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 354-4664
agents.farmers.com/oh/painesville/kelley-stewart
CI
161 N State St
Callender Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 354-9566
callenderins.com
NY
56 Liberty St # 200
New York Life
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 639-8096
vsc3.newyorklife.com
AR
50 W Erie St
Amos Rick Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Painesville, OH
(440) 354-5366

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Painesville Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Ohio typically do not charge you directly for their services. They are paid commissions by insurance companies, which are built into plan premiums. Some independent agents may charge a consultation fee of 50 to 200 dollars, but this is uncommon. Costs vary by case and plan type. This is general information, not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Painesville

Medicare insurance agents in Painesville, Ohio help residents navigate plan choices including Part D and Medicare Advantage. Ohio law requires agents to be licensed and disclose their compensation. Local agents understand Lake County healthcare options and can guide you through the annual enrollment period from October 15 to December 7.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the role of a Medicare insurance agent in Painesville?

A Medicare insurance agent helps you compare plans, enroll in coverage, and understand your options. They are licensed in Ohio and must follow state rules on marketing and disclosure. Agents do not work for the government but can explain both Original Medicare and private plans.

When can I enroll in Medicare in Painesville Ohio?

Your initial enrollment period starts three months before you turn 65 and ends three months after. Ohio also has a special enrollment period for those who lose employer coverage. The annual open enrollment runs from October 15 to December 7 each year.

Are there Ohio-specific rules for Medicare agents?

Yes, Ohio requires agents to complete annual training on Medicare products and to provide a scope of appointment form before discussing plan details. Agents must also follow state anti-fraud laws and cannot offer cash or gifts to induce enrollment.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.