ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: BeforeInsuranceUSA.com is an informational directory, not an insurance agency, broker, or licensed producer. We do not sell insurance or provide insurance advice. No agent-client relationship is created by using this site. Except where a listing is clearly marked Featured, no agent listed on this site has paid for their listing. Featured listings are paid advertisements. This is an advertisement.
HomeMedicare Insurance AgentsOhio › Lancaster

Find Medicare Insurance Agents Near You in Lancaster, OH

Browse medicare insurance agents serving Lancaster, Ohio. Updated 2026-07-14.

The top-rated medicare insurance agent in Lancaster, Ohio is Vonnie McDonald - State Farm Insurance Agent, rated 4.9 stars across 325 reviews. Other highly rated options include Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC, Bill Palmer Insurance Inc, Wentz Insurance Agency Inc. This directory lists 20 medicare insurance agents serving Lancaster.

Showing 20 medicare insurance agents in Lancaster, OHListings are displayed in no particular order and are not ranked. Order does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement.

Comparison

Top 10 listings
#NameAddressPhone
1Vonnie McDonald - State Farm Insurance Agent3036 Columbus-Lancaster Rd NW(740) 785-5650
2Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC804 W Fair Ave(740) 653-4339
3Bill Palmer Insurance Inc725 E Main St(740) 687-5733
4Wentz Insurance Agency Inc1601 E Main St(740) 653-5535
5Frear Insurance Services Inc343 E Main St(740) 653-1236
6Mitchell Insurance Agency1518 E Main St(740) 687-6258
7Tom Mertz Insurance345 E Main St(740) 687-1010
8Brightway Insurance, The Kaminsky Agency1424 Ety Pointe Dr NW(740) 654-7782
9Otto Insurance Group110 E Main St(740) 653-4004
10Clark Insurance414 E Main St # 100(740) 653-8623
VM
3036 Columbus-Lancaster Rd NW
Vonnie McDonald - State Farm Insurance Agent
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Vonnie McDonald - State Farm Insurance Agent serves the Lancaster, Ohio area, providing guidance on Medicare insurance options. The company helps individuals understand available coverage plans and enrollment periods. Clients receive assistance comparing different policy features and costs. The agent works to explain how Medicare coordinates with other health coverage. The office also handles annual plan reviews to ensure clients have suitable protection. Services include Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage plan selection assistance.

MI
804 W Fair Ave
Miller Insurance & Financial Group,LLC
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Miller Insurance & Financial Group, LLC provides Medicare insurance agent services to clients in Lancaster, Ohio. The company helps individuals understand their Medicare options and enroll in suitable plans. It offers assistance with annual plan reviews, ensuring clients stay informed about changing coverage and costs. Year-round support helps address questions or life changes that may affect benefits. Its clients include local residents, many of whom own single-family homes or live in apartment buildings. The firm also serves retired professionals and small business owners working in nearby retail shops and restaurants.

BP
725 E Main St
Bill Palmer Insurance Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Serving Lancaster homeowners and retirees, Bill Palmer Insurance Inc provides guidance on Medicare insurance plans. It helps clients navigate enrollment periods and compare Medicare Advantage, supplement, and Part D drug options. The agency explains coverage details in plain language, aiming to make the selection process straightforward for those entering retirement or seeking plan changes. Its local focus allows for personalized, face-to-face consultations. Bill Palmer Insurance Inc also covers clients in the nearby communities of Pickerington and Canal Winchester.

WI
1601 E Main St
Wentz Insurance Agency Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Serving Lancaster, Ohio, and the surrounding communities, Wentz Insurance Agency Inc works as a local medicare insurance agent, handling Medicare supplement plans and prescription drug coverage for eligible residents. The agency assists clients in understanding their health care options to make informed choices. For a typical job, it reviews a client's current medical needs and budget, then compares available plans to directly present the most suitable policy for their specific situation.

FI
343 E Main St
Frear Insurance Services Inc
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Frear Insurance Services Inc in Lancaster, OH distinguishes between annual enrollment periods for initial or changing Medicare plans and ongoing annual reviews to adjust coverage as needs evolve. The agency specializes in helping clients understand Part A hospital insurance, Part B medical coverage, Part C Advantage plans, and Part D prescription drug plans. Services are available on either a one-time consultation basis or a scheduled recurring schedule, allowing for annual plan evaluations or coverage updates as individual circumstances warrant.

MI
1518 E Main St
Mitchell Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Mitchell Insurance Agency provides Medicare plan comparisons and enrollment assistance, including prescription drug coverage and Medicare Advantage options. It serves residents in Lancaster, Ohio, by explaining plan details and coordinating enrollment periods. The agency helps with annual fall enrollment when beneficiaries evaluate or change their Part D and Advantage plans. It also assists clients navigating penalties for late Medicare sign-up following their initial enrollment window.

TM
345 E Main St
Tom Mertz Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

As a Medicare insurance agent, Tom Mertz Insurance helps individuals in Lancaster, Ohio, navigate their healthcare coverage options. The company specializes in assisting clients with Medicare Advantage plans, as well as standalone Part D prescription drug plans and Medicare Supplement policies. It also works with individuals who are retiring and transitioning from employer group coverage to Medicare. Its services are available to administrative offices, varied warehouse facilities, and local food service operations in the surrounding region.

BI
1424 Ety Pointe Dr NW
Brightway Insurance, The Kaminsky Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Brightway Insurance, The Kaminsky Agency in Lancaster, OH is known for guiding clients through Medicare plan options, including Part D prescription drug coverage and Medicare Advantage plans. This agency helps local residents compare supplemental policies designed to cover costs not included in Original Medicare. The firm serves individuals nearing eligibility and those seeking annual plan reviews. Its add-on specialty service is assistance with enrollment in Medicare Savings Programs for qualified beneficiaries.

OI
110 E Main St
Otto Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

As Lancaster residents review their coverage options ahead of the annual Medicare open enrollment period, Otto Insurance Group provides local guidance for those navigating plan changes. The agency focuses on matching clients with suitable Medicare Advantage, Part D, and supplement plans based on individual health needs and budgets. They serve the Fairfield County area by explaining complex coverage rules in a straightforward manner. A thorough needs assessment and review of current prescriptions begins the consultation process.

CI
414 E Main St # 100
Clark Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH

Clark Insurance serves the Lancaster, OH area by helping residents find suitable Medicare coverage to meet their individual healthcare needs. Their services extend to assisting local businesses with commercial insurance options throughout the surrounding region. The team provides clear guidance on plan features, enrollment periods, and potential cost savings. Clients can rely on knowledgeable support during annual enrollment and the ongoing follow-up and repeat service offered between regular visits to ensure their coverage continues to address changing health requirements.

SI
169 W Fair Ave B
Shelter Insurance - Jessica Wilkins
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 785-5025
shelterinsurance.com/CA/agent/JWILKINS
WS
1583 Victor Rd NW
Western & Southern Life
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-3210
westernsouthern.com/wslife/financial-representatives/offices/lancaster-oh-063-1
GI
711 W Fair Ave
Gibson Insurance Agency
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-7111
garygibsoninsurance.com
AF
2580 Elder Rd NE
Answers for Tomorrow Insurance Group
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(614) 900-9475
answerfortomorrow-insurancegrp.com
GI
503 Tarkiln Rd SE
Great Insurance Lancaster
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 309-1108
EI
402 S Broad St
Easy Insurance Co
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 309-3203
PI
4213 Westfall Rd SW
Priority Insurance Lancaster
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 872-7944
FI
118 W Mulberry St
Farmers Insurance - Mark Reynolds
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(614) 808-4730
agents.farmers.com/oh/lancaster/dawn-reynolds
WI
400 N Memorial Dr
Wichert Insurance
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 654-0532
wichert.com
MI
802 W Fair Ave
Miller Insurance & Financial: Heston Rita
Medicare Insurance Agent · Lancaster, OH
(740) 653-4339
millerinsuranceandfinancialgroup.com/about-our-agency/meet-our-team

What Does a a Medicare Insurance Agent in Lancaster Cost?

Medicare insurance agents in Ohio generally do not charge you directly for their services. Plan costs vary widely. Medicare Advantage plans may have $0 monthly premiums but include copays and deductibles. Medigap plans in Ohio typically cost between $100 and $300 per month depending on your age and health status. Part D prescription drug plans average around $35 to $70 per month. This is general information and not insurance advice.

About medicare insurance agents in Lancaster

Medicare insurance agents in Lancaster, Ohio help residents compare plans and enroll in coverage that fits their needs. Ohio law requires agents to be licensed by the Ohio Department of Insurance. Agents can assist with Medicare Advantage, Part D drug plans, and Medigap policies during the Annual Enrollment Period and Special Enrollment Periods.

Frequently Asked Questions

When can I enroll in Medicare in Lancaster Ohio?

Your Initial Enrollment Period starts three months before you turn 65 and lasts seven months. You can also make changes during the Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7 each year. Special Enrollment Periods may apply if you move or lose other coverage.

Do Medicare agents in Ohio charge fees for their help?

Most Medicare insurance agents in Ohio are paid by insurance companies through commissions. You typically do not pay a fee directly to the agent for their services. Always ask the agent about their compensation before working with them.

What is the difference between Medicare Advantage and Medigap in Ohio?

Medicare Advantage plans replace Original Medicare and often include drug coverage and extra benefits. Medigap plans work alongside Original Medicare to help pay out-of-pocket costs like deductibles and coinsurance. Ohio law guarantees Medigap access during your Medigap Open Enrollment Period.

Medicare Insurance Agents in Other Ohio Cities

Listings are compiled from publicly available information. Inclusion does not constitute endorsement. Verify each medicare insurance agent's credentials and current standing with your state Department of Insurance.